5 ms·
The average Chinese person's life, and China's position in the world, has improved tremendously under the Communist government. This is basic fact, not propagan
by mikeash 11y ago
The average Chinese person's life, and China's position in the world, has improved tremendously under the Communist government. This is basic fact, not propaganda.
All I'm saying is that part of the acceptance or even favor the typical Chinese person feels towards their government is because of this actual factual improvement.
I'm not sure what you find problematic here. Do you disagree with the existence of this vast improvement in people's lives? Do you agree with it, but think it somehow plays no part in people's opinions of the government?
- okc 11y agoWell, which came first, the government or peoples views on it. When people can't openly express dissatisfaction and are censored and are subject to organised propaganda, then it's very hard to say. Under the communist government peoples lives haven't improved: look at the great famine. So yes I disagree peoples lives have not improved because of communism in China. You ask me to pick which era of government I would like to be under. But its all the same government using propaganda the same way. So what if it is now improving the vast amount of peoples lives. What about the minority being tortued by it? My conversations with Chinese people don't show a favour with the current government. But that's not much of an indicator, under the great famine, their was probably even more vast support for the Government. That's the nature of propaganda. You say China has improved under communism. Think what it could have achieved without it. Or look back even further at what it achieved as an empire. The average Chinese persons life has improved from an absolutely horrific existence under communism to a slightly better one - might be more like what your saying. As I said before, it's the same party as always. Until propaganda is removed and freedom of speech installed, public opinion is far from fact and the average Chinese persons quality of life is as much fiction as it is belief.
- mikeash 11y agoI don't understand what you mean by "it's all the same government." If you were being oppressed and murdered and starved in 1940, it wasn't the Communist government, it was probably the Japanese Empire. In 1900 it was the old imperial government. In between you probably had the chance to be oppressed and murdered and starved by the Republic of China, who are now the government of Taiwan. I'm not defending the Chinese government nor am I denying the role that propaganda plays in shaping public opinion there (as it does everywhere). But it is not only propaganda which does this. Life in China is much better compared to how it was in 1949, and part of the public's view of the government is due to that.
- okc 11y agoThe view that life is better is meaningless if you mean its better than mass death and torture. Portraying life as better now, is propaganda. Its a view that affirms the current government policies (even if you don't personally believe it). Propaganda is very unique in China and communism. Mainly because it is unified, enforced, systematic and backed up with violence. The communist party have been in rule so long that they are experts in it and social engineering. Taking any view on what the public think of its goverment, ain't easy or factual. It fraught in one of the most organised regimes of properganda in existence today. You can't compare that to America, where you can openly disagree with the government. Without fear of imprisonment in a work camp without trial. Basically when you say things like life is better because peoples positive views support it - I hear nothing but the torture and oppression which supports that state. And that ain't improvement. Its propaganda and control.
- tps5 11y agoHe's saying that life is better in concrete ways. Life expectency is higher. Medicine is more available. Wages are higher. Quality of life is higher. Less crime. More security. Those are concrete things. Can we measure them perfectly? No. But clearly things have improved in China over the past 60 years...
- okc 11y agoSecurity and crime: Doublespeak. Wages and medicine: actually more inequality than ever. Life expectancy: scraping the barrel. These aren't concrete things. If they were we could, like you say, measure them properly. But even in the best conditions your anlysis would be linking your values to your methods. My point: measuring stuff like this in a 60 year old regime based on self perpetuation and social control is not improvement its indoctrination. For example: are wages higher by mean, mode or median. Or more simply does less crime measure the improvement of a country. I can think of several pertinent examples of regimes and dictators who were quite sucsesfull with crime. Higher life expectancy.. Well that's quite an easy one to improve when you stop starving everyone. I'm not saying all my points are 100% kosher. I'm saying improvement is a very subjective term reaking of contradiction when not simplified or taken out of context.