5 ms·
I've heard that many CDNs are still lagging to adopt DASH, and it causes a major problem for any service which wants to implement HTML5 video (DASH + Media Sour
by shmerl 11y ago
I've heard that many CDNs are still lagging to adopt DASH, and it causes a major problem for any service which wants to implement HTML5 video (DASH + Media Source Extensions). How does it work for Youtube, do they simply run their own CDN?
> DRM is a hugely important part of the online video workflow
I agree to other commenters here who pointed the nonsense of this. DRM is not an important part of the workflow. It's a tool of corrupted groups for standards poisoning, market control and "creative" undemocratic lawmaking.
- nacs 11y ago> Youtube, do they simply run their own CDN Yes, the Google CDN (Google owns Youtube).
- shmerl 11y agoSo why don't other CDNs support DASH?
- eonw 11y agountil it is widely used and supported, there is a big cost to adding features to a CDN. the means dont justify the ends.
- shmerl 11y agoAnd how is it supposed to be used if CDNs don't support it? Sounds like a circular dependency to me. Technology is here, but without infrastructure it's close to impossible to use at scale.
- supergreg 11y agoYou cut flash out and then the need to support it pops up.
- shmerl 11y agoCatch 22. To cut Flash out you need to use DASH + MSE. You come to CDN and say you need it, and they say they don't support it because you first need to use it... Google worked around it by rolling out their own CDN. Do you propose to do the same?
- Veratyr 11y agoMaybe I'm naïve or not seeing something here but DASH looks like something you can do by storing a couple of files somewhere and setting a MIME type [0]? What's special about DASH that CDNs need to specially support it? Or are you talking about services that handle transcoding video and such as well? [0]: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/DASH_Adaptive_Streaming_for_HTML_5_Video https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/DASH_Adapt...
- shmerl 11y agoFrom what I understood, CDN is needed to lift the heavy load from the source servers. Without them you'd be hammered by heavy traffic, and not only that, the route to the end user will be most likely longer. DASH is adaptive streaming, and as such, when you select some stream from the client, CDN should support that in their infrastructure (including codecs and etc.). I don't know the details exactly, but it's far from trivial. May be someone can explain what the difficulty is in detail. Currently CDNs support HLS and Adobe's adaptive streaming, both of which aren't open standards and aren't part of HTML5 video. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adaptive_bitrate_streaming#Adobe_HTTP_Dynamic_Streaming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adaptive_bitrate_streaming#Ado... Without DASH support in CDN, you can't scale your service, and to get rid of Flash and Adobe's adaptive streaming you need DASH + MSE. That's how I understood it at least.
- Veratyr 11y ago> CDN should support that in their infrastructure (including codecs and etc.) This makes sense if the CDN is transcoding the video for you but if you do that yourself I don't think a special CDN is necessary. From Mozilla [0]: > DASH works via HTTP, so as long as your HTTP server supports byte range requests, and it's set up to serve .mpd files with mimetype="application/dash+xml", then you're all set. And from encoding.com [1]: > To play the content, the DASH client first obtains the MPD. The MPD can be delivered using HTTP [...] > Using this information, the DASH client selects the appropriate encoded alternative and starts streaming the content by fetching the segments using HTTP GET requests. This definitely sounds like it doesn't need any special support from the server. As long as it can serve files over HTTP, the only special thing is the transcoding and setting up the manifest, which doesn't need to be done by the CDN. I have a feeling CDNs advertise support for HLS and Adobe's streaming because they require additional support. [0]: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/DASH_Adaptive_Streaming_for_HTML_5_Video https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/DASH_Adapt... [1]: https://www.encoding.com/mpeg-dash/ https://www.encoding.com/mpeg-dash/