2 ms·
I disagree. You seem to be asserting that ontologies don't drive empirical or theoretical science, but this is obviously false. Einstein himself devised relativ
by naasking 11y ago
I disagree. You seem to be asserting that ontologies don't drive empirical or theoretical science, but this is obviously false. Einstein himself devised relativity via thought experiments surrounding ontological properties he believed made sense (such as the light speed barrier). Formulating theories and testing them is exactly what science is all about.
- int_19h 11y agoI'm not disputing that intuition can be a driver for empirical science, but that's different from asserting that intuition overrides observable results. If we do see multiple experiments showing that the world is non-deterministic, trying to shoehorn it into a deterministic box because it "makes sense" to us (which is really just a roundabout way to say that our ape brains are wired to think that way because the portion of the physical world that we deal with has that nature), and rejecting theories and interpretations on the grounds that they are "troublesome", is not really science.
- naasking 11y agoOn the contrary, immediately accepting non-determinism simply because that's what you seem to have measured is also unscientific. Or do you believe dipping pencils in water actually breaks them, and then reconstitutes them when you pull them back out? Don't mistake an illusion for reality. We shouldn't simply naively accept what our experiment seem to be telling us, we should always seek alternative avenues to explain the evidence. It can yield compelling insights.
- int_19h 10y agoSure. But if we stick to the scientific method, then alternative avenues are more experiments. With the pencil, for example, assuming that water actually breaks them is a reasonable premise of the initial experiment, but then you see that it's not actually broken - that's the second observation, disproving the theory. But if all your experiments say that it is non-deterministic, again and again and again, Occam's razor approach is to say "yes, it is non-deterministic". Creating an elaborate framework which basically lets you say "it's ACTUALLY deterministic, except for all these other things that make it LOOK non-deterministic for all practical purposes" is not really science, it's just placating a preconceived (and possibly hardwired) notion.
- GregBuchholz 11y agoI also liked chapter 10 of Jaynes' "Probability Theory: the Logic of Science"... "Biologists have a mechanistic picture of the world because, being trained to believe in causes, they continue to search for them and find them. Quantum physicists have only probability laws because for two generations we have been indoctrinated not to believe in causes - and so we have stopped looking for them. Indeed, any attempt to search for the causes of microphenomena is met with scorn and a charge of professional incompetence and "obsolete mechanistic materialism." Therefore, to explain the indeterminacy in current quantum theory we need not suppose there is any indeterminacy in Nature; the mental attitude of quantum physicists is already sufficient to guarantee it." http://www-biba.inrialpes.fr/Jaynes/cc10k.pdf http://www-biba.inrialpes.fr/Jaynes/cc10k.pdf