3 ms·
While no doubt terrifying, the actual procedures and interrogation methods here are little different than in western nations. US agents are free to grab people
by sandworm101 11y ago
While no doubt terrifying, the actual procedures and interrogation methods here are little different than in western nations. US agents are free to grab people as the leave the country. And 10 hours is nothing. A US court won't think anything of a detention lasting less than 24 hours. Even the questioning seems to follow standard law enforcement procedure, with teams of age-diverse interrogators being rotated in and out periodically. So while I have great respect for Rupert Wingfield-Hayes and will continue to do so, he should talk to those who have been detained at other airports on similar accusations.
North Korea surely has a more dramatic penal system, a deadly one. But as this reporter feared the labour camp, those at US airports faced with FBI agents accusing them of terrorism see Gitmo and the black sites.
- unwind 11y agoHuh? Are you not aware that the US has capital punishment as well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_the_Unit...? Or did you mean that the NK one is "more" deadly?
- sandworm101 11y agoThe chances of death on any given day in US detention are small in comparison to detention in North Korea. A person would probably last longer on US death row (10+ years) than in a NK labor camp. So despite the US love of the death penalty, it;s the far less deadly.
- garrettgrimsley 11y agoWhile that may be the case for citizens of the DPRK the story it is certainly not true for Americans who visit. They are charged and arrested for their crimes, sentenced to a decade or more in prison, and then released and deported within a year or two. It's a story that we've seen play out many times: Kenneth Bae, Matthew Todd Miller, Laura Ling, Euna Lee, Merrill Newman, etc. Nothing new nor interesting, must be a slow news day.
- dominotw 11y agoAmerican prisoners are teated like a royalty and not sent to prison camps with NK citizens. You can read more about this in Kenneth Bae's book 'Not Forgotten: The True Story of My Imprisonment in North Korea' that he earlier this month.
- GavinMcG 11y agoUse the Principle of Charity next time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity
- tptacek 11y agoIt is not in fact normal in Western nations to be detained at the border and threatened with a month's additional detention for writing that the nation's people have the voices of dogs or ugly faces. Be careful about false equivalence. Every Western nation does, or has recently done, many bad things. Perhaps the US has done more bad things than most. But none of them are comparable to North Korea. This rhetorical point-scoring is so old it has several names; "tu quoque" is a formal one, but the more evocative of them is "And you are lynching Negroes".
- sandworm101 11y agoReally. Talk to someone who has gone through a terrorism-related interrogation. Interrogators do not have to tell the truth. They do threaten to lock you up for life. They do threaten to involve your family. The fact that those threats lack legal teeth doesn't matter for the hours you are in that room being threatened. Often they know nothing about why you were detained and are tasked simply with squeezing out your entire life history. So questions often appear random and illogical. It's a very scary experience. (Talk to Muslim travellers first detained at US airports, not soldiers who think a security clearance interview qualifies as interrogation.)
- garrettgrimsley 11y agoNo one claimed that it is normal to be detained for insults in Western nations, you're the only one arguing that point. Parent comment specifically mentioned terrorism accusations in the context of treatment that Hayes experienced and the fears he envisioned. Had they said that all travelers to the US have fears of being held on terrorism charges then you would have a point, but they didn't. It was limited to how people already accused of terrorism are treated [0] and what fears they have, not travelers in general. >Perhaps the US has done more bad things than most. But none of them are comparable to North Korea. Playing that game won't be productive. [0] https://varnull.adityamukerjee.net/2013/08/22/dont-fly-during-ramadan/ https://varnull.adityamukerjee.net/2013/08/22/dont-fly-durin...
- teh_klev 11y agoSorry Thomas, but the reason I have never revisited the US is because during a flight from London to Auckland our plane had a refuel stop in LA. Technically we hadn't entered the USA but somehow it was acceptable for the TSA or border agents to treat us as potential terrorist suspects. We were marched around the holding area like cattle and suspects to have our fingerprints and retinas scanned. It was truly awful experience. I certainly won't ever be visiting your country again.
- sandworm101 11y agoI don't like replying to myself, but was this guy even handcuffed? US agents normally cuff/tie suspects to chairs/tables and the like, especially during transport. That's a very scary thing for the average person. NK seems to have allowed him slightly more dignity than the average US airport detention.
- garrettgrimsley 11y agoWe can tell that he was not handcuffed because the article lacks a paragraph or two describing how a brutish guard (also named Kim) forced cold shackles tightly around his wrists.