4 ms·
What's in a name? What you call "social media surveillance," others might call "open source intelligence." Interestingly, the same people might call the same th
by chatmasta 10y ago
What's in a name? What you call "social media surveillance," others might call "open source intelligence." Interestingly, the same people might call the same thing by different words, depending on whether they profit from it.
For fairness, here's a blog post by Brightplanet, one of the subjects of the OP, called "What is OSINT and how can your organization use it? [0]
Many of the same issues that came up in discussion of the recent OKCupid study [1] apply to this piece. I liked what AnhonyMuse wrote in reply to my comment: "people want to create a binary distinction between 'public' (meaning public domain, can be used for anything by anyone) and 'private' (meaning something known solely to a single individual), with no intermediary steps between them."
This point applies especially to people's feelings on "social media surveillance." To those most concerned about it, an easy argument exists: if you didn't want to be surveilled, why did you post it "publicly" on the Internet? The problem with this argument is that, as AnthonyMuse pointed out, people have different definitions, and therefore expectations, of what is public.
Personally, I think that "open source intelligence" or "social media surveillance," or whatever you want to call it, needs to become as mainstream as Google. Its power is only "creepy" or corruptible so long as only a few entities can wield it. Surveillance in the hands of a few is dangerous; surveillance in the hands of many is powerful. When everyone has the power to spy on everybody else, then everyone must correctly calibrate their "expectations" for what is public and what is not. If you know that some percentage of your friends on social media are using "surveillance" tools, then you'll be more careful about what you post, because you will understand the true meaning of "public." Whereas if all the surveillance continues to happen in secret, you will continue to post recklessly, blissfully unaware of just how "public" your posts are.
We need to democratize open source intelligence in order to balance the power between those who currently hold it and those who don't. Why should the NSA have all the fun?
Will the "next Google" be a company that indexes the "deep web" [2] and provides a search engine for it?
[0] https://brightplanet.com/2013/04/what-is-osint-and-how-can-your-organization-use-it/ https://brightplanet.com/2013/04/what-is-osint-and-how-can-y...
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11705677 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11705677
[2] Deep web meaning pages behind paywalls or requiring registration. Not Tor.
P.S. I feel the same way about propaganda. Why should government agencies be the only ones with the power to propagandize their message? Everyone should have access to top-of-the-line shilling software!
- hellbanner 10y agoOpen-source shilling software would be interesting (and hilarious in a dark way). But most every day people don't have the resources to pay for marketing & servers to run massive operations.
- samstave 10y agoAre you familiar with this: https://search.wikileaks.org/gifiles/?viewemailid=289655 https://search.wikileaks.org/gifiles/?viewemailid=289655
- hellbanner 10y agoNo, what exactly am I looking at ?
- samstave 10y agoReddit founder trying to sell social manipulation services to the government
- hellbanner 10y agoOh, that's amazing.
- xyzzy123 10y agoI agree; but the value in these tools is very transient based on cat-and-mouse. For precisely this reason they become useless when open-sourced. And on the other hand it's not like they're great works of art. They're weekend hacks driving a rest API or phantomjs. Most of the "art" is threading or concurrency and getting it all to go over a 4K line "free proxy" list without falling over too badly. Want 10k Twitter accounts? It's not magic. It's just some dumb scripts and a bit of patience. You don't need massive server power (a $5 droplet will do fine) but you do have to have a bunch of time to waste.
- 10y ago