4 ms·
But that's expanding the definition to "Arbitrary processing architecture we haven't even invented yet which really could simulate a human brain, if only we kne
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
But that's expanding the definition to "Arbitrary processing architecture we haven't even invented yet which really could simulate a human brain, if only we knew what it was and how to build it - which we don't, but that's just an engineering problem."
- UK-AL 11y agoA computer is something that computes. Doesn't really matter how it does it.
- chongli 11y agoAnd what does it mean for something to compute?
- UK-AL 11y agoBeing able to follow an algorithm, a set of steps(parallel or in series) to reach a result. The brain has input, goes through various connections, and you end up with a result.
- criddell 11y agoThe steps don't even have to be discrete. An analog computer can give a continuously varying response to varying inputs with no sequential operations.
- chongli 11y agoSo is fire a computer? It goes through a series of steps to reach a result.
- UK-AL 11y agoIs fire able to follow an algorithm? I mean some creative person could probably make a computer out of using fire.
- chongli 11y agoWell, what is an algorithm? Anyway, before we stray too far from the point I was hoping to make, I'll claim that when most people use the word "compute" they mean a particular task performed at the behest of a human being. This sort of definition is problematic if we're ever to attempt to build an artificial brain or to encounter intelligent alien life radically different from our own. It all falls back to the problem of agency and the philosophical concept of the self.
- criddell 11y agoI think that's a way too restrictive definition of computation. I'd argue genetic code (messenger RNA) is a program and inputting genes and outputting proteins is a form of computation.
- criddell 11y agoAnalog computers have a pretty rich history.
- ef4 11y agoIt's definitely not arbitrary. We have solid mathematical definitions of computing that are not tied to any particular implementation. Saying "the brain is not a computer" is a shorthand for "the brain is not Turing equivalent". Now, that could be true. But if it is, it would be the first time anybody has found a physical system in our universe that can't be simulated by a Turing machine. It seems like quite a stretch.