4 ms·
My the article is misargued mush. It's hard to analyse all 4000 words of it but to pick on a few points: >But here is what we are not born with: information, d
by tim333 11y ago
My the article is misargued mush. It's hard to analyse all 4000 words of it but to pick on a few points:
>But here is what we are not born with: information, data, rules, software, knowledge, lexicons, representations, algorithms, programs, models, memories, images, processors, subroutines, encoders, decoders, symbols, or buffers – design elements that allow digital computers to behave somewhat intelligently. Not only are we not born with such things, we also don’t develop them – ever.
I have several memories.
>cognitive psychologists will never find a copy of Beethoven’s 5th Symphony in the brain
We can build artificial neural networks at the moment to recognise faces and no doubt if you fed them the right inputs, to recognise Beethoven and probably tell you which symphony was playing. You would also not 'find a copy' of the 5th in the neural network. It is likely that the human network of neurons works in a similar manner to the artificial neural network with the learnings stored in modifications to synapses and changes in memory values respectively. I mention this rather obvious stuff because the author goes on to suggest:
>Meanwhile, vast sums of money are being raised for brain research, based in some cases on faulty ideas and promises that cannot be kept
On the basis of the above kind of semi arguments. The fact that the Human Brain Project may be a poor use of research funds is kind of a different issue.
>I challenged researchers there to account for intelligent human behaviour without reference to any aspect of the IP metaphor.
If you think of anything we normally regard as intelligence such as playing chess it involves taking in some information such as where the pieces are and then doing something with it. How that is supposed to prove his point is a loss to me.
etc and on for dozens of other wrong implications and twisted logic. Life's too short...
(For a kind of counter argument check out the Recurrent Neural Networks and Inceptionism articles https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9584325 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9584325 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9736598 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9736598 for how eeriely close the behaviour of artificial neural networks can be to human ones)
- khedoros 11y agoI found it odd how he noted rooting and nursing instincts in infants, then said that we aren't born with rules or software. That seems self-contradictory.
- rdiddly 11y agoHe's saying "rules" and "software" are just metaphors to attempt to explain these instincts. They are a way of saying it.
- khedoros 11y agoWell, yes, but he's saying that "rules" and "software" are incorrect metaphors, and that they are a way of saying it wrong. I think that's an important distinction. What strikes me in the section of the article with the six metaphors is that each one is "true" at a certain level of abstraction, and as time progresses, the abstraction gets thinner and thinner and closer to reality. The author's claims that I have the biggest problem with are that brains don't store or process information. We clearly do. Our behavior depends at least partly on past experience and our perceptions of current circumstances. When I remember something, do I assert the read and address lines on a NAND chip and latch the data into a register? No, certainly not. Do I trace a weighted graph of neural connections forming a fuzzy cloud of meaning? At the least, that's closer to what I'm doing, and I'd still classify it as information storage and retrieval. The author doesn't seem like they're attacking the imprecision of a metaphor. They seem like they're rejecting the "brain as a computer" metaphor outright.