13 ms·
Keep your identity small (2009)
- angersock 11y agoAs a rule, any mention of religion on an online forum degenerates into a religious argument. Why? Why does this happen with religion and not with Javascript or baking or other topics people talk about on forums? Um, Graham is more than a little off here. Like, by a country mile.
- dylz 11y agoLet's discuss text editors. Anyone?
- AlwaysBCoding 11y agolol @ Vim users that have to write configuration files, memorize complicated keyboard shortcuts, and install 20 plugins just to be able to copy and paste text between files. It's 2016, try using a real editor like Atom. (Am I doing it right?)
- clock_tower 11y agoYes, you certainly are -- you hateful covert Emacs advocate! I know what you're up to, you're trying to discredit the good editor so that you can quietly build up your overbuilt piece of crap! Atom is built on Emacs, isn't it?! (/s. All the /s in the world.)
- ythl 11y agoAtom? What is this, 2015? Sublime is still king, Atom was a passing fad.
- devishard 11y agoI use vim w/o plugins and with the stock configuration. I frequently have two files open side-by-side. If I want to copy the current line in the left file to the right file, the keystrokes are: yy<Ctrl+w>lp It's really not that hard to copy between files in Vim. :P
- jlg23 11y agoA user who has been using vi[m] and emacs for 20+ years - what are you trying to say? Please don't tell me that I should just use the mouse and context menus, I'm so much faster with touch typing.... [EDIT: yes, I know both editors very well and have config files for both; does this make me "worse" than someone who has not taken the time to learn how to configure his/her editor?]
- trentmb 11y ago> (Am I doing it right?) No, you're using Atom
- clock_tower 11y agoDeath to Emacs! It's as arrogant as it is shoddy; it has a narrow provincial name for the Alt key, and it makes you learn Lisp in order to make it handle backspaces properly! Also, you Limeys need to learn how to spell. (There, that should get the conversational juices flowing...)
- jlg23 11y agoThe "narrow [, [sic]] provincial name for the Alt key" is actually what it was once called. And backspace just works as expected in a unix environment. > (There, that should get the conversational juices flowing...) Sane people here know when to engage in a conversation, no trolling needed.
- clock_tower 11y agoUpvoted this for the first part (noticing the information while missing the pointless quibble about comma use, which should have been a red flag), before I saw the second. A "take back upvote" option would be nice...
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoWell, I'm an emacs guy, because I've used it for 30 years, and the commands are burned into my fingertips by now. I'll admit that vi is more logical and easier to learn, though. And I don't get "religious" about editors except in jest...
- clock_tower 11y agoI think that's what it comes down to: vi is easier to learn, but emacs is much more powerful. My current job involves using a very esoteric in-house language, which doesn't have any IDEs or even Notepad++ text-formatting extensions; I'm thinking about learning emacs, which can be programmed relatively easily to become little less than an IDE for it. (Speaking of, behold another holy war: IDEs versus command-line development...)
- bbcbasic 11y agoI'm a weirdo. I love visual studio and I love vim. Windows and Linux. Haskell and C#. Etc. I more I learn the less I think I know.
- snowwrestler 11y agoI like, and frequently use, nano. There, I said it. Now vim and emacs users can both mock my child-like ignorance of real text editing.
- danieltillett 11y agoI will join in on the love for nano. If you are just doing simple things like editing config files it is all you need. I don't use vim often enough ever get really comfortable with it.
- setpatchaddress 11y agoPerverse! Nano is actually more difficult to use than vi over time. Sad, but true. The first time you have to learn the arcane control-keys to search for something, you've already lost, because vim is approximately as arcane, but much faster.
- mcbits 11y agoI don't think I've ever had to search for anything in nano or vi to get a system into a state where I can use an editor with good ol' Ctrl-F. But then I'm not hot-patching a server over an acoustic coupler from a phone booth in rural Nevada, or whatever hardcore sysadmins do.
- douche 11y agoNotepad++, anyone?
- groby_b 11y agoYep. I don't think we need to even talk about JS, and I'm happy to point him to a few baking forum flame wars that are epic. And his comment about the problem being a threshold for expertise is equally laughable. People feel perfectly happy to comment on anything catching their fancy, expertise or not. (Add to that Dunning Kruger...)
- jdquey 11y agoAgreed. I find it depends on how people go about talking about the subjects. I think it has to do more with the potential impact it has on us and others. Not to mention how much broad appeal there is. I don't know much about Javascript, but debates about how to properly use it aren't going to change a nation. Or the implication of someone's life, both now and after death. People have a lot of opinions on baking. You don't need to be an expert to blog about it (e.g. probably 1/2 the mommy blogs out there). But again, who cares if you add organic cheese to your chili or sour cream? Very few. And most would remove it if not important.
- DonaldFisk 11y agoI don't feel strongly either way about this. It isn't worth getting into an argument about.
- jayvanguard 11y agoIs he though? Questions on the most performant way to iterate over something rarely result in flame wars. I believe you are thinking of people arguing over JS frameworks or whether JS sucks or not. Both are identity related. When it comes down to arguing the specific mechanics of comparing how framework X uses MVC vs how framework Y uses it, you don't see so much conflict because it is expertise, not identity driven.
- ixtli 11y agoYes, he is. In fact he's SO off that he goes on to directly contradict himself later in the article: > For example, the question of the relative merits of programming languages often degenerates into a religious war, because so many programmers identify as X programmers or Y programmers.
- brhsiao 11y agoYou used 14 words to say what could've been said in 3 or 4.
- dang 11y agoI doubt pg was off when he wrote that about Javascript in 2009. If it had been obviously untrue, he would have known it from moderating HN. It doesn't much matter, though, because the important point holds: arguments about JS became more like religious arguments when people started to identify for and/or against being a JS programmer. The same could become true about baking; there's nothing stopping people from identifying with anything.
- cxromos 11y agonot only graham is right on the spot but even more than that. how often we tend to joke about the programming languages we love and do our jobs with. case in point every developer likes the following: https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/wat https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/wat
- ikeboy 11y agoSee also http://rationality.org/2015/03/02/keep-your-identity-fluid/ http://rationality.org/2015/03/02/keep-your-identity-fluid/
- DonHopkins 11y agoIs "identity fluid" the same as "precious bodily fluids" [1] ? [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1KvgtEnABY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1KvgtEnABY
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jshevek 11y ago" Why? Why does this happen with religion and not with Javascript or baking or other topics people talk about on forums?" I do not believe this author had much experience discussing JS on forums.
- hornbaker 11y agoTo be fair, the JS world has changed considerably since 2009.
- avitex 11y agoAgreed, though the explosion of desktop applications (that are bundled with a browser), although understandable, is annoying.
- nostrademons 11y agoI thought of commenting on that as one thing in this article that didn't really stand the test of time. As a sibling comment points out, the JS world was very different in 2009, and we didn't have the same kind of flamewars that we do now. I think that's actually a point in favor of the article. In 2009, virtually nobody considered themselves a "Javascript programmer". Rather, Javascript was a skill that you used to build webapps, which itself was a skill you used as part of a larger software system. It was pointless to get emotionally invested in Javascript arguments on the Internet, because whether you won or lost, you still needed Rails/Django on the server, and SQL or C++/Java on the backend. Sometime between 2009 and 2015, Javascript became a tribe, where you could invest enough of your life in it that discussions about it became a matter of identity. And its growth became threatening enough to other programming "tribes" (eg. Windows programmers, Rails programmers) that you could suddenly have very heated discussions about it on the Internet.
- jasode 11y ago>In 2009, virtually nobody considered themselves a "Javascript programmer". I'm guessing the "Javascript is my identity" era began with Nodejs. Before 2009, Javascript was something that was "tolerated" because it just came with all the browsers. Back then, having any point of pride in being a "Javascript programmer" would be a little weird as if a homeowner proclaimed he was a "Panasonic keypad microwave programmer instead of a Samsung microwave programmer". Nobody cares what buttons you press to pop your popcorn. Likewise, the "Javascript" stuff was just something you had to do for interactive webpages. However, for someone to have the audacity of duplicating the Javascript environment on the server side... that means subsequent programmers get to make an invested choice, which means... flame wars.
- phantom_oracle 11y ago> Politics, like religion, is a topic where there's no threshold of expertise for expressing an opinion. All you need is strong convictions. What I don't get is who/what determines a threshold? A university degree? 10 years of experience? As others have rightly pointed out, perhaps there is no such thing as a "threshold of expertise". Any programmer could have 10 years of experience repeatedly cookie-cutting their beginner-level code and never going beyond that. Does that give them the right to be called/known as JavaScript-Ninjas? Perhaps Grahams identity leans towards anti-establishment/anti-religion/hacker-think, which by proxy of his argument, makes him partisan towards those opinions about religion and politics (see how the snake eats its own tail here?).
- montecarl 11y agoPeople determine the threshold themselves. Most people won't join in conversations about science or math topics unless they feel like they have a solid grasp of what is being discussed (relative to those around them). However, almost everyone feels like they have valid points to make on religious and political topics regardless of how well educated they are on those topics.
- brhsiao 11y agoThe point is that with politics and religion people don't even think they need to be knowledgeable to contribute to the discussion. I wish this "who can know for sure?" relativist hands-in-air sort of sentiment were less prevalent on HN.
- lizard 11y ago"Identity" in most psychological context generally refers to how a person perceives themselves. It's personal; there is no threshold. You can identify as The Greatest JavaScript Master of All Time and no one can do anything but disagree. The way I read it, that's precisely the danger this essay is warning about. When you start identifying as a "JavaScript Developer" you are making JavaScript development a part of who you are. Anything about JavaScript becomes personal. You expose yourself to attacks that aren't even being directed at you. The bigger you inflate your identity the more get hit, until eventually you can't hold a conversation without getting offended about something. If you can keep these things out of your identity it is much easier to shrug off other opinions about them. You can stay objective and have meaningful conversations about the benefits and consequences of it. Because it's just a thing, it does its thing and gives you something to think about when it doesn't. Identity is personal: Identity is what you choose to care about. Some things should become part of your identity. Studies find that in most successful relationships partners see each other as part of their own identity. But most things probably don't belong there.
- helmett 11y agokeep your identity to yourself ..until you're rich enough to be shielded from the consequences
- keeringplastik 11y agoOr at least until "rich" becomes your identity, then you defend your position. http://paulgraham.com/ineq.html http://paulgraham.com/ineq.html
- bhewes 11y agoI would added sports.
- chris_wot 11y agoThis doesn't help when you aren't in your right mind.
- chris_wot 11y agoDownvote away, but I speak from personal experience.
- jleader 11y agoOne of the biggest invisible biases is thinking you've managed to free yourself of invisible biases.
- zyxley 11y agoI'm reminded of the inevitable "I'm not biased, but I'm going to complain about this because I think it's an attack on me" that comes up whenever anyone on the internet mentions that institutional racism exists.
- bendbro 11y agoI'm reminded of the inevitable "I'm not biased, but I'm going to complain about this because I think it's an attack on me" that comes up whenever anyone on the internet mentions that speaking about institutional racism is just virtue signalling. You can see that arguments of that form aren't effective. I don't think that's a compelling argument for anyone other than those who have similar beliefs to you. Arguments from the left like that are the reason for the resurgence of the right.
- Spivak 11y agoYou do understand the other side's situation right? You are, albeit impersonally, being accused of participating in something monstrous, the institutional subjugation and prejudicial treatment of an entire class of people, and there is literally nothing you can say or do which will demonstrate otherwise since your racist acts are unconscious and unknowable to you. It's like trying to convince someone that you're not crazy when they already think you are. It doesn't mater, anything you say or do just reinforces their belief. We all hold biases and prejudices for just about everything from concepts, ideas, products, institutions, and especially one another based on their history, race, creed, social status, clothing, voice, stature, hometown, manner of speaking, educational background, career field, job title, wealth, attractiveness, political beliefs, the list goes could go on for pages. But trying to equate these kinds of biases to being *-ist in any meaningful sense is missing the forest for the trees.
- 11y ago
- carapace 11y agoAw c'mon! Don't attach to (identify with) things is, like, Spirituality 101.
- pystack 11y agoI've realized there are things I can change and there are things I cannot change. I try not to feel too strongly on the things I cannot change, because it distracts me from the things I can change. For politics, I try not to feel too strongly about Trump and the electoral process. I would still vote, but I know it would have a minimal impact, no matter how strongly I feel. Instead, I focus my energy on my business, which I can change.
- zyxley 11y agoThe Serenity Prayer may resonate with you. > God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, > Courage to change the things I can, > And wisdom to know the difference.
- douche 11y agoBetter (and not tainted by association with AA...) I must not fear. Fear is the mind-killer. Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration. I will face my fear. I will permit it to pass over me and through me. And when it has gone past I will turn the inner eye to see its path. Where the fear has gone there will be nothing. Only I will remain.
- reitanqild 11y agoBetter ? The first is shorter, less abstract and easier to remember.
- wry_discontent 11y agoI always remember this from Slaughterhouse Five. God, I love Kurt Vonnegut.
- pbreit 11y agoI think Suster was going there today: https://twitter.com/msuster/status/733330477046587392 https://twitter.com/msuster/status/733330477046587392 People waste so much energy trying to change others when they could change themselves with practically no effort.
- chejazi 11y agoLabels might make you "dumber", but there's a huge tradeoff: you can arrive at a conclusion a lot faster. Of course in a discussion you wouldn't just jump to the conclusion, which is why labels fail in the situations Graham described.
- birdDadCawww 11y agoWhats funny is this theory pushes us to be more like computers. Less passion and more logic. Not to mention people on the Internet say and talk about options in forums reinforcing maybe a small part of ones identity. while in the real world you might get punched in the face. I still favor this theory but I would say spend less time on Internet interactions, so you don't have your personal held beliefs blossom into something more toxic for rational communication and real human connection. Being at the computer is a suit of idealogical armor and you can disengage from conversations like I am about to do.
- denzil_correa 11y ago> Less passion and more logic. You can be more passionate and have more logic.
- tehchromic 11y ago"I think what religion and politics have in common is that they become part of people's identity" You might also say that people have identity and religion and politics use those to advantage. But is it wrong to have identity? I'd argue it as a basic human requirement. Religion can be considered a technology of group identity which was refined over millennium to be most effective at generating a unified form. Like all technology it was disrupted by something better and more efficient at transmitting shared consciousness. That definition also fits the web which is the most powerful method of transmission yet invented, and is the fruit of the science religion.
- altonzheng 11y agoWow, you just out-generalized Paul Graham. nice.
- tehchromic 10y agocan you give me specific examples of how tho?
- tehchromic 11y ago"I think what religion and politics have in common is that they become part of people's identity" You might also say that people have identity and religion and politics use those to advantage. But is it wrong to have identity? I'd argue it as a basic human requirement. Religion can be considered a technology of group identity which was refined over millennium to be most effective at generating a unified form. Like all technology it was disrupted by something better and more efficient at transmitting shared consciousness. That's the web.
- tn13 11y agoNot particularly well articulated but the core point is one of the most valuable lesson I had learned. It not just applies to religion and politics but many other things in life. We might be wasting too much of time on certain thing with very little impact. It is hard to not to fall in that trap but trying surely saved a lot of time.
- sevenless 11y agoPeople who don't have an identity... I hate those people.
- beatpanda 11y agoThis essay only works because Paul Graham is a white man in America, whose 'identity' is the presumed default in the society he lives in. Anything he makes a part of his identity, he gets to choose. If he chooses nothing, he has the luxury of being 'just normal' and gets to go through life thinking of himself as perfectly rational. Sometimes you get to choose what you identify with. Other times, people choose for you. For instance, you don't get to wake up one morning and decide not to be black, or gay, or a woman. You don't get to simply shed those categories and avoid the increased violence that comes your way apropos of nothing. I know, you're already thinking, "but this essay is about religion and politics!", but the thing is, for a lot of people, politics are not abstract. I'm also a straight white cis guy living in America, and so I have the luxury of choosing or choosing not to support gay rights, or feminism, or racial justice. I can choose or choose not to make those things a part of my identity. In fact there's incentive for me to choose not to, because if the balance of power were re-arranged in society, and poverty and violence were more evenly distributed, my life might not be so easy. But for a lot of people, making "politics" a part of their "identity" is a necessary defense mechanism, because the society we live in implicitly sanctions violence against anybody who shares characteristics of their identity they can't do anything about. "Politics" is not some separate sphere you can disconnect yourself from. Politics are embedded in everything. Choosing not to "identify" with any political orientation is implicitly choosing society's defaults, and those defaults implicitly condone a specific power structure and make acceptable a certain amount of violence against certain people.
- beatpanda 11y agoP.S., if you're in San Francisco: >On Thursday morning, a San Francisco police sergeant shot and killed a woman who was driving a suspected stolen car near the Bayview neighborhood, officials said. There was no immediate indication that the 27-year-old woman had a weapon or was trying to run down the sergeant before the shooting, police said. There's a vigil tonight at 8:30 at Shafter Ave and Elmira Street in San Francisco, and if you're nearby and you're reading this, you should be there.
- dopu 11y agoWhat I wanted to say upon reading this article, and you laid it out quite nicely. Thank you.
- athenot 11y agoI don't think it's so much about identity as it is about (in)security. Regarding politics, I completely follow his argument: I don't identify with any party and like to think I'm evaluating each policy on its on merits and according to my personal beliefs. Which leads me to the other one. I happen to be Catholic and strongly believe in the mental and societal framework put forth by that theology. However, I'm more than happy to discuss objectively with fellows of other faiths (including atheism) and will happily point out the common threads in seemingly opposite belief systems. Yet if others make arguments that I'm not in position to counter, I'm happy to let it go. My identity is deeply rooted as a Catholic, yet my security is not in being right. There is a temptation on my part to put forth the argument that some religions foster greater amounts of insecurity, but I don't think that is fair to say. Pretty much every belief system has a version of the Golden Rule. To take Paul Graham's argument just a little further, I would say that religion and politics can be misused as convenient mental shortcuts behind which to hide one's insecurities.
- sysk 11y agoJust a nitpick but atheism is not a faith, it's the absence of faith.
- enord 11y agoDo you identify as atheist? Is the distinction important to you? Grouping different religious views together with atheism under the same category is useful when discussing people and their beliefs. Arguing the semantics of wether Atheism is a "belief" or "faith" (or some nicer, more certain-sounding term) is in my experience unfruitful and most often besides the point. /nitpick
- reedlaw 11y agoThis is the weakest pg essay I've come across. I can think of so many counter-examples. "Stand for nothing and you'll fall for anything." It's very convenient to have a small identity with few convictions because convictions are costly. Sophie Scholl identified with anti-Nazi politics and it cost her her life. We have a word for people like her: hero.
- santoshalper 11y agoPaul didn't say "have no convictions", he said "keep your identity small"... save your convictions for things that really matter, not stupid shit like sports teams, programming languages, favorite <games/movies/books/TV>. I don't feel like you grasped the article clearly.
- reedlaw 11y agoHis main examples of identity were politics and religion.
- newjersey 11y agoI think it is possible/fairly safe to cheer for the Denver Bronco's or the New York Yankees, or Crystal Palace football club or Team SoloMid or whatever without making that one's identity. Edit: Just now, someone showed me a video which claimed drinking apple cider vinegar helped prevent cancer. I tried to say that this is billshit because nobody can really say drinking something prevents cancer without a long-term study that I doubt this YouTube celebrity had done. I don't claim I don't have a bias. But I don't think we should be sin free to cast the first stone on ideas.
- chillacy 11y agoRegarding sports teams and identity, I suspect the guy who says "wow good game" after their home team loses and the guy who feels crummy for a week is the extent that they identify with the team. I had a brief stint with that in college with my college football team. The wins felt like giant ego rushes and the losses felt like I had lost a million bucks. Now I can pretend to cheer but I don't really care as much.
- mcshicks 11y agoPhilip Tetlock has done a lot of research on objective measures of political expertise, specifically the ability to make objective predictions about future outcomes and likelihoods. He wrote a pretty famous book on it. The basic conclusion is nobody is really that good, but some people are objectively better than others. If you are really interested in this he has as website called "good judgement project" where you can test your ability to predict against other people on the site over time. http://www.amazon.com/Expert-Political-Judgment-Good-Know/dp/0691128715 http://www.amazon.com/Expert-Political-Judgment-Good-Know/dp... https://www.gjopen.com/ https://www.gjopen.com/
- fao_ 11y ago> Why does this happen with religion and not with Javascript or baking or other topics people talk about on forums? He must not spend a lot of time on Slashdot, or Hacker News, for that matter.
- statictype 11y agoWell, he did acknowledge this later on: For example, the question of the relative merits of programming languages often degenerates into a religious war, because so many programmers identify as X programmers or Y programmers.
- peteretep 11y agoHacker friends who have started new hobbies are often posting their bewilderment about how it follows everywhere. Beekeeping being the most surprising example.
- aws_ls 11y agoI am seeing this point being repeatedly pointed out on this page (i.e. his first mention of Javascript as non-controversial as baking, and then later on in the essay Programming lang X vs Y) . Remember it was 2009. Surely Chrome had come out by then a few years, with the much improved JS engine, but IE still had the dominant market share. And so I doubt there were so many JS frameworks as today. Surely there was jquery and also things like GWT already, and I am sure quite some other frameworks. But the full impact of a fast JS execution engine, had still not played out, I guess. Today, if PG writes the essay, he would most definitely not include Javascript there. Also if I look at the context of what he is trying to say, that mention is not important. Its about wearing labels or not. Or in other words about being open to think, because of not tying ourselves down with published identities.
- kaonashi 11y agoSometimes identity has a way of finding you, even if you try your hardest to keep it out. People define you, and depending on who or where you are, those definitions can have profound impact on your life. This piece reads like a person who has never had to deal with that, or at least never had to think about it.
- hypertexthero 11y agoRemind's me of Paul Buchheit's [I am nothing][1] and Jiddu Krishnamurti's [The observer is the observed][2]. An application by Buchheit (and others!) that improved my life: Gmail. Two books by Krishnamurti that improved my life: Think on These Things and The First and Last Freedom. [1]: http://paulbuchheit.blogspot.com/2011/08/i-am-nothing.html http://paulbuchheit.blogspot.com/2011/08/i-am-nothing.html [2]: http://www.jkrishnamurti.org/krishnamurti-teachings/view-daily-quote/20140305.php?t=The%20observer%20and%20the%20observed http://www.jkrishnamurti.org/krishnamurti-teachings/view-dai...
- ixtli 11y ago> any mention of religion on an online forum degenerates into a religious argument. Why? Why does this happen with religion and not with Javascript Then later > the question of the relative merits of programming languages often degenerates into a religious war, because so many programmers identify as X programmers or Y programmers. Also as another poster said, this works because he's been able to go his entire life choosing what to put in and take out of his identity because he is of the privileged class in his society. If someone perpetrated violence on him because of something he _couldn't_ choose, say, his skin color, I have a feeling he'd be less likely to conclude that "The more labels you have for yourself, the dumber they make you." The people to whom this "labeling" is most important are those who were labeled. Not those who label themselves.
- pbreit 11y agoI got the sense this article trended now because that's exactly where JavaScript/Node is right now.
- lliamander 11y ago> If someone perpetrated violence on him because of something he _couldn't_ choose, say, his skin color, I have a feeling he'd be less likely to conclude that "The more labels you have for yourself, the dumber they make you." I disagree. Each person reacts to circumstances differently. It might lead him to reject (what he perceives as) arbitrary labels all the more because others were using it as an excuse to hurt him. And yes, these labels often come from outside of us, but I think his point is to resist internalizing them. > The people to whom this "labeling" is most important are those who were labeled. Not those who label themselves. I'm not quite sure what you are getting at. We all get labelled, we all have cultural scripts we are expected to follow. And yes, some have more negative labels. Are you saying such people are more justified in internalizing and defining themselves by their labels? I guess I'm just curious as to whether you accept his premise that striving for a minimalist identity helps remain objective? Is it not worth analysing in our own lives what identities we have internalized that we could do without?
- abtinf 11y agoIf I attack you because your identity conflicts with my identity, say over differing skin color, then it demonstrates his original point: the label I've given myself is making me behave dumb/stupid/evil. My action creates no obligation on your part to adopt the identity I've assigned to you. Your station in life has no impact on whether you will accept the label; you are a human capable of reason and you have free will - the choice is yours. In literature, Tom of Uncle Tom's Cabin is a solid example of this. Tom, a heroic black slave, rejects the labels and associated moral principals others (both black and white) wish to assign to him. He acts in accordance with his self-selected moral convictions. And when confronted with an ultimate evil that demands the surrender of not only his body but also his reasoning mind - demands he accept an unchosen identity - he refuses.
- known 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_politics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_politics
- eternal_intern 11y agoIsn't it just more succinct to say we have tribal instincts because of our evolutionary origins? I see heated debates in politics, religion, even sports, because people identify from a certain "tribe". And I agree with Paul there, from what I have noticed, tribalism does seem to give you a certain blindspot to opposing arguments
- sannysanoff 11y agoThe story about the person who kept his identity small, during WW2 ( https://www.ushmm.org/wlc/en/article.php?ModuleId=10007392 https://www.ushmm.org/wlc/en/article.php?ModuleId=10007392 ) : """ First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out — Because I was not a Socialist. Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out — Because I was not a Trade Unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me — and there was no one left to speak for me. TLDR: paul graham is sofa philosopher.
- lucb1e 11y ago> I did not speak out Even if you are not a jew, why couldn't you have a discussion about jews? In fact, isn't that Paul Graham's entire point, that if it's not part of your identity (i.e. you're not a jew), you can have a much more reasonable conversation about it?
- adrianratnapala 11y agoThis is almost the opposite of keeping your identity small. The point is not that this person should have expanded his identity till he was a Socialist. The point is that there are principles that you should stand up for in the defense of people outside your identity group.
- peferron 11y agoUm. Are you missing the entire point of the quote, or am I? I understand the quote as meaning that we should speak out even when groups we do not identify with are being oppressed. But you seem to understand the quote as meaning that we should identify with as many groups as possible. I very much doubt the author of the quote meant it the way you do, and even if they did it just sounds very wrong. It's expected and accepted to not care about any other group than the ones you identify with then? I do not identify as LGBT or as a woman, so I should not speak out for LGBT and women's rights? What about groups that will remain small because you can't just decide one day to identify with them, they're screwed?
- Throwaway585250 11y agoThe two more or less inescapable identities are "human" and "yourself". I read this essay as saying that you should embrace both of these, and nothing more. A socialist, a trade unionist, and a Jew are still all people. You should be a human being, and treat others as such. If your identity is, as per your example, "right-wing", "German", "Christian", "pagan", "working class", or "member of the NSDAP", then you may not feel that your shared humanity is more important than your other identities. I don't know which reading is correct, but I prefer mine.
- pete_b 11y agoIt's usually inappropriate to draw in politics and religion when they are off topic, but sometimes they are involved. Ethics are involved frequently with technology, so politics and religion are not that far off. Though really, It's pretty shallow to draw like for like comparisons between religion/politics and JS discussions. JS is trivial. Most tech discussions are trivial the day after they've been had.
- tempodox 11y agoGreat advice. Don't believe in anything, and you won't have to stand up for what you believe. Ever. And others won't be disappointed if you don't. Win-win.
- w8rbt 11y agoAny thread about C versus C++ degenerates pretty fast too.
- madmax96 11y ago>the more labels you have for yourself, the dumber they make you You could keep going, stripping yourself of all labels via the discovery that labels are neither good nor bad in a qualitative sense. But this begs the question "what is good?" And then you might conclude that you know what is good, and then form your labels as such. Having labels isn't dumb; not being mindful of your labels is dumb.
- d0100 11y agoNot the first Paul to think like this, 1 Corinthians 9, 20-22: [...] I am made all things to all men [...]