5 ms·
hang on, what? So in the USA the police can just take your personal possessions without providing any cause or reason? That doesn't sound like Freedom! to me,
by marcus_holmes 11y ago
hang on, what? So in the USA the police can just take your personal possessions without providing any cause or reason?
That doesn't sound like Freedom! to me, that sounds like a police state...
- tn13 11y agoNot only they can take they are under no obligation to even pursue charges. You have to prove your innocence to get your stuff back. Note: Police get to divide this loot among themselves (as their own private property) it does not even go to government coffers.
- marcus_holmes 11y agoSo if I'm a copper and I see someone with a nice shiny laptop I want, I can just stop them and take their laptop for my own? that's insane! Why aren't Americans rioting in the streets about this?
- virmundi 11y agoBecause the government always trots out drugs and terrorism as the defense. Americans hate drugs and terrorists. Therefore we need to stop their funding! Fortunately this family of stories are getting more ink and video. John Oliver did a show on it. Local stories popup about small time business owner trying to buy a truck getting screwed. So we are seeing two things America likes hitting heads: fighting terror and small businesses getting screwed. https://youtu.be/3kEpZWGgJks https://youtu.be/3kEpZWGgJks
- tn13 11y agoForget your shiny laptop. Imagine you own a hotel. Copper can catch some guy hanging out in your lobby claiming he might have drugs then take your motel and delivery van. Americans don't riot because they think "drug person lost his motel? who cares?".
- a3n 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carmen_Ortiz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carmen_Ortiz
- danieltillett 11y agoCarmel is a charming women. I think there is a need for more people like her in positions of almost total power. How can "hands off leadership" and "overzealousness" go wrong.
- tn13 11y agoI think Dark Triad is at work. You cant be a CIA agent unless you are good at lying but then you cant be expected to uphold law and be accountable for the exact same reason. A DA who has compassion for people, who tries to be nice and keep the community safe without being overzealous is likely to lose to someone who keep trash talking criminals, puts lot of people behind bars etc. "Mr. X is a child abuser, should he be sent to jail? " How can anyone answer NO to that question but in reality Mr. X married a girl of 17 years old and could have had a very happy married life.
- ccvannorman 11y agoHoly crap, I thought the poster had made that story about the motel up. The best part is, there is zero penalty for trying to take an entire hotel! It's like Grand Theft Auto in reverse with god mode on.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoKid has $40 worth of heroin in in his bedroom, parents' housed seized for being tied to a drug crime. http://www.cnn.com/2014/09/03/us/philadelphia-drug-bust-house-seizure/ http://www.cnn.com/2014/09/03/us/philadelphia-drug-bust-hous...
- a3n 11y agoPeople may make stories up, but there is often an actual occurrence that mirrors the story, even if the story and the occurrence are unrelated. In other words, even if you can demonstrate that a particular story is made up, it doesn't mean that it doesn't happen. It doesn't even mean that it doesn't happen often.
- pjc50 11y agoThe police are careful to prioritise nonwhite people for looting, and occasionally they do riot about their treatment by police. The fact that US police can shoot people dead without an external legal investigation is also riot material.
- nommm-nommm 11y ago>Why aren't Americans rioting in the streets about this? It isn't something that your average middle class American has to worry about too often. Cops mostly target the poor and people of color so the issues around civil forfeiture are largely unknown outside those who have experienced abuse of civil forfeiture. Just like how many white Americans think racism is a solved problem since they don't experience it personally.
- mapt 11y agoIt is. And it's explicitly forbidden by our Constitution. Efforts to pretend otherwise, but only for suspected drug dealers, lost that qualifier a decade or so ago when fiscal conservatives started to doom state governments to persistent budget shortfalls. Police departments lacking funding found themselves a status as highwaymen that the federal government (since Reagan) would tolerate, robbing out-of-state vehicles under cover of federal law and judicial precedent. These people swear an oath to uphold the Constitution. There is no wiggle room on this subject in the Bill of Rights for people to have their possessions stripped from their person absent a criminal conviction. Practitioners of 'civil asset forfeiture' are traitors to that oath and to their country, in addition to being guilty of the common crime of armed robbery. Why hasn't it been changed yet? * It's rare. This is not an everyday thing. * It often targets people on long-haul car journeys through what wealthy people (the sort who can afford lawyers) term 'the flyover states'. Most people do not want to battle this in court at least a days' drive from their home, on disadvantaged terms with a lawyer who will cost more than the goods in question. * Most wealthy people (the sort who can afford lawyers) no longer carry large amounts of cash. * State & local police departments have become reliant on it. Law enforcement agencies are extremely averse to going up against each other. Politicians with the power to shape law respond to the opinion of the people in the place they live and to local campaign donations by wealthy people, not to out-of-state victims.
- cauterized 11y agoPlus the cases in many states are framed in such a way that the cash itself is the defendant and the person it was taken from has no standing in the case. They make it essentially procedurally impossible to contest the seizure.
- marcus_holmes 11y agosurely this introduces a precedent for defence lawyers too though? "My client did not buy the drugs. My client's money bought the drugs. If my client has no standing in civil forfeiture then he also has no case to answer in criminal proceedings"
- InclinedPlane 11y agoNot exactly, but it's pretty bad. Here's the thing. There are two kinds of legal systems in the US, the civil system and the criminal justice system. In criminal justice there are tons and tons of protections for the rights of individuals, right to legal counsel, right to face your accusers, right of a jury trial, presumption of innocence, and very importantly the requirement that a trial find you guilty "beyond reasonable doubt" in order to mete out a sentence. In civil law a lot of that doesn't exist (the lowest rung being small claims court) and most importantly the requirement for a conviction is merely a "preponderance of the evidence" standard, meaning that it's more likely than not that the defendant committed the crime (i.e. 50 + epsilon percent chance). The kicker is that with civil forfeiture laws the accused is not a person, no individual has to be found guilty of a criminal offense, the accused is an item, a piece of property. This neatly skirts a lot of the protections of the constitution and civil law. The basic idea is that if you pull over Jim Bob on a country road and you take ten thousand dollars off his person you don't need to put Jim Bob on trial in criminal court and convict him to take any of his stuff, instead you can put the ten thousand dollars on trial in civil court and assess whether there was a greater than even odds that it was in some way involved in a crime (typically drug dealing) and then when a judge says "sure enough, that seems likely" you take that money and you use it to pad out the operating budget of your police agency. Seems ridiculous but it's been a major aspect of the "War on Drugs" for over 3 decades now. Consider, for example, this court case, the United States Versus $124,700 in US Currency: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._$124,700_in_U.S._Currency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._$124,700_in_U... This sort of thing happens on a regular basis day in day out. Hundreds of millions of dollars worth of goods and cash are seized every year in the US. And yes, it does sound like a police state. The War on Drugs has been one of the most extreme erosions of rights and liberties in the entire history of the US.
- marcus_holmes 11y agonice explanation, thanks :) It relies on the obvious farce of an inanimate object being able to commit a crime, though. Kinda flies in the face of "guns don't kill people..."
- phil21 11y agoGreat post, but the scale of the problem was off by an order of magnitude. The theft is measured in billions per year these days. It's hard to get an exact number since most of the data combines criminal and civil forfeiture - but even those numbers don't include all the state programs. From my reading on the topic I think it's fairly safe to say it's over the $2B/yr mark and growing.