4 ms·
> people often do not have sufficient liquid holdings to pay the taxes. This is the "death tax" argument and has been debunked over and over. When they tried
by bsder 11y ago
> people often do not have sufficient liquid holdings to pay the taxes.
This is the "death tax" argument and has been debunked over and over. When they tried to find one of those, as the story goes, "farmers who lost their family farm", they couldn't actually find one.
If this is a genuine concern, then personal holdings of property should have capped tax increases until they transact. At point of transaction (inheritance generally), the assessment jumps to match the market.
As for corporate holding of property, it should get no such consideration. If you can't pay the tax, you transact the property. California is having a massive problem with the fact that a bunch of really expensive real estate in places like Silicon Valley have subleases that are 20+ layers deep to avoid triggering a reassessment.
- onetimeusename 11y agoThat isn't true. Great article about the death tax here[1]. Also, have a look at these famous auctions[2]. Some were brought on by things other than taxes but death duties that Labour increased in the 1940s were definitely a precipitant. But these taxes are far reaching. From [1] it even says the death duties earn less than booze or tobacco, or vehicle duties. I can't speak to corporate holdings of property, I am specifically talking about property held for generations in families. My general points are that it is a)inefficient and strange to target certain people that inherited and b) when you do target them, there are unintended consequences. [1]http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/georgeosborne/11907392/George-Osborne-should-abolish-inheritance-tax-in-its-entirety.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/georgeosborne/11907... [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_country_house_contents_auctions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_country_house_contents...
- bsder 11y agoAs your article mentions, the problem is that the rich have a loophole because the property isn't taxed properly when transacted. The point isn't to make "inheritance" the taxation point, it's to make "transaction" the taxation point. In addition, I think that "inheritance tax" executes differently in the US than the UK.
- onetimeusename 11y agoI wasn't quite sure what you meant originally but I see it now and completely agree with taxes on transactions and perhaps removing those loopholes.