4 ms·
> effectively skim off of the top of the market The problem with this point of view is that it implies they are just taking, and not providing. HFT provides a
by kbenson 11y ago
> effectively skim off of the top of the market
The problem with this point of view is that it implies they are just taking, and not providing. HFT provides a more accurate market price by providing liquidity at small price differences. Whether what they provide justifies their cost is another question though.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoIt's algorithms guessing about something in nanoseconds with little context. Feels like that would reduce accurate pricing. Not a finance guy, though, so my intuition could be wrong.
- kbenson 11y agoTo make money, they have to be accurately pricing. If the spread on something was $0.50, meaning that there are people on record as willing to buy at $0.50 lower than others are on record as willing to sell, the real price is somewhere within that range. Presumably, the real value of the stock is somewhere in the middle, but we don't know, because there's not any transactions happening right now, and the real value of something is the value at which people are willing to exchange it. HFT firms provide liquidity, in a lot more transactions, and at smaller spreads than regular people are willing to do (because HFT firms can automate away much of the work). This results in a more accurate price (smaller spread), and you being more likely to sell at that price (even if it's to a HFT). At least, that's the theory. I'm not a finance guy, but I've followed it here for quite a while, and this is my general impression of it. I used to be fairly anti-HFT until I learned more about it. Now I'm somewhat ambivalent, except for the topic of rogue trading algorithms, which seem fairly dangerous, but the genie's out of the bottle.
- Retric 11y agoOne of the most useful HFT tools is to reduce liquidity. Doing this over an hour would cost ridiculous amounts of money, but cornering a specific exchange over 0.01 seconds is cheap and potentially profitable. Remember, if a HFT extracts money that means the actual seller and actual buyer's price never meets which means the market is not doing accurate price discovery instead providing two prices separated by fractions of a second.
- kbenson 11y agoHmm, in which case I guess it would be more accurate to say that HFT's provide some limited ability to control liquidity, whether that's increasing it or decreasing it. Assuming decreased liquidity is bad (I don't know if there's situations where it's seen as beneficial to the market), the question is how to we disincentivize the use of the ability to decrease liquidity that HFTs have, or do we just accept it as a consequence of their participation, and accept that it happens from regular brokers as well?
- gnaritas 11y agoWhat? None of that made any sense. The only way they can reduce liquidity is to stop trading, or buy it all up, neither of which is bad. > Remember, if a HFT extracts money that means the actual seller and actual buyer's price never meets which means the market is not doing accurate price discovery instead providing two prices separated by fractions of a second. Just no, that is not at all correct. HFT increases price accuracy, it doesn't reduce it.
- Retric 11y agoLiquidity means the price is stable not that trades will go through.* Stable prices prevent HFT traders from making money. Price accuracy is somewhat debatable. Many HFT traders may toss lot's of trades around at a price, but that does not mean you can buy or sell large numbers of shares at that price as they can easily just be trading relatively small number of shares back and forth. *Dramatic price swings are often tacked onto this. But, that's also relative to number of shares traded. If selling 1,000 shares at ~20.00 each involves any price shift it's hard to call that stable.
- gnaritas 11y ago> Liquidity means the price is stable not that trades will go through.* Stable prices prevent HFT traders from making money. No, liquidity means there's limit orders sitting on the market. That is quite literally all liquidity is. > Stable prices prevent HFT traders from making money. No they don't, stable prices are good for market makers as it reduces the risk of flipping the spread. You can sit there all day long without prices moving a lick and make bank buying at the bid and selling at the ask getting pad the spread for providing liquidity; this is what HFT's want to do. Directional movement, aka volatility, increases the risk for market makers, aka HFTs as it forces them to predict a direction and makes their trades more risky. Yes, some strategies work better with volatility, but market making is the least risky when price doesn't move at all because you're not making your money from the volatility but from the pocketing the spread over and over.
- gnaritas 11y ago> Feels like that would reduce accurate pricing. Nope, exactly the opposite, it creates better pricing. HFT is a bidding war to see who can create the best prices and still make enough profit to survive, this reduces trading costs for everyone else by reducing the spread.
- jandrese 11y agoIsn't this exactly the opposite effect? You place a bid for what is currently showing on the market, and the HFT firms use their speed advantage go and buy up most of the stock at that price and relist it for a bit more. So the price is never what you actually think it is, it is what you see plus whatever the HFT firm decides to add. HFT firms can't provide liquidity--they don't hold positions! At the end of the day their books are all 0.
- gpderetta 11y agoThat's not how markets work. If an HFT firm saw your order resting, means that nobody wanted to trade with you at that price in the first place. If you cross the market then there is nothing the HTF firm can do. When it becomes aware of your order it will be too late. Of course the order you want to trade with might have disappeared while your order is in flight, but that would not be casually related to you sending the order to the market.
- jandrese 11y agoYou're forgetting that "the market" isn't one monolithic thing anymore, it's a number of independent exchanges. Your order goes out to all of them, and the HFT firm sees it on the nearest market then races (and beats!) your offer to all of the other markets. That's why they care about nanoseconds so much, they're racing the speed of light. That's why you get a tiny fraction of your bid filled and then everything else suddenly dries up and is relisted at a higher price (aka Arbitrage).
- gnaritas 11y agoThat's grossly oversimplified and wrong. > Your order goes out to all of them, and the HFT firm sees it on the nearest market then races (and beats!) your offer to all of the other markets. No, they have no idea or way to know if your order was big enough to even go to other markets; if they rush out ahead of you and you don't show up, they lose money. What they do is not risk free. > That's why they care about nanoseconds so much, they're racing the speed of light. Incorrect. They about latency because all traders have always cared about being first to get their orders in and this would matter whether HFT existed or not. They're not racing the speed of light, they're racing other traders and that would happen no matter the speed of the trading. It's not the speed that matters, it's being first that matters. Even if you outlawed HFT, being first would still matter except it'd be human traders seeing who could push buttons faster.