7 ms·
The title is misleading. Here is what the experiments actually showed. Quantum mechanics continues to predict things correctly in an experiment that has a fun
by btilly 11y ago
The title is misleading.
Here is what the experiments actually showed. Quantum mechanics continues to predict things correctly in an experiment that has a fun interpretation within pilot-wave theory.
We also received the standard lecture on why pilot-wave theory makes more sense than the standard Copenhagen interpretation. And a passing acknowledgement of the many-worlds interpretation.
There is no explanation of the fact that many-worlds also explains the result, also is mathematically simple, and lacks the explicit non-locality that is troubling in pilot-wave theory. There is also no note of the fact that all interpretations of quantum mechanics can explain all possible experiments that fit the predictions of quantum mechanics. Therefore no experiment can support one interpretation over another UNLESS the result is in contradiction to quantum mechanics. (In this case the result was emphatically not in contradiction to prediction.)
- DavidPlumpton 11y agoThe Everett FAQ makes even stronger claims about the status of Many Worlds. See http://www.hedweb.com/manworld.htm#interpretation http://www.hedweb.com/manworld.htm#interpretation
- sp332 11y agoThat is just plain bombastic. It says "All the other theories fail for logical reasons." No reasons given. It has a link, but the very first section in the link says "Copenhagen Interpretation... not fatal, but unpleasant". Well OK, you don't like non-locality. That's not a real argument! And a bunch of the questions about linearity ignore the fact that gravity is clearly non-linear.
- pierrebai 11y agoAh, why do these kind of Physics FAQ always claim to be objective and then obviously are not? This fact commits all the sins of the typical physics FAQ. For example it claim sthat only many-world is scientific, that other interpretation requires extra assumptions. It even labels Copenhagen as being "vitalist". It also does not address some very valid cristicisms: 1. Conservation of energy. 2. Relativistic observers seeing multiple decoherence events in different orders. 3. Experiments that affect whether a particule pair did decohere inthe past. (i.e. quantum state recombination.) Basically, MW assumes that the probability wave exists and that all outcomes exist, which is a very big assumption, which that FAQ gloss over rapidly. (And then explictly call other interpretations' assumptions as a negative...)
- Strilanc 11y agoWhy would a MW faq address criticisms of the Copenhagen interpretation?
- naasking 11y ago> 1. Conservation of energy. This is not a problem for MWI. > 2. Relativistic observers seeing multiple decoherence events in different orders There is no decoherence in MWI.
- btilly 11y agoThere is no decoherence in MWI. Yes there is. Decoherence provides the theoretical framework to explain why the superposition of parallel observers can never meaningfully interact with themselves again, even though a superposition of simple particles can. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_decoherence#In_interpretations_of_quantum_mechanics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_decoherence#In_interpr... for more. That said, the order in which an observer notices decoherence events has no particular physical importance.
- anotheryou 11y agoCan you explain why the more simple explanation is not favored by most scientists than?
- sampo 11y agoWhen you have to choose between hidden variables, nonlocality, and many worlds, the opinions differ wildly which one of these is more simple. Everyone claims their version is the most simple and logical, but then others disagree.
- krastanov 11y agoIf you are talking about Pilot Wave Theory - it definitely is not simpler mathematically. It might not require complex numbers, but it still requires the same number of parameters. It is actually more complicated to do multi-particle physics in this setup. But at the end they are just equivalent descriptions (same mathematical object, different ways to describe it). Many-words is pleasant because it requires (arguably) less "mental gymnastics", but again, it is just an interpretation of what the equation means. It is still the same equation, the same mathematical object. The claim is that Quantum Mechanics (or QFT more generally) is not a complete theory (and we do know that to be a fact, it does not work when space-time curvature is important). The only reason I personally find Many-words interesting is because it might be easier to generalize to a complete theory. But again, if we are constraining ourselves to flat space-time, all those interpretations are completely equivalent.
- 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- snarfy 11y agoI'm not sure what is more far fetched - many worlds or non-locality.
- VladKovac 11y agoWhy is many worlds far fetched? We observe it in a smaller scale in experiments when you pass light through a half silvered mirror. It's just the logical extrapolation of that observation to the macro scale.
- goodcanadian 11y agoYou say that observation shows many worlds. I say that the photon interferes with itself. I find the latter far more plausible than invoking multiple universes for the photon to interact with.
- VladKovac 11y agoThat's fine until you start talking about a magical collapse process that happens conveniently at sufficiently large scale. IMO postulating additional non-local, non-unitary, ftl, etc. collapse process is strictly more complicated.
- millstone 11y agoMost modern interpretations have "collapse" as only a change in the description level, not a physical process. You're right that postulates such as the projection postulate complicate the theory. But it's not clear how to explain experimental results, like the stochastic nature of measurements or the Born rule, without it. I can make a theory as simple as you like if you don't require it to explain experimental results.
- btilly 11y agoThe many-worlds interpretation has no collapse at all. :-)
- xlm1717 11y agoReplace non-locality with infinite universes, which is more troubling? The article does touch on this question. Additionally, the article's aim was to demonstrate that the ESSW does not contradict pilot-wave theory, not to show that pilot-wave theory explains the results better than alternative theories, and it demonstrated this by showing that there is no contradiction if you take in account nonlocality. The title is not misleading because the experiment described in the article does provide experimental support to the theory, support which ESSW aimed to take away. Importantly, it is not an experiment designed to show pilot-wave theory describes the results better than other theories.
- btilly 11y agoIf the experiment does nothing to advance this theory over any competitor, or vice versa, how can you say that it provides experimental support to the theory? ESSW demonstrated that pilot-wave theory requires a weird form of non-locality. These experiments confirm that experiment requires the exact form of non-locality that ESSW required. Whether non-locality bothers you depends on your philosophical position, and is not affected by this experiment.
- mangeletti 11y agoYou seem to suggest that support for a theory is meaningless unless it is absolutely conclusive. If that was the case, I'm pretty sure most of quantum physics would have been abandoned long ago. Until we know everything, is anything in theoretical physics really a zero-sum game? I think the problem is in the thinking quantum physicists must possess in order to believe in such a theory in the first place. I mean, the idea of, "if we don't know where it came from, it couldn't possibly be hidden information; it must therefor be 'random'" is absurdly egotistic in the first place.
- btilly 11y agoI have no idea how you get from my words to, "...support for a theory is meaningless unless it is absolutely conclusive." What I said is that if the outcome of an experiment is predicted by two different theories, getting the expected result does nothing to help you decide between them. It happens to be the case that ANY experiment that is in accord with quantum mechanics is equally well explained by EVERY interpretation of quantum mechanics. The result is that most working physicists so not consider wondering about the right interpretation to be a useful scientific endeavor. Indeed most will gladly affirm that they belong to the "shut up and calculate" school of physics in practice. There are plenty of detailed questions within quantum mechanics which can be asked and answered by experiment. That is what scientists tend to do instead of debating interpretations.
- Strilanc 11y agoPop-science articles about quantum mechanics make this fallacy (affirming the consequent) all the time. Them: "PilotWave implies E. E was observed. Therefore PilotWave!" Everyone: "AAAAAaaaaaaaaaaargh! That is not how science or logic works! You're missing the 'not-PilotWave implies not-E' part!"
- Jach 11y agoThis is how common sense works, though, and is covered formally by probability theory. I'd also argue science works by probability theory more so than deductive logic, so you're only right that this isn't how logic works.
- cousin_it 11y agoProbability theory doesn't work that way either. If A and B both imply C, then seeing C doesn't raise the probability of A compared to B.
- Strilanc 11y agoActually, this issue also applies to probability theory. It does get more subtle, though, because theories might predict observations with differing probabilities and what matters is the difference in probabilities. But this this case theory A and theory B both predict observation C with the same probability p. So you gain 0 decibels of evidence (w.r.t A-vs-B) whether or not you observe C. When I said "You're missing the 'not-PilotWave implies not-E' part!", I was making a simplified reference to the fact that the probabilities predicted by not-PilotWave (e.g. Copenhagen) need to be different from the probabilities predicted by PilotWave in order for evidence/inference to pry them apart. See [1] if that all sounded confusing. 1: http://www.yudkowsky.net/rational/technical/ http://www.yudkowsky.net/rational/technical/
- trhway 11y ago>Quantum mechanics continues to predict things correctly in an experiment that has a fun interpretation within pilot-wave theory. Both of them predict correctly because they both actually use quantization of particle position. The issue with both of them is that both interpret that solution to equations as a real object - QM takes it for particle itself while pilot-wave theory assigns some real world existence to that "Pilot Wave". It would be like in case of shooting a bullet from a rifle QM would say that the trajectory is the bullet, where is pilot-wave would say that there is real trajectory object guiding the bullet.
- riskable 11y agoI always thought the "multiple universes" theory was just a convenient way to explain particle interactions that occur outside of our observable universe. They may very well be in the this universe but because they're not observable it's presumed that they occur in another universe or many universes simultaneously.
- btilly 11y agoNot exactly. The "multiple universes" theory is an explanation that if quantum mechanics describes both the quantum mechanical system under study and the observer, then after the interaction of "observation", the system looks like a superposition of independent systems that each look like the observer observed something different. The amplitude of each system corresponds directly to the likelihood that we will think we observed one thing versus another, and quantum mechanics + thermodynamics shows that these copies will never be able to have any meaningful interaction. In short, in this interpretation reality, is quantum mechanics. There is never a "collapse" as there is in the Copenhagen interpretation. "Multiple universes" is merely a description of what quantum mechanics predicts the outcome will act like.
- tim333 11y agoOr another way of thinking about it: If you fire a particle at two slits with a screen on the other side you get an interference pattern on the screen implying the particle in a sense went through both slits and the results interfered. This happens even if you use quite complex particles such as C60 buckyballs. So the universe in some sense runs multiple versions some with the molecules going one way and some going the other. All the "multiple universe" explanation implies really is that this is a general phenomena and the universe runs all possible versions even when we can't observe the results.
- scythe 11y agoMany-worlds isn't mathematically simple if you demand world-splitting occurs locally. http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0103079 http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0103079 Interpreting quantum mechanics is often like this: you can preserve locality or convenience, but usually not both. This is why I prefer the minimalist relational interpretation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relational_quantum_mechanics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relational_quantum_mechanics However, I don't recommend this as a preferred interpretation because it does not motivate discoveries (the other interpretations all fail here too). So far, none of the interpretations has led to a new physical theory, and in particular none has really helped the study of quantum gravity, which if anything is the whole point of metaphysics: to aid in learning.
- naasking 11y ago> Interpreting quantum mechanics is often like this: you can preserve locality or convenience, but usually not both. Indeed, John Bell of Bell's theorem said that non-locality was THE big problem of quantum mechanics. He was a fan of Bohmian mechanics/pilot waves because it places what he considered the central problem front-and-center.
- rdtsc 11y ago> There is no explanation of the fact that many-worlds also explains They do mention many worlds albeit not in too many words ;-) it just says it is rather a convoluted explanation just like the other ones. Infinitely many universes being generated during every particle interaction is just as silly as a funny path or Copenhagen. > There is also no note of the fact that all interpretations of quantum mechanics can explain all possible experiments that fit the predictions of quantum mechanics. So what did you mean by "many worlds" being "mathematically simple" isn't it the same mathematics, just different interpretation of it? Not sure what you man
- btilly 11y agoAccording to quantum mechanics, if a simple quantum mechanical system interacts with a complex one, the complex one is thrown into a superposition of states that can have no meaningful interaction from then on. Many worlds says that quantum mechanics is all that there is, and all observed consequences can be predicted from the assumption that we, ourselves, are complex quantum mechanical systems. The prediction is that we coexist with superpositions of ourselves doing different things and cannot meaningfully interact with them. This seems weird to us, but is exactly what the theory predicts. Consider Schroedinger's cat. We ask whether the cat is both alive and dead before we open the box. This puzzles us because that is what quantum mechanics predicts and that seems weird. Multiple worlds says that quantum mechanics holds, it remains both alive and dead AFTER we open the box, and while it seems weird, there is no actual contradiction anywhere. So mathematically simple. Weird consequences. In perfect accord with our best theories and best experiments. By contrast the Copenhagen interpretation says that there is a collapse somewhere even though there is no experimental evidence for it, and we have no theory about how it might happen. And the pilot-wave interpretation says that our best theories notwithstanding, the universe is something different and weird in a different way.
- gohrt 11y agoIn any interpretation, it seems the same question remains: Copenhagen: Why did the wave collapse into state A and not B,C,... MSI: Why am "I" in multiverse branch A, and not B,C,...? (and who am "I" anyway?) Pilot wave: Why is the pseudo-random seed = A', which I can only see indirectly by observing experiment result state A?