3 ms·
This 1998 MSDS does list polyethoxylated tallow amine as an inert ingredient, with an immediately adjacent note that it is a Hazardous chemical under the cr
by maxerickson 11y ago
This 1998 MSDS does list polyethoxylated tallow amine as an inert ingredient, with an immediately adjacent note that it is a Hazardous chemical under the criteria of the OSHA Hazard Communication Standard (29 CFR 1910.1200).
http://greenhouse.ucdavis.edu/pest/pmsds/Roundup.PDF http://greenhouse.ucdavis.edu/pest/pmsds/Roundup.PDF
I've used Roundup a little bit (not anywhere close to what would happen occupationally) and have always been more concerned with exposure to the solvent during application than any later exposure.
I'm not sure what the OSHA thing entails, I'm sure it means that employers would have to make information available to employees, but it isn't clear that it would require them to do anything more.
- ArtDev 11y agoInteresting that is contains Ethoxylated Tallowamine. I would like to know what other "inert" ingredients are commonly found in it. Also, is it true that it contains heavy metals?
- maxerickson 11y agoThe linked article is largely about Ethoxylated Tallowamine. If you believe that the US system for hazardous materials is effective, then no, it won't contain anything more than traces of other materials, because those things aren't on the safety label. If you don't believe that the US system for hazardous materials is effective, why would you believe me either?
- ArtDev 11y agoI think that MSDS sheets have their limits. Its basically just for acute exposure.
- maxerickson 11y agoThey are required to characterize the material in question. They don't say a bit of glyphosate and some other stuff we had around, they list the ingredients and give the proportion of each ingredient.
- ArtDev 11y agofrom the article: "But because manufacturers of weed killers are required to disclose only the chemical structures of their “active” ingredients — and can hide the identity of the rest as confidential business information — for many years no one knew exactly what other chemicals were in these products, let alone how they affected health."
- maxerickson 11y agoThe company is still required to list the health effects of the withheld ingredients. http://www.ilpi.com/msds/ref/tradesecret.html http://www.ilpi.com/msds/ref/tradesecret.html Also, note that in the MSDS dated 1998 that I linked above, the surfactant is identified by name.
- DanBC 11y agoHere's an MSDS for a Monsanto product. We can see it covers acute exposure, and repeat exposure, and chronic exposure. http://www.roundup.ca/_uploads/documents/RoundupUltra2Liquid-Canada-English.D14.pdf http://www.roundup.ca/_uploads/documents/RoundupUltra2Liquid...
- SigmundA 11y agoPolyethoxylated tallow amine is also used in toilet bowl cleaners, lubricant's, hair coloring, and hand degreasers. I believe it it listed in OSHA database as non-carcinogenic.