2 ms·
> Intelligence. I would've selected/edited for intelligence if it had been a sure thing. Gender is special in being easily chosen with ~100% accuracy, either v
by gwern 11y ago
> Intelligence. I would've selected/edited for intelligence if it had been a sure thing.
Gender is special in being easily chosen with ~100% accuracy, either via embryo selection or simply selective abortion. But for everything else, it's more a question of reducing the odds or increasing the average. How much of an average increase in intelligence would you want before you did it?
> Life is hard, and while I don't care much for superficial traits (hair/eye color, height)
You know all of those correlate strongly with career success and income, right? Taller better-looking people get paid substantially more. (And the Mendelian randomization on BMI, IIRC, indicate it's causal.)
- toomuchtodo 10y agoAs soon as the odds approach 40-50% that the traits I select would be expressed, I'm willing to start spending tens of thousands of dollars. Its an investment in the future, with probably the biggest return I could provide my child(ren).
- gwern 10y agoI think you're misunderstanding. Traits like 'intelligence' are always 'expressed'. They aren't binary and ~100% determined by genetics like gender. You don't select for 'would be expressed', you select for something like 'on average, has 0.1SD higher measured trait values'. Even a trait which seems to be binary, like schizophrenia, is actually probably on a continuum (relatives of schizophrenics have lower IQs, many people have symptoms which wouldn't rise to the level of a full diagnosis) and can be seen as a liability threshold model where a large number of genes each have deleterious effects, yielding a normal distribution of risk and the higher your risk, the more likely random chance or an environmental insult will push you into a full-fledged schizophrenia. So if you were selecting on mental illness risk, it would be impossible to select for someone who 'does' or 'does not express' schizophrenia, but it would be perfectly meaningful to talk about halving or doubling the risk, which would translate to 0.5% vs 2% (in almost all of the people selected for less schizophrenia risk, they wouldn't have had schizophrenia either way; what it buys you is 1 less future out of 200 futures in which the person becomes schizophrenic).