6 ms·
WhatsApp makes a lot of sacrifices to have encryption by default, like no backup of messages, no real ability for the servers to do anything smart, no real sear
by mike_hearn 11y ago
WhatsApp makes a lot of sacrifices to have encryption by default, like no backup of messages, no real ability for the servers to do anything smart, no real search functionality, desktop client that requires the phone to be on, etc.
An incognito mode allows the default mode to have more functionality, and matches their approach with Chrome. It's not a bad tradeoff.
- ikeboy 11y agoI don't get why encryption and incognito (not leaving a trace on the device) go together. I should be able to have one without the other.
- eightysix_four 11y agoDid you watch what Allo does? In its normal mode it couldn't possibly function with end-to-end encryption. They also have encryption to and from the server in the middle when you aren't in that mode.
- ikeboy 11y agoIncognito is a useful feature. E2E encryption is a useful feature. There's no reason to only allow those two features to be used together. You could have them both turned off by default, and have three modes, one which turns on E2E and one which turns on incognito. Also, the incognito decision should be made by each side independently. Just because I want to delete my traces doesn't mean my partner does.
- eightysix_four 11y agoI think this is a terminology issue - from what's been said elsewhere the only two differences in incognito mode is that it is E2E and doesn't show messages on your lockscreen. It's not ephemeral messaging like Snapchat or something, although they are discussing it as a future feature.
- ikeboy 11y agoI followed the arstechnica liveblog. http://live.arstechnica.com/google-io-2016-keynote/#post-885127 http://live.arstechnica.com/google-io-2016-keynote/#post-885... >Incognito also offers message expiration. When you close incognito mode, your message is gone forever. I assumed that was accurate. Did they misrepresent it somehow?
- eightysix_four 11y agoPossibly - the two sites I've seen with "hands-ons" do not mention this anywhere.
- ikeboy 11y agohttp://www.wsj.com/articles/google-takes-on-apple-facebook-with-allo-and-duo-chat-apps-1463599791 http://www.wsj.com/articles/google-takes-on-apple-facebook-w... (https://archive.is/ELitC https://archive.is/ELitC for paywall) >All chats will be encrypted, but a special incognito mode will have an end-to-end encryption, and expiring chats that are permanently deleted once you leave them.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> There's no reason to only allow those two features to be used together. UX simplicity is, in fact, a reason.
- ikeboy 11y agoThen have the default incognito be as described, with an option in settings to separate the two features.
- mike_hearn 11y agoI don't think you've thought this through. If one side enabled this "use E2E encryption for everything" feature, then the other side would presumably no longer have access to any of the smart assistant features. And it would not be obvious why. Additionally, it would be hard to explain why you'd ever want to enable such a feature which means nobody would do it. I suspect you want default E2E encryption for political reasons. Such things don't work unless it's on by default.
- ikeboy 11y ago>If one side enabled this "use E2E encryption for everything" feature That's not what I'm suggesting. I want E2E to be separate from the "delete chats when I'm finished" feature. Wanting an E2E chat that stays on my device when I'm done should be fine. I'm fine with having E2E require a separate mode, but that shouldn't be bundled with the incognito feature of not remembering history.
- mike_hearn 11y agoI see. In that case, yes it'd make sense to have such a feature, probably implemented as an archive button in the incognito window (with a warning that archiving such a chat makes it non-private).
- ikeboy 11y ago
- mtgx 11y agoI don't mind the two being used together. I've been using OTR in Gtalk/Hangouts for a long time, too (yes, I know Google actually keeps those messages anyway). However, I would like an option to make the Incognito mode the default (always-on), just like Firefox can make Private Mode the default. If Google wants people to believe it cares about their privacy (which is probably the reason they're even doing this in the first place), then it should not just offer the feature to them in an obscure way, but it should make it easy for them to use it if that's what they want.
- tdkl 11y ago> If Google wants people to believe it cares about their privacy They don't, it's just more easibly marketable this way since it's a checkmark on someones Powerpoint slide. > but it should make it easy for them to use it if that's what they want. Google doesn't cater to users, since they aren't customers (services are free), but advertisers are.
- mtgx 11y agoI think it could if the AI was done locally, but don't expect Google to do that anytime soon, even if it becomes technically feasible and cheap to do. Didn't Apple already employ some client-side AI for photos and gave the reason that this is for privacy? I don't recall what the feature was exactly though. As a sign of good faith, Google could also stop data-mining Hangouts now, since they have Allo for that, and make Hangouts end-to-end encrypted by default.
- mderazon 11y agoThey wouldn't be able to insert a chat bot to all of your conversations if they were all end to end encrypted. I agree it's a good trade-off
- ikeboy 11y agoBut why not allow E2E without incognito? Have both as separate options.
- dragonwriter 11y agoProbably because proliferation of options is bad for UX for most user types and bad for uptake, and "incognito" is what they've named the package of privacy-related options, including E2E.
- skybrian 11y agoIt seems to me that it's simpler to understand. If you really want to keep something a secret, it's probably not a good idea to keep a copy on your (or their) phone. Providing separate options would make it easier to make mistakes.
- ikeboy 11y agoPretty much no other E2E app feels the same way, and certainly doesn't enforce that.
- nl 11y agoWhat use-case does E2E without incognito address? * Sharing naked pics on a monitored work network? No - there is at least some chance that your company owns your device, so therefore you want it to disappear from that * Sharing politically outlawed content? No - you can be compelled to give up your device. Wanting it "just because" is fine, but simplifying the UI is a pretty valid counter argument too.
- nothrabannosir 11y ago
- nkobeissi 11y ago> WhatsApp makes a lot of sacrifices to have encryption by default, like no backup of messages Small clarification: WhatsApp actually does seem to have a backup feature, at least on my Android phone. I was prompted by the application to enable it just this morning.
- subliminalpanda 11y agoMessage backup is there on iOS too.
- noja 11y ago> WhatsApp makes a lot of sacrifices to have encryption by default, like no backup of messages Huh? I have backup of messages. > no real search functionality I can search on my phone. > desktop client that requires the phone to be on, etc. I want this: the messages should live on my phone.
- rmc 11y agoDidn't WhatsApp Web require the phone to be on, before they got encryption?
- subliminalpanda 11y agoIt still does