4 ms·
> He seems to have completed it in 5-6 years, which is average for full-time PhD students, so my question is what got left out? He did his PhD in the UK, where
by chrisseaton 11y ago
> He seems to have completed it in 5-6 years, which is average for full-time PhD students, so my question is what got left out?
He did his PhD in the UK, where 3 years is the norm for full-time.
UK PhDs are shorter for a number of reasons.
First we specialise earlier - normally just three related subjects from age 16 - I specialised on computation, discrete maths and physics - and from your first day at university you will only study your major and no other subjects such as liberal arts requirements.
Secondly, US students are still doing classes and exams while they're a PhD student. In the UK you are expected to be researching from the first day of your PhD and you don't do any classes or exams which take away time from your research.
Thirdly, US students spend I believe a lot of time doing things like being a teaching assistant, which have nothing to do with their research. I only did a couple of hours of teaching during my whole PhD. It seems crazy to me to spend time doing work like grading undergraduates when you are supposed to be making perhaps the major research contribution of your life!
Finally, I think there's a culture in the UK that you are released from your PhD as soon as you can show you can do it. So if you publish three top tier papers in two years then what else is there to prove?
- argonaut 11y agoUS CS PhD students only spend on average 2 semesters teaching (at Stanford/Berkeley/CMU, the requirement is roughly 2 terms of teaching, at MIT it's 1 term).