4 ms·
YES. Design patterns are super useful as tools. As "goals" they are idiotic. I think lots of people that think they are idiotic have been exposed to them as "
by jrochkind1 11y ago
YES.
Design patterns are super useful as tools.
As "goals" they are idiotic. I think lots of people that think they are idiotic have been exposed to them as "goals", or don't realize that's not the point.
I think there is a larger issue here, which is that many kinds of software development, including web dev, has become enormously more complex in many ways than it was when many of us came up.
People coming up now are looking for magic bullets and shortcuts and things they can just follow by rote -- because they are overwhelmed and don't know how to get to competence, let alone expertise, without these things.
It's easy for us to look down on people doing this as just not very good developers -- and the idea of 'software bootcamp' doesn't help, I think it's probably not _possible_ to get to competence through such a process -- but too easy to forget that if we were starting from scratch now we ourselves would likely find it a lot more challenging than we did when we started. There's way more stuff to deal with now.
"Design patterns" are never going to serve as such a magic bullet or thing you can follow by rote, and will often make things worse when used that way -- but so will any other potential magic bullet or thing you can follow by rote. Software doesn't work that way. It's still a craft.
- orasis 11y ago"People coming up now are looking for magic bullets and shortcuts and things they can just follow by rote" This is the normal progression of learning. As a beginner, following the rules by rote is the goal. So, for the newbie that is first being exposed to design patterns, implementing some of those patterns should be the goal so they can learn where they fit in the toolbelt.
- mirchiseth 11y agoFor another somewhat funny take on Design Patterns watch the first two minutes of this talk from last year DEVOXX https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e4MT_OguDKg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e4MT_OguDKg Speaker echoes similar sentiments about design patterns being written by highly experienced developers and should be used to communicate about code etc.