2 ms·
Why is this money taken from "European Cloud Initiative"? It has nothing to do with it. Is the comission aware of this fact? Are all those research institut
by nabla9 11y ago
Why is this money taken from "European Cloud Initiative"? It has nothing to do with it. Is the comission aware of this fact?
Are all those research institutions standing behind claimed security impact of their work? Were security experts and cryptographers involved, or is this just wild speculation from physicists as DJB's Theory 2 assumes.
I'm all for moving more EU money to basic research, but money can be moved to the direction I want with wrong promises.
- ThePhysicist 11y agoHonestly this is the first time that I hear this claim, and I cannot judge whether it is true or not (I will try to find out). What I know is that the money for the flagship projects was allocated around five years ago already (within the Horizon 2020 programme), and I am not aware of any relation to the European Cloud Initiative. The only mention of cloud computing at the conference was in the context of providing Quantum Computing capabilities over the cloud as a means to make these technologies accessible to a wider audience as soon as possible, as buying a quantum computer will probably be beyond the capabilities of most individuals / organizations for the foreseeable future.
- nabla9 11y ago€2 billion in Horizon 2020 funding will be allocated to the European Cloud Initiative[1]. Quantum manifesto lists many items that might be funded under the Cloud Initiative [2], - Core technology of quantum repeaters - Secure point-to-point quantum links - Quantum networks between distant cities - Quantum credit cards - Quantum repeaters with cryptography and eavesdropping detection - Secure Europe-wide internet merging quantum and classical communication - Universal quantum computers will be available with computational power at a level of performance that will exceed even the most powerful classical computers of the future. They will be reprogrammable machines used to solve demanding computational problems, such as optimisation tasks, database searches, machine learning and image recognition. They will contribute to Europe’s smart industry, helping to make European manufacturing industries more efficient. [1]: http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-16-1409_en.htm http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-16-1409_en.htm [2]: http://qurope.eu/system/files/u567/Quantum%20Manifesto.pdf http://qurope.eu/system/files/u567/Quantum%20Manifesto.pdf
- ThePhysicist 11y agoThe question is whether the 1 Bn. € allocated to quantum computing would have been spent on other cloud technologies instead, which in my understanding is not the case. As far as my understanding goes the flagship money was distributed via an open propsal-based process, so I really don't see how this money was "stolen" from other initiatives, as the goal of this kind of funding is to let researchers compete for it by making convincing proposals.
- nabla9 11y agoThe way I see it the question is not that proposal based process itself was fair. The question is if the winning proposals made credible promises. Did the commission know it funded basic research without practical solutions in the sight, or did they read material like Quantum Manfiesto and thought there would be commercial and infrastructure benefits? I'm leaning towards Theories 2 and 3: stupidity and marketing. Physicists who want to build quantum devices made claims outside their expertise and the commission didn't consult experts to verify these claims because it generally has no idea of what it's funding.
- ThePhysicist 11y agoYou should not assume that the EU commission is stupid, as they have a large department which employs experts across many fields (mostly scientists as well) that informs policymakers about the risks and potential of these things. And concerning the potential risk of failure: Yes, everyone is aware of that. The flagship projects fund research, which means that there is a risk of failure and that we don't know all the details yet (otherwise it would be engineering). The funding bodies are fully aware of this and they do not expect that every project they fund will work out, but they know that today's research is tomorrow's revenue.
- nabla9 11y agoDJB is one of the leading experts in the field. Who are the security experts who think that quantum communication premises could lead to practical implementations? Even if the base research is successful, most experts agree that quantum communication is solution searching for problem. We can already transmit data securely trough bit-pipes using quantum resistant symmetric ciphers. Actual security problems are on different level (protocols etc.)