4 ms·
Two biology events (not sure this book covers) that are completely underestimated. 1) evolution of cyanobacteria as a freak merger of green-sulfur and purple p
by dnautics 11y ago
Two biology events (not sure this book covers) that are completely underestimated.
1) evolution of cyanobacteria as a freak merger of green-sulfur and purple photosynthetic bacteria. Well, biological historians DO understand the importance of this, but the reason why the chemistry is important is not well appreciated. Cyanos use water as a reductant - as an electron donor. Normally one does not think of water as a reductant, but as a facilitator oxidation. This is biology's "great umpolung chemistry" moment.
2) The great oxidation catastrophe. Because oxygen, the oxidized poop of the previous process is highly toxic, there was a huge exinction event across pretty much all clades. But some of the emergent chemistry (disulfide bonds e.g.) really enabled structural scaffolding that facilitated higher order cellular structure. Mitochondria went into hiding inside of the reducing environment of an proto-archaeal species and boom - eukaryotes.
3) The size and distance of the earth from the sun. Hydrogen at ambient temperature achieves escape velocity. This means the net chemical trend over billions of years was oxidizing. One wonders if this made the first two chemical processes somewhat inevitable.
I'd also like to point out that thinking parsimoniously about energy from an evolutionary standpoint is not necessarily productive. For example: There's a lot of junk DNA (VNTRs, e.g.) which do not seem to be subject to aggressive optimivation for energy.
- lumpypua 11y agoYes, this book and the author's previous books cover exactly those topics among others. Nick Lane is a fucking awesome writer.
- dnautics 11y agoIt's not the events themselves that are underestimated- it's the details. Do the books specifically address using water as a reductant? My experience is that not even scientists in the field (I worked at reprogramming hydrogen-producing enzymes) have a full appreciation of how bizzare that is.
- lumpypua 11y agoMy chemistry background is pretty weak so I don't know if it touches the specific points you're curious about, but there's a pretty extensive discussion of electron transport and what all the mechanisms we see in the world today tell us about how life began to harness it. He ends up using the discussion to make the argument that all life in the universe likely uses redox chemistry for energy. Made sense to me anyway.
- dnautics 11y ago> He ends up using the discussion to make the argument that all life in the universe likely uses redox chemistry for energy. If that's the conclusion, it's trivially true, since basically you can assign a redox value to every chemical transformation using the nernst equation. The interesting thing is that IMO the resistance to the conceptual framework behind the way that the mitochondrion works was because it was hard for biochemists to picture the proton motive force (concentration gradient) as a redox potential (it truly is one) because it seemed more physics-ey than biochemistry-ey. Peter Mitchell cleared that up amidst quite a bit of controversy. He had to go to the lengths of setting up an independent research institute to get the work done.
- areyousure 11y agoYou should read the book and tell us whether it lives up to your standards. If so, then we know that the book is a particularly valuable contribution.
- rusanu 11y agoOxygen, a previous book from Nick, cover these topics in great detail. The Vital Question deals with events that long predate the cyanobacteria, the Great Oxygenation Event and how we avoided oceans evaporating into space under UV radiation (at least the first chapters of the book, rest of it covers mostly origin of eukaryotic cell).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- danieltillett 11y agoI am not too sure we know how Cyanobacteria arose (I did my Ph.D. on them) nor how mitochondria arose. Given how rampant horizontal gene transfer is I doubt we ever will. I think the most interest question in this early biology is why LUCA is so complex [1]. We have a massive gap between abiotic processes and the first organism we know anything about. What happened. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Last_universal_ancestor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Last_universal_ancestor
- acqq 11y agoThanks. There are some hints to "why" on the page you link to: "Before high fidelity replication, organisms could not be easily mapped on a phylogenetic tree. Not to be confused with the Ur-organism, however, the LUCA lived after the genetic code and at least some rudimentary early form of molecular proofreading had already evolved. It was not the very first cell, but rather, the one whose descendents survived beyond the very early stages of microbial evolution." And the question that fascinates me is "where are these primitive forms"? Even if the original forms evolved since, why can't we find at least some "improved" forms that use these more primitive principles than the ones we're accustomed to?
- wolf550e 11y agoThey competed with modern bacteria and lost?
- acqq 11y agoYes, I'm aware of that hypothesis. But everywhere, forever? It can also be we'll never know, as the life on Earth apparently existed for so long, billions of years, since the times the whole Earth was completely different than we know now (from the life's point of view). Which is also fascinating, as on the Universe level we can actually observe the glow of the Big Bang, which happened much earlier.
- lawpoop 11y agoExtinction is only a macro-phenomenon?
- Evgeny 11y agoNormally one does not think of water as a reductant, but as a facilitator oxidation. Normally I don't think of water in either way ...
- dnautics 11y ago1) rust 2) if you do the basic transformation (addition of water to alkene, https://www.khanacademy.org/science/organic-chemistry/alkenes-alkynes/alkene-reactions/v/addition-of-water-acid-catalyzed-mechanism#! https://www.khanacademy.org/science/organic-chemistry/alkene...) biochemically and chemically speaking you usually assign an integral oxidation change of 0, but in reality, the alcohol is slightly higher oxidization state than the alkene.