They're both still single malts, so a long way from tosh like Johnny Walker blends which are awful even with a stated age. :) I've only tried the Ardbeg, and i

They're both still single malts, so a long way from tosh like Johnny Walker blends which are awful even with a stated age. :) I've only tried the Ardbeg, and it's nice enough, but I'd call it a bit rough round the edges. Like tptacek, I'm wary of no-age, but if they get good enough to pass for long age complexity but bring them into my price range...