3 ms·
> This functionality already exists in GNU coreutils, it's done by the shred(1) command. No need to install any extra third-party software, shred is already ins
by masklinn 11y ago
> This functionality already exists in GNU coreutils, it's done by the shred(1) command. No need to install any extra third-party software, shred is already installed.
That's only true for GNU-based userlands, not BSD-based ones.
> Also, as another commenter already pointed out, this kind of in-place overwrite is not guaranteed to work on SSDs
And if the system properly TRIMs it might not be necessary at all, though that greatly depends on the SSD.
- throwaway7767 11y ago> That's only true for GNU-based userlands, not BSD-based ones. Sure, but installing (a subset of) GNU coreutils is probably going to pull in a lot fewer dependencies than this JavaScript command line tool. Plus, you can use ports, no need to mess with a seperate package manager (npm) and the associated package verification foibles. > And if the system properly TRIMs it might not be necessary at all, though that greatly depends on the SSD. The "depends on the SSD" is a big one. Various recent forensic papers have shown that it can take a while until a TRIM'd sector is actually erased by the firmware. I still think that if this kind of thing causes worries, full-disk encryption is really the only sensible solution.
- masklinn 11y ago> Sure, but installing (a subset of) GNU coreutils is probably going to pull in a lot fewer dependencies than this JavaScript command line tool. No objection here. Though the original note is right, you just pointed to the wrong tool: > I still think that if this kind of thing causes worries, full-disk encryption is really the only sensible solution. And full agreement there.
- GalacticDomin8r 11y ago> That's only true for GNU-based userlands, not BSD-based ones. "rm -P" with the same caveats as the GNU implementation.
- Jaepa 11y agofor BSD-base systems there is srm (secure remove), which overwrites, renames, & trucates before unlinking. https://www.freshports.org/security/srm/ https://www.freshports.org/security/srm/
- DannyBee 11y ago"That's only true for GNU-based userlands, not BSD-based ones. " RM(1) BSD General Commands Manual RM(1) ... -P Overwrite regular files before deleting them. Files are overwritten three times, first with the byte pattern 0xff, then 0x00, and then 0xff again, before they are deleted.