3 ms·
The same could be said of almost any study that tried to show this. It is unethical to design the study in the way you're suggesting (i.e. stop people exercisin
by Someone1234 11y ago
The same could be said of almost any study that tried to show this. It is unethical to design the study in the way you're suggesting (i.e. stop people exercising to see if they get cancer).
They did however:
> Body mass index adjustment modestly attenuated associations for several cancers, but 10 of 13 inverse associations remained statistically significant after this adjustment.
So even for two thin people, exercise seems to have helped. I legitimately don't see how you could design a study that you'd be satisfied with.
- vagabondvector 11y agothe problem is that on noisy data, that adjustment of the variables isn't really as statistically clean as maths would say. it's the same with red meat causes cancer studies. they say they remove smoking and lack of exercise and still wave the statistical significance. it's very questionable how they removed the influence of these variables, since meat eaters do smoke way more, and do not exercise, and care about their health less.
- jimrandomh 11y agoActually, I think noise is a red herring, and that worrying about noise (instead of worrying about unmeasured confounders and incorrect causal structures) is how epidemiology got into this mess in the first place.
- jimrandomh 11y agoThe correct study is one where some participants get an intervention to make them exercise more, and some are left alone. There's no ethical issue, but running such a study would be difficult and expensive. Adjusting for BMI does not solve the problem, because there are many things besides BMI (unmeasured confounders) which affect both cancer risk and willingness to exercise.
- ekianjo 10y agoAnd BMI is a pseudo science measure anyway. Its been proven to be a poor indicator in about every disease many times before.
- ekianjo 10y agoStatistically significant does not prove anything, and it does not mean the difference would be large either.