8 ms·
Japan: It's Not Funny Anymore
- scorciapino 17y ago> if a guy doesn't want to go to a party and get terribly drunk with everyone else in the company, then he obviously has some element of his outside life — a girlfriend, a hobby, et cetera — that is more important to him than the company god...
- wallflower 17y agoI'm eagerly awaiting patio11's comments on the smoking/meat/Sararīman culture.
- mootothemax 17y agoWow, this guy sounds like a lot of fun!
- Estragon 17y agoYeah, that was 20,000 words of relentless positivity.
- houseabsolute 17y agoYou are completely justified in complaining about the article's negativity. It's not like he announced in the title or the first paragraph what it was going to be about.
- houseabsolute 17y agoI come to HN for the intelligent, relevant commentary. I stay for the ad hominem.
- chaosmachine 17y ago"When you buy Super Famicom games in used game shops, the gray plastic is very often stained deep, ugly yellow from existing in houses packed to bursting with cigarette smoke. Sometimes, the consoles themselves are so yellow." That's actually due to the plastic used, it's not from smoke. http://vintagecomputing.com/index.php/archives/189 http://vintagecomputing.com/index.php/archives/189
- dazzawazza 17y agoThe plastic goes yellow but there is often a film of brown sludge that stinks of cigarettes... it's not pleasant.
- 83457 17y agoReminds me of the time I bought a used Dreamcast at GameStop and it had a disc all scratched to hell in it and reeked of pot. Actually looked and smelled like someone cleaned their pipe and dumped it in the system.
- weeksie 17y agoI can't imagine living in Japan as a vegetarian teetotaler. There's nothing wrong with that lifestyle but, man, pick your battles. Those things—the working, drinking, and meat eating—are part of the culture and it's not exactly a well kept secret. I know that I love booze and meat so I'm not going to relocate to Bangalore any time soon.
- hsuresh 17y agoMight not be a bad idea to relocate to Bangalore. It is the so-called Pub capital of India.
- weeksie 17y agoMate, I've been to Bangalore and while there are more bars than elsewhere in India it's a far cry from, say, New York where I'm living in alcohol sodden bliss ;)
- blogimus 17y agoAdd nonsmoker to the list.
- rjurney 17y agoYou can get by fine as a meat eating drinker in Bangalore - although the bars are a bit depressing :)
- yashodhan 17y agoThe author comes across as a whiney and effeminate control freak. Japan has it right; meat is awesome. 80's music is awesome. The liberty to choose what drugs you inject into your body is again, awesome. Seems like he would fit well with hipsters in NYC or SF. Apologize for the condescension but he just rubbed my the wrong way. I suggest he chills out and learns to go with the flow sometimes. But happiness is probably the last thing this guy wants, he's the type of guy who thrives on finding things at fault.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"I know that I love booze and meat so I'm not going to relocate to Bangalore any time soon." Plenty of Booze and meat in Bangalore. Good Pubs, not so much.
- ErrantX 17y agoThe problem with anime and animation becoming dumbed down and trashy is a global one. (incidentally did anyone else struggle to read the start of this article - it didnt flow very well)
- glhaynes 17y agoThe whole thing seemed amateurishly written. Left me thinking: does Kotaku not have editors? Why did he suddenly directly address the reader as "man" three times in one paragraph? Why did paragraphs seem rambly and disconnected? If one's going to take the "asshole" tone, one needs to be likable or at least amusing... maybe the author should read some Bukowski.
- jmillikin 17y agoLong ago, manga aspired to be like Dragon Ball Z: graphically iconic, with a story more coherent than it probably needed to be. Now there's the ADHD-addled Dragon-Ball-Z-inspired One Piece, a manga for the Twitter age if there ever was one. Pop culture was best when you, the reader of this sentence, were 12: http://i46.tinypic.com/1625ims.gif http://i46.tinypic.com/1625ims.gif I remember watching DBZ after school, and while it is certainly "graphically iconic", there is no legitimate way to claim it has a coherent plot. It seems like the author is remembering his Saturday morning cartoons through some rose-tinted cokebottles. I won't even touch "Anime is terrible. It used to be okay."
- jayair 17y agoReading the article I felt that just like how he is comparing current Anime to DBZ (what he remembers) is the same way he is comparing his current feeling towards Japanese culture to what he thought it would be. It feels like reality has settled in and his daily life has some deeper rooted problems than the stickers being placed on the barcode a certain a way. Regardless he gives a view of the culture that you don't often hear about.
- xenophanes 17y agoWhat are you talking about? They have, e.g., 30 eps in a row of goku fighting frieza. it's an extremely slow plot, but every episode follows after the next. (except after a saga ends, then they just do a time skip to the next big fight)
- itistoday 17y agoMan does this bring back memories from back when I was still a young hackling... Watching in eager anticipation what will happen next. For four straight episodes it was Goku with his hands in the air constipating, and somehow I loved every minute of it.
- camccann 17y agoconstipating That is not a word that should ever exist... yet I cannot imagine a better description.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoGood article, but about 3 or 4 times longer than it should have been.
- cmelbye 17y agoDid anyone actually read this novel?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoStarted out reading, then scanning, finally skimming for section heads and interesting topics. The problem is that the author didn't make a cogent point and back it up. Instead he started off with a lot of excuse-making, then went into a list, but kept deviating from the list to talk about video games (which, I guess, should have been the topic?) It had the feeling of a long list of grievances strewn together, ranted about, and then tacked on to a couple of other conversations. The strength of the article was in the negative first-person impressions of Japanese culture. He should have stuck with that, cut out the apologizing and made that just a sentence or two at the end. Then he should have tightened the hell out of the prose and tried to make some kind of thesis that his stories supported. Other that that, the first-person stuff was good. But damn -- this guy is an editor? The structure is a mess. At one point he even admits how bad it is -- and then continues on in the death march towards the end.
- ErrantX 17y agothis guy is an editor? The structure is a mess. Aha it makes a little more sense now. Editors are usually poor writers/reporters - their skill set is different (which doesn't excuse the fact he clearly never copy-edited what he wrote)
- Alex3917 17y agoI read the whole thing and I actually liked the style. It's not like he's randomly reviewing video games in the middle of the article, he's using his examples of things he finds stupid to show how the arbitrary and nonsensical social conventions contribute to a lack of creativity in Japanese business.
- Tichy 17y agoHaven't finished yet, but I find it a surprisingly entertaining read.
- DannoHung 17y agoTim Rogers is a nutjob. But he's got a few interesting points buried in there regarding language.
- Groxx 17y agoOnly barely. English has plenty of similarly complicated words that are used frequently without people understanding their meaning. Learning about those meanings puts a bit of a shade on what people are actually saying, until you realize people don't actually mean it that way. It's the same way with irrashaimase; it's a self-deprecating phrase (and Japanese does indeed have a lot of them), but it's a stock phrase, and that's how people use it. Similarly, a lot of our exclamations have origins in words, even if we've forgotten them. For instance, why do we say "ow" instead of "ai", or simply "aa"? "Ow" is significantly more complicated physically than simply "aa!"ing. Other cultures say different things for exclamations, even "spontaneous" things like pain, and that's normal. Getting uppity about it isn't.
- DannoHung 17y agoI don't think that's a particularly good example unless you say "ow" in some very strange way.
- houseabsolute 17y agoWait, your example from English is completely unrelated to Tim's point, which is that they use words with some meaning that may not apply to the current circumstances. Tim's argument is that that imposes a subliminal message, which, repeated often and widely enough, has a negative effect on the society. Maybe you have some argument against that, but you didn't make it in this comment.
- gcv 17y agoI only read about half that article before losing interest, but one argument jumped out at me: the mandatory office parties and drinking outings. This, IMO, is not a Japan-only phenomenon, although I'm sure the Japanese put their own cultural twists on this lovely concept. After college, I went to work in a bank in New York. The in-crowd in my group went out for drinks, together, at least three times a week. I never saw any appeal in $10 martinis or $6 beers — especially with a bunch of people with whom I just spent 10 working hours. Needless to say, it did not take long before I was considered "not a team player." (My bosses liked me, so I did well enough before I realized I loathe corporate life and left, but my peers were not fans and caused considerable trouble.)
- rick888 17y ago"I only read about half that article before losing interest, but one argument jumped out at me: the mandatory office parties and drinking outings. This, IMO, is not a Japan-only phenomenon, although I'm sure the Japanese put their own cultural twists on this lovely concept." You are right about this. Pretty much any place I have worked (I'm from the US) has had office parties or other kind of outings. I almost always went because it does help you get to know your boss and co-workers (it was only about once-a-month). I don't really see a problem with it. Your example of going out three times a week is a bit much (I wouldn't go out that many times a week), but you could have at least gone out with them once-in-awhile to show them that you don't completely hate your co-workers. If you do, you probably shouldn't be working there anyway. You can't take the human nature/social aspect out of working. If you don't do these things, people will think you are weird/the outsider/don't like them. Maybe you should run your own business?
- plinkplonk 17y ago" I almost always went because it does help you get to know your boss and co-workers (it was only about once-a-month). I don't really see a problem with it." I made it a point never to go for one after my first experience. In Bangalore these take weird forms, usually wasting a holiday or a weekend, landing up in some god forsaken "resort", where you can do exciting things like play badminton or carroms, Quoits or Dumb Charades (I kid you not!), or quietly get drunk in a corner, with some of the really bad companies throwing in a few "mission and vision" style speeches from the powers that be. Once I got a letter from a VP telling me to report to his office and explain why I didn't attend the "office party weekend + mission and vision session" over the previous weekend and I explained (quite diplomatically) that I didn't give a fuck about these things and had no intention of ever attending anything like this in the future either. He seemed completely shocked and speechless and was almost in tears when I left. My immediate superior later gave me a veiled warning that my " career progress could be affected" by such "unorthodox attitudes" but, strangely enough, it wasn't. I got regular promotions and raises and was "on the leadership track" when I left because work was too boring. They didn't believe my reason for leaving either ("I am bored out of my skull"), because I was a "senior person" (I was 28!!) and was "poised on the leadership ladder" (yes they actually spoke like that!). These were large companies though. Small (less than 20 people) company parties were often a lot of fun. I am so glad I don't have to work for large companies anymore.
- froo 17y agotl;dr edit - that's not entirely true, I got about 1/10th of the way through and realised I could do more constructive things with my time.
- cookiecaper 17y agoI think this is the kind of article that you scroll through until you find a paragraph with some interesting words, read until you get bored, and do that again until the end.
- Agile_Cyborg 17y agoLife would be an excruciating slog if I had enough time to write a fucking novel about the things I hate in a place I chose to live.
- Groxx 17y agoI hadn't considered the meat part before, but he's right, nearly everything has meat in it. USA is getting pretty vegetarian-friendly, Japan not so much. As to the other complaints: rose-tinted glasses looking back to "the good old days", plus a bit of culture shock. It's a frickin' different culture, of course you're not going to understand / go along with it perfectly. I'll fully grant that some of the cultural habits are downright dangerous (not merely creepy), but every culture has that. Sounds like he's merely found out recently that Japan isn't some holy grail location like he seems to have thought it was, and is merely a location on Earth.
- jmoiron 17y agoI'm actually very surprised this ended up here. For those who might not know Tim Rogers, him and a few other college-age gamers started a recently defunct site called 'insert credit' around 8 or 9 years ago to try to apply Hunter S. Thompson style "New Journalism" to video game journalism. Their articles had a high incident of insight to them that was largely the result of repeated deconstruction and re-examination of the game design of various 80s-era classics. Quite often the articles (some of which read a lot like the linked article) were pretty entertaining. Bringing personal experience into the essay or game review was always the point, and Tim in particular tended to go off on completely wild tangents and write in an almost incoherent and stream of consciousness style (perhaps, "style"); from memory, in one review he pauses to go cook a burrito, then describes the burrito cooking process, before resuming what he was writing about the actual game in question. This article is pretty classic Tim Rogers: an extremely long exploration of an idea that touches on some interesting (if perhaps apocryphal) stories or facets of that idea, but may or may not have a coherent underlying vision or message.
- cookiecaper 17y agoI've always admired the writing on Insert Credit, and I'm sad to learn that they're gone now.
- thristian 17y agoAfter Insert Credit imploded, the forums moved to selectbutton.net but without any "main content" (the front-page stories are just selected forum threads). Soon afterward, Tim started up actionbutton.net to host game reviews by himself and other like-minded folks; they're generally just as good as the old Insert Credit material, and of course more up-to-date.
- jmoiron 17y agoI've found actionbutton to be a step below the old reviews, perhaps for similar reasons that Tim now finds his honeymoon in Japan souring. The reviews there tend to be a lot more about being entertaining than enlightening, and their stated goal of having the average score being 1/4 stars has been thrown to the wayside. I also don't really play games anymore. There are a few potentially "important" things that I hope escapes IC and its graduates and becomes more mainstream. Reviews that explain the context of their creation, and reviews that examine the philosophy of the game design. Unfortunately these are hard, require work, and don't look any better on the glossy page. Some examples: Rogers wrote a fantastic review[1] of Romancing Saga: Minstrel Song that starts off by chronicling the entire career of its designer (Kawazu) and reviewing some of his earlier games with depth and insight. There are clear patterns evident in his early games, which are then used to give context to and explain the current game under review. The second is probably my favorite video game review, which is of Windwaker by Eric-Jon Rossel Waugh[2]. EJRW is a better and more insightful (but less colorful) writer than Rogers, but perhaps not as colorful. He made an old forum post I distinctly remember lamenting the laziness of linear game design, which is something of a cliche. When challenged for an alternative, he backed it up with a very interesting review of the use of "danger" rather than contrivances like keys or inventory items as a limit on exploration in Dragon Quest/The Legend of Zelda. As for this particular posting of Tim's, I don't really have much more to comment. Like I said in my original comment, it's classic Tim Rogers, and it's hard to explain what "classic Tim Rogers" is without just pointing people to another 15-20 articles similar in construction and content. It feels odd to write about it in a familiar tone since I was largely a lurker at IC (as I am here). [1] http://www.largeprimenumbers.com/article.php?sid=saga http://www.largeprimenumbers.com/article.php?sid=saga [2] http://www.insertcredit.com/reviews/windwaker/windwaker1.html http://www.insertcredit.com/reviews/windwaker/windwaker1.htm...
- xiaoma 17y agoInsisting on a way of life completely at odds with where you live can be stressful. I'm kind of curious how he ended up deciding to live in Japan. I know wouldn't if I were a strict vegetarian, tee-totaling, non-conformist who didn't like anime, didn't like rigid company culture and couldn't even tolerate the existence of smoking sections at restaurants. It's almost as if he's drawn to frustration.
- rjurney 17y agoIn my experience, the way it works is - at first everything in the foreign culture is great. Its all novel, the language and culture, and every idiosyncrasy is fascinating and every difference is a new challenge. In time you adapt, and then things seem normal again and you enjoy participating according to the rules of the new society. Once you're 'over it' though, you come to realize just how much work you're putting in just to function. It becomes extremely tiresome just getting by, and many little things irritate you. It sounds like he's in this final stage. It sounds like its time to come home.
- xiaoma 17y agoI agree that a trip home might be a good idea in his case. There is another possible step for someone living abroad, though-- adaptation. It doesn't have to be any harder than it was at home. People can change. It's possible to adjust to one's surroundings on a deeper level, in a way such that daily life is no longer a struggle. I say this having the majority of my adult life living in a country far from where I grew up.
- GFischer 17y agoAnd what if you're tired and irritated... of your home country? I'm in my own mini-crisis myself, and I don't know what to do (emigrating is a bit drastic, but I'm considering it).
- techiferous 17y agoStart your own micronation! :)
- clusterfu_k 17y agoI'm rather surprised by this article, mostly because I basically have the opposite opinion about Japan. My theory is that I was born in Japan and lived there for most of my life and so for me this is all just how life works. More importantly, from a Japanese perspective, this is how we enjoy life. It externally seems that I should have a similar opinion of Japan as him because I am not Japanese and I seem to have had similar experiences. Yet my exposure to the culture from birth leaves me taking for granted a lot of what he fights. When I first came to Canada to study in university I had grudges toward the culture and way of life and I hadn't noticed until now why that was. It was because my perception of "how things work" was challenged.
- starkfist 17y agoI lived in Japan in the early 2000s. I don't know anything about anime or videogames, but everything else in the article seemed accurate. Personally I loved it, but I left before things started to wear me down. Much of this is a critique of salaryman culture. Salaryman culture is bananas, a bi-polar combination of Kafka-esque hallucinatory boredom during the day, and 'girls gone wild' at night. Except, it isn't girls going wild, it's 48 year old men. It's interesting for about 2 weeks, and then becomes completely tedious, and slightly scary if you care about your health at all. I'm astonished that the Japanese still top the life expectancy charts. When I wasn't working, I hung out with artists, skaters and surfers. I visited small towns on weekends and spent a lot of time at the beach. Life outside of Tokyo and the salaryman grind is much more relaxed, fun, and "good" weird instead of "WTF" weird. Whenever I have a friend interested in relocating to Japan I plead with them to NOT work at a Japanese office. Only go there to work if you're the best fixed-gear bike welder, or are a popular underground DJ, or some other sort of "big in japan" folk hero. Anything that keeps you out of salaryman-land.
- neilk 17y agoWhen it comes to entire countries, or even large cities, they usually have every possible lifestyle within them -- somewhere. It's never what you know about a place; it's who you know. You may have to make different choices though. It's probably possible to be a teetotalling vegetarian in Japan, but you might have to go to a monastery or something. Whereas you could easily be a games developer with those traits in the USA.
- nandemo 17y agoI couldn't make myself read the whole thing, but I think it's far from accurate. For instance, he seems to be able to communicate in Japanese but he still doesn't grasp that "otsukaresama" and "irasshaimase" are really only greetings. I wonder what would be his reaction if he heard that in some places it's usual to say "ohayou gozaimasu" (usually meaning "good morning") when you get to the office in the evening. Mandatory parties aren't really mandatory, you see. Many Japanese do "escape" the parties. You just have to do it tactfully. And so on. That said, I agree with you about avoiding working in a Japanese office. The usual English teaching path seems to work for a lot of people, though.
- bh23ha 17y agoThis poor person is suffering from culture shock. I'm an immigrant let me explain. Culture shock is not OMG they eat X here. Culture shock develops slowly from the stress of being away from home and living in a strange land. You are long over people eating X or what ever, and then one day you're just sick of it all. Not exactly ALL of it, but you tend to fixate on the defects of the strange place you're in and you're in a perpetually bad mood, very similar to the stressed out shitty mood someone quiting smoking is always in. Some of the points he makes are valid. There is lard in bread, I think that's MUCH better then the hydrogenated fats of margarine. Lard may not be good for you, but it is better then the alternatives. And smoking is definitely bad for you. And as an European I feel that American corporate culture bleeds far too far into everyone's personal life, much like how the author feels about corporate partying in Japan. The no-real friends thing also strikes me as something I can say about Americans, who from my perspective seem to have trouble forming deep adult friendships. But the author and I have two options, get over it or go home. The curious thing about culture shock is that it never strikes in the very first moments of awe when you just arrive. It takes a little while. But then you tend to get over it and then many months or some times years later it hits you again, and this time it is WORSE. And many immigrants/ex-pats never got over the second wave. They (we!) just end up pissed off at the host culture. * EVERY JAPANESE POP SONG IS ABOUT THE SAME THING * Yeah, that's kind of every pop song period. And this attitude is a classing sign of culture shock.
- intranation 17y agoCulture shock to me, as someone who has visited 20-ish countries and lived in 2, is more that "things are almost normal and like what you're used to, but just not enough to be comfortable", and as a result you end up perpetually on edge and perpetually adjusting just outside your comfort zone. It's jarring and difficult, a little like the room in Orwell's 1984 where the corners aren't quite straight, and things are just out of focus. I didn't get culture shock in Tokyo, because it's just so different to everywhere else I'd been that I completely stopped the usual comparisons and just gave up.
- prawn 17y agoA bit like a cultural uncanny valley. Sounds plausible to me.
- sailormoon 17y agoMan, this guy's list of reasons for hating Japan is pretty much identical to my list of reasons for loving Japan. Non-smoking, tee-totalling vegetarian? Sounds like a real fun guy. Got to hand it to him on the comedy shows, though, they're awful.
- MikeMacMan 17y agoOy, if I had a yen for every time a westerner made some off-base criticism that belied their understanding of Japanese language, Japanese culture, and Japanese psychology...
- cookiecaper 17y agoAre people really so harsh to non-drinkers? That's sad. What about people who don't drink for religious purposes? Are they better tolerated?
- archgoon 17y agoHuh. Suddenly, I wonder much more about what life is like for Ruby's Matz.
- cdavid 17y agoI can only relate to my own experience (6 years in Japan now), but I have never been in a position where I had to drink. I have never been in a very big Japanese corporate company, but in both University, gvt labs and start up, there have always been people who do not drink, and that has never been an issue.
- pwim 17y agoJapan is a very homogeneous society. Almost no one is religious here, so I think you'd still suffer if you don't drink because of religious reasons.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoMaybe I can sum up every little point I'm trying to make in this whole word-slab by saying I don't like that so many people agree to do things that they obviously hate doing. This seems like a great description of the meat-free, booze-free, non-comformist working for a big Japanese corporation. Why didn't he leave the country 19,000 words ago?
- andrewljohnson 17y agoSomeone should turn on the Patio11 signal and summon him to comment on this. 00000 0000000 000P11000 0000000 00000
- djcapelis 17y agoTimezones. It's still pretty early in the morning there for a hacker. I imagine he'll be along within the next hour or two.
- donw 17y agoI'm 'there'. It's way too early for a hacker, but just fine for a startup owner. :)
- dmoney 17y agoThe "Pat Signal" for short.
- ramchip 17y agoYou know, he's not the only HN reader in Japan... ;) I'm not sure what needs commenting. The article is quite in-depth and mostly fits with my experience. I can add an anecdote, perhaps, on this part: The Japanese are so serious about work that even work-related parties are mandatory. If you don't go to a company party, you're not part of the team. If you're not part of the team, it's possible you're not actually working at the company. This is very real. I live in a university dorm and I'm friend with one of the Japanese assistants working here. He was nearly fired because he wasn't going to nomikai (drinking parties) with the other assistants and the manager often enough. He wasn't going because he had to study for exams and prepare a trip. He got a long email from one of his older colleagues saying that "maybe he wasn't cut out for the residence assistant lifestyle" and that as the youngest one it was his duty to do better to fit in the group. All that even though he was, as far as I could see, the only one to actually socialize with the foreign residents (that's supposed to be his job)... Incidentally, my university keeps a fairly strict separation between foreign and local students. Exchange students live in the same building as the sports club members for my university (the teams are required to live together), but we're not allowed to go into their area or for them to come. People who learn Japanese here are rather encouraged to stay together and not mix with the Japanese students (except those who want to practice English). It's what they call tatemae/honne: the uni wants to give an air of internationalism, but it doesn't really matter to them if it's true or not - just that it looks like it. I'm in a way lucky to be in engineering, so that I take all my classes with local students, but I've had to deal with many exceptions and needed special permission from all teachers I take a lesson under. I'm literally the only undergrad exchange student on my campus. To their credit however, I've always felt welcomed by teachers - I feel like a few have travelled and actually wish their students were more exposed to other countries. I've also seen a professor say to his new undergrad students (unpaid interns) that "from now on, the laboratory lifestyle is going to be the main thing for you" (main in English). Life in Japan is defined by your group, and it mostly goes from school, to laboratory (or intern work), then to the company. At each point people are expected to dedicate a lot of time to being with their group.
- Rauchg 17y agoAnime is awesome.
- rglovejoy 17y agoAnime used to be awesome. For me, it stopped being cool sometime back in the late 1990s, when it went mainstream.
- petercooper 17y agoSo, a list of problems some dude has with a country. You can come up with a similar list for every country on earth, especially if you're suffering from culture shock. Everywhere has its pros and cons.
- brianmckenzie 17y agoI'm not sure who's funnier - the author or the people he's criticizing. It's like a mobius strip of confusion.
- askar_yu 17y agoCompletely agree that had it been short, it'd be much more interesting as there are a lot of people who have interest in Japan, and they would love to read about those experiences you have. I doubt that the author is in any of the 'cultural shock' phases, as he starts the article by saying " I've lived in Japan for a long time ". Nevertheless, anybody living in foreign country with a different culture faces the trade-off between preserving their previous 'ways-of-doing' (cultural values, ways of behaving under various circumstances, etc.) and adjusting to the new culture (thus, changing yourself to some extent). So the office culture of Japan only seems to be one of these instances in the case of the author, and it also confirms what I've known about Japan. <i> "Why not "Tim-san"? I'm required to put "san" on the end of their names. " </i> From what I've heard (I've never been to Japan), Japanese don't attach '-san' to foreigners names'. But I have to say, I liked this :) - <i> " - ... This is just how we do things in Japan, Tim. - Well, [Name-removed]-san, you can try putting 'san' on the end of my fucking name from now on, then, you know, as practice. " </i>
- houseabsolute 17y agoI am really disappointed in the HN commentary on this one. A quarter of the commenters seem to have stopped reading when they saw the anime criticism. Half came in here to say that the guy sounds boring. And the remainder is split between talking about patio11 (what the fuck is that?) and how long the article was. Most of the criticism here seems to boil down to the same "you're not Japanese" bullshit the author mentions in the piece itself. Is that really the best we can do? This is probably the worst-commented article I've seen since I started at HN. I agree with others that the anime point is probably off-target. Nostalgia is a big component of thinking things used to be better than they are. The insights into Japanese company-culture are fascinating. American corporations do make people do some incredible bullshit, but nothing on the level of the official greeting he mentioned. The standing around on the street thing and yelling is entirely odd. I also liked some of the points about the subliminal impact of self-deprecating language. From what I've read, and from the few movies I've seen that deal with Japanese culture, it _does_ seem like there's something about it that forces an distance between people that is hard to bridge. The host clubs and the separate master bedrooms are a fascinating symptom of this problem.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- Alex3917 17y ago"American corporations do make people do some incredible bullshit, but nothing on the level of the official greeting he mentioned." Wal-Mart makes their employees do this every morning, and they are the largest private employer in the US. IIRC there is footage of this is The High Cost of Low Prices. I agree with your comment in general though. This article should pretty much be required reading for everyone in the US, since at least to me it's pretty clear that in another 20 years life here is going to resemble either Idiocracy or Japan depending on your socio-economic status.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"Wal-Mart makes their employees do this every morning, and they are the largest private employer in the US. " On my way to my office here in Bangalore, I once saw a team do the "Walmart cheer" ("Give me a W" ...) in the lobby of another office in the same building. All the offices in the building were sw dev companies I am not sure if they had a sw dev team here or outsourced some stuff (probably the latter) but it was quite early in the morning and most of the people looked half asleep and the rest acutely embarrassed. I'd rather quit then take part in such nonsense. Starting every work day feeling like an idiot must be quite draining.
- kimfuh 17y agoJapan's quirkiness is what makes me love it so much. It's just so totally different. You can find normal anywhere.
- caffeine 17y agoHe should move back to the U.S. for a while. I bet he lasts two weeks before he's screaming for Chokukuro.
- barrkel 17y agoI was wondering what the difference between this "chocolate croissant" and a pain au chocolat was. (I have seen pains au chocolat described as chocolate croissants in the northern CA area.)
- donw 17y agoARTICLE SUMMARY: I'm a vegetarian non-smoker living in a country where nearly everybody smokes and all the native cusine has meat. I also don't like all the word-dancing involved in office-level Japanese, not to mention the office politics, and I especially can't stand the sheer pile of pointless (to me) social protocol. Because I don't participate in most of what the natives do, I've had a hard time making friends with said natives, and I'm lonely. There's nothing wrong with me, of course. This is Japan's fault, and they should fix themselves to be more like California. END ARTICLE SUMMARY Begin my take: I'm a native Californian, currently living in Tokyo. Admittedly, I'm not a vegetarian, but I don't smoke, and I agree that a lot of the stuff here can be maddeningly irritating... if you try and apply your own value systems. But you can't. It's a different country, they do things differently. If you try and fight that, for the most part, you're just going to end up bitter and frustrated. If you're going to live somewhere where the value systems are different, you need to figure out what you need to compromise on in order to keep both yourself and the natives happy. The one nice thing about being a foreigner, is that because you're a foreigner, you can get away with flaunting a lot of social protocol already. If you even make a solid attempt at observing social niceties, you can totally cock them up, and the Japanese will still be pretty happy that you bothered in the first place. Patio11-aka-Patrick, please feel to correct me where I'm wrong here. :)
- teyc 17y agowriter is suffering from ennui. Just like yoga - any single posture held over a long time becomes stressful.
- jason_tko 17y ago9 years in Japan. Whenever someone criticises Japan, I'm always reminded of a comment I heard years ago that stuck with me. "If Japan changed to be exactly what you want, you wouldn't have come here in the first place."
- mburney 17y agoThis article makes me want to move to Japan.
- kazuya 17y agoThe article is a bit amusing even for a native Japanese, but too lengthy for me to read it through. I happened to work at a big-business cubicle farm (or kind of) in Tokyo, but there is no such obligatory parties. I have heard of that kind of stories but they are almost caricaturized and exaggerated. If any, he was just unlucky about it. However I agree about smoking. That's so pervasive and annoying. But I found our situation better than some of south European countries, and smoking in public space is being illegalized. It's totally okay for him to moan as he likes, but of course, don't take it as he writes.
- gommm 17y agoFrom my friends working in the game industry in Kyoto, it doesn't surprise me that he had this kind of experience... But, yes, on my end, working in a small company in Kyoto, it was not as extreme. There were of course a few parties, but not much more than in Europe or the US... One thing though, when I first started work there, the thing that chocked me is that nobody left work at 7pm (our official work time was 10am to 7pm). They just kept on working as if being the first one out was a bad thing (and indeed I've had comments from my coworkers to that effect later on when I started to make an habit of leaving on time). For the rest of his rant, I understand where he's coming from and I've sometimes had the same criticisms as him. But now that I don't live in Japan anymore, I miss it and want to eventually move there again... Go figure :-)
- maxwin 17y agoIt is all about cultural relativity. This blogger grows up in Western culture so it is so natural for him to perceive things or norms that are different from his norms/culture as being weird. For example, he complained a lot about the Japanese greeting "You're tired". About how it doesn't make sense. However, to many Japanese, it is just a way of saying "hi". Dude, a Japanese coming to US will complain about the greeting "What's up" being so freaking weird and rude. Yeah, the sky is up!
- jrockway 17y agoYeah, Asia is different from the US. Different people, different cultural values. I went to high school in Japan for a year, so I disagree with some of the author's points. Nobody tried to isolate me from the "real" students, for example. Nobody really cared that I was different from them; there was too much other stuff to worry about (exams, extracurricular activities, etc.) I think a lot of people think that they are going to get special treatment for being white, and then don't, and then call it racism. (And admittedly, there is a little of that from normal people, and it is usually cleared up when you are able to explain your situation in Japanese. Same as any culture -- until you speak their language, you are considered retarded. We do it in the US, too.) Anyway, I know a lot of people in Japan that are software developers, and they opt out of the whole "salaryman" thing too. In the end, it's your choice how to spend your life. There is the easy path of least resistance, but if you don't like that, then you can do something else. Just like everywhere else in the world. The only thing I don't like about Japan is the political and criminal justice system. This is beginning to annoy Japanese people, too, though, so the era of their third-world criminal justice system is probably coming to an end. Maybe they will get rid of the rich career politicians too, although even the US can't figure that one out :) (Looks like they finally have the concept of a "trial by peers" now, although it's not quite like the common-law system. Better than "you're guilty because some judge thinks so", however.)
- c00p3r 17y agoJust one remark - "hostess club" in Kathmandu are called dance bars. Same idea - pay, talk and go away. Prices are ten times higher than on street. Juice will cost you 10 bucks. And a men returns to buy even more dreams. Lots of Indians, Germans (of course) and Russians. =)
- prewett 17y agoI'd recommend the book "Polite Fictions" to this guy. (I have a summary at http://www.physics.ohio-state.edu/~prewett/writings/BookReviews/PoliteFictions.html http://www.physics.ohio-state.edu/~prewett/writings/BookRevi...) I felt like I understand Japanese culture a lot better (the little bit I see from here in the U.S.) because of it.
- elblanco 17y agoFunny I was reading this while on a trip to Korea. Different country, but some of what he describes applies here as well. But my final thought was "really, he's a vegetarian and he picked Japan as his place to go?" I was talking this article over tonight with some friends over a bowl of Sujabi http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sujebi http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sujebi, which could be vegetarian-ish, but like most things in Asia, never really are. It had clams in it, and the broth was boiled out of cow bones or sardines or something. I've yet to encounter some food in East Asia that didn't have some kind of animal product in it.
- hkuo 17y agoThe title should really be renamed "Tokyo: It's Not Funny Anymore". For anyone that hasn't bothered to think about it, Japan is much richer and has more breadth than this single city. It's unfair to critique an entire country based on the experience of one place.