2 ms·
I must bring up a study I recently read. A research team in Sweden wanted to test if there existed bias in who get declared criminal insane. They took a larger
by belorn 11y ago
I must bring up a study I recently read.
A research team in Sweden wanted to test if there existed bias in who get declared criminal insane. They took a larger number of current working criminal psychiatrist and gave them a fake profile of a criminal. For half the participants, the otherwise identical profile had the name of the criminal be that of a typical male, and the other half got the profile with a typical female name. Everything else being equal, both group should have rated the profile as equally in/sane.
The result was that the female version was 4 times more likely to be deemed criminal insane and thus not responsible for their action. This has real effect on justice, and its not getting fixed in any time soon. The culture just is that men who do bad things are evil, and women who do bad things are insane, and justice reflect the people who live in that culture.
Or to bring an other example. In the duration of a single week there were two stories on Swedish national news. In the first one, a young women was put against her will in a mental institute, and had her arms and leg put into a cast in order to "prevent her from harming herself". The cause of this was a meeting with a psychiatrist where she had said "I don't know what I might do to myself", and the whole story was presented as an strong example of current overreaction by the psychiatric system towards women.
The second story had a man go to the hospital telling the staff that he was hearing gods voice and it was telling him to kill his daughter in order to grant her eternal life. The staff sad that it sounded serious, but the psychiatry ward were full so he should return next week. He then went home and murdered his daughter with a knife. The hospital said in the article that maybe they should taken the situation a bit more serious.
The problems that get fixed are only those that fit the current gender culture and gender identity. Men are all strong, has perfect health, and are wealthy, so biases from those assumptions are not getting fixed any time soon. Same is true for biases for women, in that the biases that people do care about is those that fit current gender culture and gender identity. Neither women or men is benefiting from this.