6 ms·
people will stop going to the hospital to give birth, raising the rate of mortality and complications for infants and mothers. According to Healthcare Triage,
by stcredzero 11y ago
people will stop going to the hospital to give birth, raising the rate of mortality and complications for infants and mothers.
According to Healthcare Triage, home births have an overall lower risk of complications. It's only in the cases of things going spectacularly wrong that being in the hospital helps.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xHWvSPhENtk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xHWvSPhENtk
It fits with my view of things: If there's something really broken, go to the hospital to get it fixed. However, if you're fine, you're better off avoiding the place. (Do get checkups from a doctor you have a good relationship with.)
- JshWright 11y agoWhen it comes to having a baby, things can go from "perfectly normal" to "spectacularly wrong" in a (literal) heartbeat. The vast majority of the time, that doesn't happen, but when it does, I'd rather be down the hall from an OR, rather than a 20 minute ambulance ride away...
- epoxyhockey 11y agoAgreed! Even in the article, the woman needed an emergency c-section.
- hackbinary 11y agoPre modern medical times, like before the 1930's or so, something like 1 in 10 women died in child birth.
- stcredzero 11y agoI've heard the same statistic. I wonder where it comes from. Also, the overall chance of pregnancy with unprotected sex involving a man and a woman of childbearing age is 1 in 4. So, would you engage in such sex knowing that there was a 1 in 40 chance it would lead directly to your own death? (Or your partners? Bees be Krayton!) I wonder if that's where some of our cognitive biases around risk come from? It benefits our genes that we're cavalier about certain kinds of risk.
- JshWright 11y agoI don't know that the numbers in this thread have any basis in reality, but even if they did... sex is fun?
- MaxfordAndSons 11y agoThe first number you give is wildly inaccurate. It rises to about 35% in the +/-1 day window around ovulation, with lower probability during a wider weeklong window, and very near 0 for the rest of the menstrual cycle. I'm fairly sure the actual compounded odds of conception from procreative sex at a random point in the woman's cycle is much closer to 1 in 1000. Also unprotected sex does not necessarily equal procreative sex, which I realize is a somewhat controversial statement, but nonetheless true.
- hackbinary 11y agoReally? Controversial, yes. Do you have any science to back that up?
- MaxfordAndSons 11y agoIt's really a matter of semantics, not science. Either party could be incapable of providing the needed input. But also yes, to address the controversiality, the withdrawal method, used perfectly, is a 96% effective [0] contraceptive method vs. 98% for condoms used perfectly [1]. Obviously the prerequisites for perfect use are different and YMMV. [0] https://www.plannedparenthood.org/learn/birth-control/withdrawal-pull-out-method https://www.plannedparenthood.org/learn/birth-control/withdr... (there's no fragment, it's under the effectiveness section of the accordion) [1] https://www.plannedparenthood.org/learn/birth-control/condom/how-effective-are-condoms https://www.plannedparenthood.org/learn/birth-control/condom...
- stcredzero 11y agoThe first number you give is wildly inaccurate. I knew that when I posted it. When I posted it, I thought I had clearly indicated it, but looking at it again, that must have been forgotten before it could be enacted. My intention was to play with the two wildly inaccurate figures together.
- brianwawok 11y agoSo what if 1/200 times your baby was saved by being closer to the doctors... but 1/180 times your baby got a Staph Infection they would not have gotten at home and died? The numbers are obviously bogus, but there are dangers to anyplace you choose to give birth... As long as people are well informed, seems they should be able to choose their own adventure.
- Vraxx 11y agoExcept the numbers that aren't bogus seem to suggest that birthing at home can be much more dangerous for mothers and children. I'm not saying that there's no room for improvement at the hospital, there always will be, but when we don't use fake numbers your point doesn't hold water. I'll refer to another user's comment in this article's thread for the citation. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11724332 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11724332
- brianwawok 11y agoWalking is much more dangerous than being carried in a litter, yet we let people do it all the time. Drinking a hot beverage is much more dangerous than drinking a cold beverage. Life is full of dangers and risks. Why should birth be any different? I could post many stories of people who had their first kid in a hospital and had a horrible experience, ends up getting a C section when not really needed, etc (See american C-section rates vs European for example). Then they chose to have a kid at home and had a 100x better experience and a more healthy baby (due to lack of C section and all the problems that leads to).
- carc 11y agoI've heard the exact same argument from an anti-vaccer :)
- stcredzero 11y agoWhat's bad about anti-vaxxers isn't that they weigh relative risks and make a decision. What's bad is that they spread wildly inaccurate information about what those risks are, which causes people to make faulty decisions that increase the risks for others in the community. What you are doing here, is glossing over the underlying logic and falsely reasoning by resemblances. I find this sort of false reasoning flat-out stupid. It needs to be called out so others do not imitate it. (Which is a more meaningful resemblance to anti-vaxxers your comment is exhibiting.)
- koolba 11y ago> According to Healthcare Triage, home births have an overall lower risk of complications. I'd be very surprised if that was a controlled study accounting for people who are at risk of complications making sure to deliver in a hospital. > It's only in the cases of things going spectacularly wrong that being in the hospital helps. Which you wouldn't really know in advance as it comes up during the delivery itself.
- JshWright 11y agoThe major study Dr Carroll referenced did indeed look at planned vs unplanned out of hospital births.
- ygjb-dupe 11y ago> It's only in the cases of things going spectacularly wrong that being in the hospital helps. Yep. My wife had a perfectly normal pregnancy, and everything went perfectly until something went spectacularly wrong. When my daughter was born, and didn't breath on her own for the first 3 minutes. If she hadn't been in a hospital, it would have gone down as still born. She was in the hospital, immediately received resuscitation and numerous other treatments which maintained her blood oxygen level sufficient to prevent brain damage, and now at the age of 4 is ahead of every developmental measure. "It's only in the case of things going spectacularly wrong" that any risk mitigation activity actually provides value, and in every other case is essentially worthless. YMMV, but I tell everyone I can the story of my daughter whenever they talk about home birth.
- Arnt 11y agoI agree with the larger sentiment, but don't be so quick, it's a game of chance even when shit happens. One of my daughters too didn't breathe when she was born. The midwives grew very very ernest very very quickly, and the little child was rushed off to hospital in an ambulance. All went fine. I was a little shaky that first night.
- ygjb-dupe 11y agoLife is a game of chance, but we make our own luck (beyond what we are born with) by making sensible decisions, taking measured chances, and knowing when to admit we are out of our depth. Yes, midwives (in some jurisdictions) are trained, qualified practitioners. That said, they are not equipped to deal with many, many complications other than by calling an ambulance and hoping for the best. Choosing to have my daughter born in a hospital instead of a home birth was most likely the difference between having a healthy baby girl and something in the range of severe mental handicap to stillbirth. Having a child is a huge risk and investment (by every measure, emotionally, financially, socially, economically, etc). Why would you risk having a stillborn child, life with a mentally or physically handicapped child (this is not a shot against handicapped children - it's a shot against people who refuse to apply critical thinking skills to emotionally charged high risk decisions) so that you can satisfy some foolish ideal that being born at home is better than being born around people who have trained for much of their adult lives to keep your kid alive in its first few days? It ranks right up there with the foolish parents who refuse to vaccinate children against common ailments or choose naturopathy or homeopathy because of "toxic western medicine".
- dragonwriter 11y ago> According to Healthcare Triage, home births have an overall lower risk of complications. It's only in the cases of things going spectacularly wrong that being in the hospital helps. "Complications" is a broad categories and includes many things that may not lead to adverse outcomes if managed appropriately, and which hospitals may be more prepared to manage. According to this study of Oregon births in the NEJM, planned out-of-hospital births studied have substantially higher rates of infant death and neonatal seizures than planned in-hospital births (and these results are, per the study, in line with other studies of out-of-hospital vs. in-hospital births.) http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa1501738 http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa1501738
- gdubs 11y agoFor a different perspective: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/01/opinion/sunday/why-is-american-home-birth-so-dangerous.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/01/opinion/sunday/why-is-amer...
- pm24601 11y agoHow about just decriminalize being a drug user/addict and focus on treatment. Where things went wrong and bad in the story is the attitude of the nurses. The social worker who initially responded was no presumptive and did the smart thing of not escalating the issue.