8 ms·
Gendercide: The worldwide war on baby girls
- lionhearted 17y agoI just finished Genji Monogatari, a work from 12th Century Japan. It follows Prince Genji from being born to an low ranking concubine of the Emperor and follows his adventures, and how he gets exiled, and returns, and eventually becomes Emperor himself. Very interesting read. Anyway, at one point in the book, he meets a family in the countryside where the mother had died and the father was working off in another city, leaving one last elderly grandparent in the care of a 10 year old girl. Genji took her, raised her, and she became a member of his household. About 10 years later, after Genji's wife died, he actually married her. Anyway, it'd be totally politically untenable to loosen the adoption restrictions, and going as far as to allow adoptive parents to compensate the family would never happen. It'd be just politically impossible due to perceptions involved, and maybe that's a good thing. Still, infanticide is no good, and I wonder if there's other solutions if we could broaden our perspective.
- greenlblue 17y agoGirls in general are better people and killing them is plain stupid.
- riffic 17y agoI agree with this.
- greenlblue 17y agoHonestly, why would anyone take offence at this and downvote? Most of human history has been dominated by men and it has been war after war after war. Throw in the several male prophets whose followers have created several religions and the subsequent strife and women win by at least 1000 points. At this point it shouldn't even be an issue which is the better gender.
- allenbrunson 17y agoEven if true, it's a very polarizing thing to say. It drags the conversation towards an unhealthy, flamey place.
- greenlblue 17y agoIf somebody disagrees I would like to know their stance on it and their argument against my view. Being downvoted certainly says people don't approve of the comment but I don't see how it's polarizing or why it's wrong to make polarizing comments if there is a modicum of truth in it. I'll chalk it up to my Asperger's syndrome.
- potatolicious 17y agoSaying something so obviously controversial and polarizing demands more backup than the mere statement itself. You know your opinion is going to be unpopular, so the onus is upon you to expand upon that idea in your original post, otherwise it looks like you're just trolling. In response to your later justification, though, most western societies have been patriarchal, so the fact that we've been very successful at fighting and killing each other is not an indication that women somehow would not if given the chance. Your argument breaks down to this: since men are so bad at keeping the peace, women must therefore be better at it.
- greenlblue 17y agoIn response to your later justification, though, most western societies have been patriarchal, so the fact that we've been very successful at fighting and killing each other is not an indication that women somehow would not if given the chance. But that's just it. The entire time men have been behaving badly women haven't even shown the slightest interest in participating so that's already evidence enough for me to make some conclusions about which is the more docile and empathetic gender.
- lionhearted 17y ago
- wooster 17y agoIt's fairly easy to see that this is going to be one of the great causes of worldwide instability in this century. Many of these societies will be left with little choice in the face of political and societal forces but territorial expansionism, civil war, totalitarianism, or cultural suicide.
- kiba 17y agoThe European and the Japanese is declining in population. Greece is already bankrupt. The United State government is racking up extraordinary debt, backed with little saving. If it keep doing that, we may entered not just stagnation but collapse. There is also the agriculture crisis in Africa as a certain fungus ravages crops all over. It has already spread to Iran, I heard. The 21st century certainly hang in the balance as we flirt with danger.
- barrkel 17y agoUS government debt actually isn't very high, nor are interest payments very high compared to GDP. And racking up extraordinary debt is the correct counter-cyclical response to an extraordinary recession. Governments shouldn't be reducing spending or increasing taxes when the economy hits hard times. Instead, it should reduce spending and maintain or raise taxes when the economy is doing well. And Greece isn't bankrupt. You can't reasonably say that a country is bankrupt until it starts defaulting on its loans.
- kiba 17y agoUS government debt actually isn't very high, nor are interest payments very high compared to GDP. And racking up extraordinary debt is the correct counter-cyclical response to an extraordinary recession. Governments shouldn't be reducing spending or increasing taxes when the economy hits hard times. Instead, it should reduce spending and maintain or raise taxes when the economy is doing well. Why would government spending help the economy at all? Let give people shovels to dig holes and fill it back it in! Surely, breaking windows will make jobs for the glassmakers. Let not forget that all the fancy infrastructure projects that the government is making has to be maintained. We may like all the new roads that we're paying for right now, but too many roads mean higher maintenance bills, which mean higher taxes and less money for consumers to spend it on or save. Maybe it is better to let all the irresponsible firms bankrupt themselves and let people who made the correct bet win all the money. Let the Nassim Nicholas Taleb of world win big. The free market runs on firm failure, not just firm success.
- klenwell 17y ago"Throughout human history, young men have been responsible for the vast preponderance of crime and violence—especially single men in countries where status and social acceptance depend on being married and having children, as it does in China and India. A rising population of frustrated single men spells trouble." In The Moral Animal, Robert Wright discusses this in addressing the social benefits of egalitarian, pro-monogamy social values. As a kind of real world experiment illustrating the meliorating effect of marriage, consider this: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2001/12/all-you-need-is-love/2351/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2001/12/all-you-... In the 1970s, the PLO reigned in the radical militant young men in Black September by marrying them off. Apart from the obvious horror of infanticide, this is what I find most unnerving about the widening gender skew in these countries.
- sruffell 17y agoI don't have anything new to say about the larger societal issues raised in this article, but as a father of a young daughter, this article certainly made me feel sad for all the daughters who aren't given a chance.
- kls 17y agoNo doubt, I read this article with my 2 year old daughter in my lap and my 3 year old son sitting in the other chair and cannot imagine choosing her over him or vice verse. It really makes you wonder how much societal norms affect things that seem like basic human tenants.
- Jun8 17y agoExactly! I don't have a daughter but the story resonated so powerfully that I cannot think of anything else this morning. This would be an interesting case to discuss with proponents of cultural relativism (pretty much everyone in academic circles), along with bride burning in India and female circumcision in Africa: I see absolutely no way you can defend it.
- detcader 17y agoWhat a blow against the Online Ads cause: I start to read the article, and a "subscribe now" popup slides right over the first paragraph. Nice.
- jpcx01 17y agoIt's the economist so I'll put up with anything they throw at me since they have such good content. Plus the ad was for their own product, and not some 3rd party crap. I guess I'm just happy whenever I can actually access an article there. I thought they put up a pay wall a few months back.
- scorciapino 17y agoMeh, this is a war against MEN. In a society with such a gender imbalance, women can be more picky and some men are left without hope of getting a partner. Without a partner, what are they going to focus on life, if not work? And who is gonna get their money when they die? Communists may be evil, but they aren't stupid, so it's unlikely they haven't foreseen this.
- orborde 17y agoIt's only great for the women who aren't murdered at birth. I'm not sure there's a clear winner in this gender war interpretation of yours. EDIT: Did the math and concluded that for a normal sex ratio of ~103 to turn into one of 120, you'd have you be losing 14 of every 100 females through either prenatal abortion or unreported killing at birth.
- hga 17y agoActually, things tend to get really ugly for girls in a society where they become a scarce and valuable resource for their families. E.g. their value is in what can be extracted in the marriage market (note the comments on how this is skewing savings in the PRC), not in what they intrinsically are. All in all I'd have to say this helps explain why the PRC is ramping up their police state (e.g. see http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704240504574585120857399040.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870424050457458...)
- lionhearted 17y ago> Communists may be evil, but they aren't stupid, so it's unlikely they haven't foreseen this. I'm in Cambodia right now. Communists are, in fact, quite stupid in addition to being evil. However, that doesn't really pertain to the infanticide thing, which is more a characteristic of very poor areas than communism.
- wooster 17y agoI have a friend whose mom told her: "I wish I'd left you to die when you were born." She's Chinese, and a successful Chinese-American entrepreneur. I can't even begin to imagine what a mindfuck that must be.
- billpg 17y agoMy favorite story is of someone who sold a treatment that guaranteed boys, offering a full money back guarantee if you had a girl. Half his customers were fully satisfied. Quite clever I thought.
- hga 17y agoA note on South Korea: It is by far the most Christian nation in Asia: 29% in the 2005 census and the largest (vs. 23% for Buddhism and 46.5% no religion). This is going to have very strong effects on social attitudes towards women and means what happened there in reversing this problem very probably won't elsewhere. Certainly not the PRC with its suppression of religion (of any non-Party dominated mass organization) and likely not in India with its well entrenched two major religions and their focus on each other.
- araneae 17y agoIf we wait long enough, this problem will fix itself. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fisher%27s_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fisher%27s_principle Too bad evolution is so slow.
- Retric 17y agoHumans don't have a 1:1 M/F ratio. It starts at ~1.05:1 at birth and with men dieing off sooner.
- Rexxar 17y agoThe 1.05:1 probably permits to have a 1:1 ratio at the age of reproduction in a pre-industrial societies.
- araneae 17y agoExactly. The only individuals relevant to evolutionary processes are those that reach reproductive age.
- DaniFong 17y agoCompletely false. Consider bees. Almost all females in a bee colony don't reproduce, but if the other females left the whole colony would collapse, no work would be done.
- araneae 17y agoFirst of all, honey bees are an exception to Fisher's principle. Secondly, your reasoning is more generally completely irrelevant. What you said was analogous to this: Children can kill their mothers in childbirth, so obviously kids before reproductive age are still relevant! Ok, so obviously non-reproductive individuals can affect the transmission of a person's genes. So can hurricanes, viruses, and cows. However, when you're solving your nice systems of differential equations to look at the evolutionary dynamics of various genes, you only consider reproductive individuals, because these are the only ones that transmit genes. Yes, non-reproductives can have effects in evolutionary dynamics, but only as passive environmental elements. Dying because you have a gene that makes you susceptible to a virus is the same as dying in childbirth, to evolutionary processes. There's natural selection against the genes that made you weak to the virus, and natural selection on the genes that made your fetus too large. I hope that makes sense. It can be hard to communicate with people from different fields; they use words differently than you do. (I'm a graduate student in evolutionary biology)
- akgerber 17y agoAs China grows economically what is the likelihood of it simply allowing female immigration and thus pass this problem off to poorer nations?
- rsheridan6 17y agoWhere are you going to find that many women? Nowhere but Africa, or possibly Latin America. That would lead to an interesting culture clash.