5 ms·
New Evidence for the Necessity of Loneliness
- sridca 11y ago> the pain of being alone motivates us to seek the safety of companionship, Yes. > which in turn benefits the species by encouraging group cooperation and protection. Yet, a fear-driven cooperation and protection is bollocks compared to a spirited one (as illustrated by the French expressions bien dans ma peau and joie de vivre).
- lgas 11y agoPerhaps you could elaborate on that? I know what both expressions mean but I have no idea what it is that you think they illustrate about cooperation, loneliness, etc.
- sridca 11y agoOne is fear-driven, and thus highly dependent on other people's granting of validation. The other is self-generated spirited enjoyment of anything one might do, with little dependance on the validation provided by other people. Essentially, the difference is to do with which set of emotions are being dominant: loneliness/ validation/ approval-seeking versus enjoyment/ spiritedness/ play. Think of the fun inherent in hobbyist programming, but extended to life at large.
- curiousgal 11y agoAnother French expression to go along would be Sartre's "Hell is other people". Which is the reason I choose to distance myself from people.
- sridca 11y agoWithdrawal is a common reaction to stress (loneliness). However a reaction is not necessarily a solution.
- icanhackit 11y agoA lot of people who isolate themselves can be perfectly normal and it can be a valid solution to the source of their stress. Deep thinking, introspection and creativity thrives without interruption. It depends on the individual.
- sridca 11y agoThe only solution that is worth its name is the utter or virtual absence of the problem (loneliness) it is intended to solve, otherwise it is a second-rate one. Withdrawal, no matter how "valid" and "normal" as deemed by a segment of society, does not fall under that felicitous characterization. Do the people that withdraw generally demonstrate bien dans ma peau and joie de vivre?
- icanhackit 11y ago> Do the people that withdraw generally demonstrate bien dans ma peau and joie de vivre? Generally, no. But if someone withdrew to a monastery to seek enlightenment then this question lacks significance. Withdrawal can be a tool that allows us to control envy, desire, distraction and other aspects of human existence which can be destructive or a mental nuisance. How would you posit your question to an existential nihilist? To them it would have no meaning.
- sridca 11y ago> Generally, no. Then, no matter how “valid” and “normal” their modus operandi may be it is of no relevance to someone looking to enjoy life (bien dans ma peau and joie de vivre) instead of wasting time — and it is indeed such a waste of life, don’t you think — feeling alone or withdrawing (via dissociating from the said loneliness). > How would you posit your question to an existential nihilist? To them it would have no meaning. It takes the naiveté (innocence/ unsophistication; not gullibility) of a child to want to enjoy life. Nihilists, and spiritualists, are too sophisticated for that.
- jdbernard 11y ago
- dominotw 11y agoI might be reading this wrong but their evidence seems like its not consistent and they explain this away with this speculation. "Neurons are somehow tapping into that subjective social experience of the mouse, and only producing a significant effect on the behavior of mice who perhaps previously valued their social connections, rather than those who did not" So what exactly is the proof ? They also explain that this might lead to two possibilities social vs antisocial mice . How did they even come up with these possibilities surely from their own experience and understanding of the world.So they are starting on with hypothesis that they came up with and end up with inconsistent results and claim that as proof. tl;dr hypothesis1: loneliness corresponds to dopamine -> not conclusive -> hypothesis2: results explained by social position of mouse -> further testing needed
- baron816 11y agoI really wish more startups focused on ending loneliness. It has to be the worst problem afflicting advanced countries, but it's all but ignored for fancy hi-tech stuff and anything that will make you're life slightly more convenient. I've started Krewe (https://www.gokrewe.com/get_started https://www.gokrewe.com/get_started) to help people make a group of friends in their neighborhood and build a strong local community, but I think there should be other companies who's focus is on fostering real personal interaction.
- bksenior 11y agoIndirectly the whole messaging and social media culture is built on this simple premise. There are a ton of companies doing it, just not how you would expect it. Note: I know it causes more lonliness
- Terr_ 11y agoAlas, it's much harder to sell something to people who are truly content. This means most self-help organizations are either non-profit, bankrupt, or foster customer-dependence on their line of products or advice or books etc.
- sametmax 11y agoLoneliness is not a technical problem, a startup will not solve anything. Evolving as a society will sove this, and for a society to evolve, its parts must evolve. So the first step to end loneliness is to work on yourself.
- baron816 11y agoDoes every startup solve a technical problem?
- feelix 11y agoRecently I've found myself a bit lonely at times due to changing circumstances and a lack of being introduced to other people that would like some more friends. I have gone to a few meetups. Which is a technology based product. It has helped me meet people and end loneliness. This has nothing to do with the evolution of society, as you put it.
- dschiptsov 11y agoWhy, we are social animals, whose kids and elders can't survive alone. No surprise that there is appropriate machinery in the brain, or rather that machinery gives rise to what we call empathy, parental care, altruism, family and in-group bonds, etc. Apart from that, other people are constant source of problems, distraction, annoyance, due to their narcissistic tendencies to assert themselves, to show off, to gain attention, to validate their inflated self-esteem, their extremely annoying primitive and rude attempts to manipulate, use, cheat, take advantage of others, etc. Truly "Hell is other people". Moreover, they tend to validate everyone according to their artificial, biased socially constructed "norms", which leads to hegemony of mediocrity and much uglier things, like hunweibins and similar cancer-like social formations. So, the balance is subtle - as long as we are dependent of each other for survival, which reflects each and every clan or tribal societies, we are OK. But since we have forsed to live in too much crowded, overpopulated, highly competitive urban areas of post-infustrialized societies, everything is doomed. The only thing Marx got right is alienation.) Back to loneliness. Loneliness is a prerequisite for any intellectual or spiritual (which is an ancient word of intelligence) achievement. Less other people - less worries, less distractions, tension, noise, pressure, cruelty, violence. That's why everywhere in the world monasteries has walls and no academics work in Starbucks. Loneliness should be understood as necessity, like privacy and embraced. Unless you are a brick in the wall, a living cell, a soldier or a drone.
- pond_lilly 11y agoIt is not that simple. Many of domestic violence victims would have been alive today had they not chosen to stay with their abusers because of fear of loneliness. In a sense, the same mechanism that urges individuals to end loneliness might as well lead to their death, because in their desperation they associate with violent and dangerous people. It could be argued that in situations like that fear of loneliness is maladaptive.