3 ms·
There is almost no evidence that rent control is the primary, secondary or even tertiary cause of San Francisco's woes. As https://medium.com/newco/a-guy-just-
by btilly 11y ago
There is almost no evidence that rent control is the primary, secondary or even tertiary cause of San Francisco's woes. As https://medium.com/newco/a-guy-just-transcribed-30-years-of-for-rent-ads-heres-what-it-taught-us-about-sf-housing-prices-bd61fd0e4ef9#.r7qldtd56 https://medium.com/newco/a-guy-just-transcribed-30-years-of-... shows, the long-term price curves barely change in 1979 when rent control came into existence.
The three things that matter are the amount of housing, the number of jobs there are, and the total salary paid for those jobs. See the article for the formula. I am sure that a similar formula applies in San Francisco. The result is that having or not having rent control is immaterial. Being unwilling to build housing is a problem.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- aorloff 11y agoRent control helps the well connected, not necessarily those who need it : http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB122126309241530485 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB122126309241530485 and ties up existing inventory. I know people here in SF who have an apartment, and own a house or two outside the city, but will never give up their apartment because its just so cheap. Rent control definitely ties up supply.
- btilly 11y agoIn theory, absolutely! In practice the effects seem to be small.
- dietrichepp 11y agoThe evidence presented in the article you linked is really not strong enough to support your conclusion with reasonable certainty. It's using a massive "post hoc ergo proper hoc" fallacy to prop up a weak argument. "Ties up supply" is also a statement that is not necessarily connected to "increases price". I'm not entirely clear on the economic theories behind rent control, but from what I understand, it affects availability more than it affects price.
- refurb 11y agoI don't think you claim rent control has no impact from that data. What would rents done without rent control? We'll never know. Maybe the increases would have flattened out? One can imagine what would have happened without rent control. Prices would have gone up for everyone and people would have left, increasing the supply. I'm not saying that's a desirable outcome, or necessarily a large impact, but artificially keeping rents low for some people would logically reduce supply and increase rents.
- btilly 11y agoI agree that economic theory says that rent control should increase rents. But is it a large or small impact? This is harder to answer. The available data suggests that the impact is relatively small compared to other factors. Small enough that the average annual increase before and after was almost unchanged. In fact theory says that rent control should mostly matter because of reduced incentives to build more housing. But other policies (like zoning laws) more directly reduce the ability to add capacity, and so should matter more.
- randyrand 11y agoEconomic theory says rent control should create shortages, not necessarily drive up rates. But, since rent control is only on a few building, it increases rents in the rest of them. The options are: 1. rent control everything, and let there be shortages, old buildings, etc 2. rent control some, and let half the city be expensive 3. build housing.
- btilly 11y agoSupply/demand curves say that creating shortages will drive up rates. If you rent control everything, you will create black markets at much higher rates. Other than that, you're right. Except that in the case of San Francisco, most of the city is under rent control. However the rate resets to the current market rate every time a tenant moves out and another moves in. If you assume regular renter turnover, then rent control changes the short-term path but does not necessarily change the long-term trajectory of rents much. Reality says at least one of three things will be true. You can be undesirable to live in, build lots of housing, or have rising rents. San Francisco tries to avoid all three, and does less to prevent rents going up than the others so that is what happens.
- ryanwaggoner 11y agoReally hope that link isn't your only source for such a strong claim. Isn't rent control being bad one of the very few things that almost all economists agree on?