4 ms·
Are there any known cases of embryos that were human yet not animal?
by tremon 11y ago
Are there any known cases of embryos that were human yet not animal?
- kashkhan 11y agoiirc all humans are animals.
- nutheracc 11y agoIs there a term for non-human animals?
- greydius 11y agoThat depends on who you ask. I've met people that hold firmly to the belief that humans are not animals. Explanation? God created Adam in his own image, so humans are somehow special and better than animals. We need to prevent these people from making decisions for society.
- doulos 11y agoI agree. These people shouldn't be allowed to vote, or own a business either. If only there were a way we could identify them more easily just by looking at them so we could avoid them. They are such a nuisance. What would be really great is if we could just create a certain section of our cities to keep them separate so we don't have to worry about them screwing things up anymore. They are so incredibly ignorant. How can they look at humans and animals and believe that one is different than the other? How can they look around this world and believe that any of this could have been created by a higher being? This ignorance cannot be tolerated. This world will not be right until we get rid of them altogether.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lliamander 11y agoHave you considered the possibility that "your people" and "these people" should just form separate societies, or is it your preference to keep them within a common society as permanent second-class citizens?
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoThis is where reading comprehension kicks in. Given the context with "human" and "animal" juxtaposed, one would assume they are using the word "animal" in the sense of "(non-human) animal". By pretending that this meaning of the word does not exist (or is not obvious), you're being intentionally obtuse to try to score points. That is, of course, the most generous interpretation of your comment, there are other less flattering ones.
- headShrinker 11y agoScoring points, or not. Humans are in fact technically animals. To write about a scientific endeavor in nontechnical/ambiguous or inaccurate terms is disingenuous or worse, negligent. By the way, I believe you were attempting to 'score points' by pointing out the op's intentionality.
- lliamander 11y ago> To write about a scientific endeavor in nontechnical/ambiguous or inaccurate terms is disingenuous or worse, negligent. No, it is not. Communication is not about being correct, but about being correctly understood. Also, if we are being technical, "animal" was a word used prior to the development of modern biology, and it means what the article means when it uses the word, i.e. non-human animals. The fact that scientists decided to reuse the same word to mean something slightly different is if anything a flaw on their part. They could have come up with a more precise term to disambiguate (e.g. "neural mobile multi-cellular organisms (NMMCOs)" or some such) but they didn't. As this article is aimed at the lay-person, it is perfectly reasonable (I would say obligatory) to use the meaning that is expected by that audience. The headline as it shows up in HN was renamed to "In Search for Cures, Scientists Create Multispecies Embryos". This is a ridiculous act of pedantry that completely obscures the rather important fact that one of those species in "multispecies" is human.
- headShrinker 10y ago> The fact that scientists decided to reuse the same word to mean something slightly different This is like saying we should have used different terminology when Copernicus published his work on planetary bodies. Or science should have used a different name for Earth when it proven that our planet round? No, if people are inaccurate, you don't keep on using old outdated definitions and invent new nouns for the new meanings. You update the old inaccurate definitions. People used to think humans were distinctly different than anything else on the planet. We are not and we are not special. We are animals. At the root of this debate is the fact that this idea deeply offends a select few, mostly religious zealots . The same groups were offended that the Earth was still Earth even though it's round. Animals are still animals even thought people are animals too. Gravity is still gravity as our definition of what it is and how it works changes.
- Veratyr 11y agoDuplicating my comment below for the the sake of visibility, the OED defines "animal" as: a. A living organism which feeds on organic matter, typically having specialized sense organs and a nervous system and able to respond rapidly to stimuli; any living creature, including man. b. In ordinary or non-technical use: any such living organism other than a human being. In a technical context, such as a scientific journal, I expect that "animal" would include humans. In the headline of a science-focused mainstream media article, I think it's ambiguous. Given that the context, I think it's clear they're using the non-technical definition of the word.
- tremon 10y agoYet, I think "animal" was the worst word they could have chosen, because (as I said in another comment) the latter definition is directly from the Bible. Given that genetic manipulation evokes strong religious sentiment, the word is not neutral in this context.
- ada1981 11y agoTrump.
- ada1981 11y agoI came here to critique the same thing... Reminding people that humans are animals and thus, part of, connected to and dependent on nature is important.