3 ms·
On the contrary, immediately accepting non-determinism simply because that's what you seem to have measured is also unscientific. Or do you believe dipping penc
by naasking 11y ago
On the contrary, immediately accepting non-determinism simply because that's what you seem to have measured is also unscientific. Or do you believe dipping pencils in water actually breaks them, and then reconstitutes them when you pull them back out? Don't mistake an illusion for reality.
We shouldn't simply naively accept what our experiment seem to be telling us, we should always seek alternative avenues to explain the evidence. It can yield compelling insights.
- int_19h 10y agoSure. But if we stick to the scientific method, then alternative avenues are more experiments. With the pencil, for example, assuming that water actually breaks them is a reasonable premise of the initial experiment, but then you see that it's not actually broken - that's the second observation, disproving the theory. But if all your experiments say that it is non-deterministic, again and again and again, Occam's razor approach is to say "yes, it is non-deterministic". Creating an elaborate framework which basically lets you say "it's ACTUALLY deterministic, except for all these other things that make it LOOK non-deterministic for all practical purposes" is not really science, it's just placating a preconceived (and possibly hardwired) notion.