4 ms·
Instead of giving all kids free lunches, why not just have everyone scan/swipe their ID, those of means get charged, those who qualify either don't get charged
by mc32 11y ago
Instead of giving all kids free lunches, why not just have everyone scan/swipe their ID, those of means get charged, those who qualify either don't get charged or the tally gets cleaned at the end of the year?
- protomyth 11y agoBecause the equipment / procedures cost more than just giving everyone lunches. Also, the people with means are probably the ones paying the majority of the school's taxes so they might as well give their kids lunch too.
- gohrt 11y agonon-parents pay taxes too, so your proposal does shift more of the burden from students (even wealthy students) to general population.
- protomyth 11y ago"non-parents pay taxes too" - yep, all taxpayers pay for education. Its not my "proposal". Its how I have heard some school districts talk about their school lunch programs. I'm answering a question not advocating some opinion.
- tropo 11y agoThe kids who most need the free lunches are most likely to lose the ID. (and books, and pencils, and...)
- toomuchtodo 11y agoLunches are so cheap (a little under $3/lunch [1]), we might as well just give them away for free to all school age children. For some of them, its the only real meal of the day they'll see. [1] https://schoolnutrition.org/AboutSchoolMeals/SchoolMealTrendsStats/#5 https://schoolnutrition.org/AboutSchoolMeals/SchoolMealTrend...
- rayiner 11y agoWe should give them breakfast and dinner too.
- Spivak 11y agoSarcasm is difficult to convey over the text so I'm not sure if you're serious, but you should be if you aren't. Forget about morality, ethics, or any of that think of the children bullshit, paying the cost of about $2.50-$5/student/day is downright cheap for the returns we get down the line: from not having to pay to fix the medical problems they acquired as kids from malnourishment or shitty TV dinners, the welfare they wont be collecting because their grades are better, the reduction in crime, the increase in GDP, etc.. It's a really small thing, but it really does keep poor kids from getting stuck on the C student/underachiever track when their parent's get a break an don't have to worry about food. Source: This is one of the programs the local food bank I volunteer at does for poor families in the city.
- rayiner 11y agoI'm absolutely serious.
- ap3 11y agoHave you seen school food? I have been to my kids school during lunch - so much wasted food it's incredible. Please dom't waste more money on that. I can see myself voting for this only if I owned the local food company.
- dctoedt 11y ago> so much wasted food it's incredible The incremental social ROI of feeding three meals is very likely to be far greater than the cost of wasted food. Or: Let's optimize for child-development outcomes and not for food usage.
- flubert 11y agoBreakfast is already covered: http://www.fns.usda.gov/sbp/school-breakfast-program-sbp http://www.fns.usda.gov/sbp/school-breakfast-program-sbp
- Houshalter 11y agoIn my school everyone had to memorize a PIN number. How else do they know who gets free lunches or not?
- ams6110 11y agoWhen I was in school you paid cash or had a free lunch card. So it was very obvious who was on free lunch. My kids have used PIN numbers since they started school going back over 12 years.