3 ms·
Borderline. Police boxes have their downsides. The OP missed one important distinction between Japanese and North American police architecture: Guns. A japan
by sandworm101 11y ago
Borderline. Police boxes have their downsides. The OP missed one important distinction between Japanese and North American police architecture: Guns. A japanese police officer may feel comfortable sitting at a fixed point, brightly lit, surrounded by darkness. A north american or even a UK officer will not... and probably should not. That's why those police buildings don't have big windows.
(Note the "best" example is actually Canadian, with a very different gun culture than the US. And the worst is in a rural part of the US where guns are the norm.)
Also, privacy. Japanese police do not interview people in the same manner or with the same regularity as north american police. North American police buildings need to be able to take people inside them without worry of someone snapping pictures from a car outside. They need a closed environment to interview suspects, witnesses, and any number of other people outside of public eye. That extends to police vehicles, which are regularly used to move people to places for interviews away from prying eyes. This is not as common in Japan.
Thirdly, density. North American policing involves a relatively few officers spread over a much greater area. Even our dense urban cores are more spread out than anything in Tokyo. Tying an officer to a fixed point severely limit's their area of operation. And an empty police box gives the impression of an absent force. North American deterrence relies on the concept that police 'might' be watching. Any clear indication that they are or aren't at a given time, whether or not the police box is empty, works against that deterrent.
- ricardobeat 11y agoWhy does all of that activity have to happen "away from prying eyes"?
- ascagnel_ 11y agoOn top of that, such activity can happen on upper floors or inside larger stations; these boxes don't take the place of larger centralized stations.
- sandworm101 11y agoBecause not everyone wants the entire neighborhood to see that they are meeting with a police officer, especially if you are reporting a crime by someone still walking around that neighborhood. Nor do police want to embarrass people. So it is normal to interview someone in a private place, without windows.
- EliRivers 11y agoBrisbane has them. Big open storefronts with open areas inside and a counter with a copper. Police there carry guns and the gun laws are much less restrictive than in the UK. They seemed pretty comfortable.