4 ms·
If we believe the first form of life occurred on the sea floor, why shouldn't we believe that new forms of life are spontaneously occurring on the sea floor all
by CamperBob2 11y ago
If we believe the first form of life occurred on the sea floor, why shouldn't we believe that new forms of life are spontaneously occurring on the sea floor all the time?
Many people don't seem to understand just how incredibly different the environmental conditions on Earth were when life was first ramping up. Those conditions not only no longer prevail, but the world is also full of competitors that weren't there in the beginning.
Also, we probably haven't cataloged 10% of the life forms on our ocean floors yet. There's still a lot to learn, and there will be surprises.
- mentalpiracy 11y agoGlad you made this point. To expand on it a bit: Continuing abiogenesis may very well be occuring (in the very few locations that may still resemble the beginning), but at what complexity are we defining "life" when asking this question? Simple spontaneous assembly of RNA precursors? Something more fully fledged? In any case, the problem isn't even competitors that have evolved since then - it's the existence of complex metabolism. All of the "ingredients" you would need for abiogenesis to occur are now consumed by established organisms, ripping down the molecules for their own energy needs before they can catalyze into a more complex form. Life as we know it doesn't have room for the earliest products of abiogenesis anymore. Whatever form our earliest genetic ancestors may have taken, Earth's present-day micro-biosphere is simply too ubiquitous and too ravenous.