4 ms·
It's not just the US that is expensive and riddled with cost explosions. This seems to be a failure of pretty much every political system - for example, Germany
by mschuster91 11y ago
It's not just the US that is expensive and riddled with cost explosions. This seems to be a failure of pretty much every political system - for example, Germany, where construction costs explode (BER, Stuttgart 21, Hamburg Opera House).
The most common cause why costs have exploded is that, unlike "old times", where either the state itself has employed all kinds of construction planners and workers or awarded a specific company all construction projects in a given timeframe, now everything has to be available for bidding - usually the lowest bid recieves the contract. This, in turn, creates incentives (often lined with kickbacks for the responsible politicians!) for the construction companies to underestimate the bids and charging the government for each and every change to the contract, to cut corners and generally mismanage the projects.
Also, in the EU, projects above a certain threshold have to be advertised in the entire EU - leading to projects with little to no "native" people employed on site, and regular language problems and misunderstandings due to different legal requirements in the EU states (e.g. training of the work force, different specifications - what may very well be an acceptable project under Polish regulations is totally unacceptable by German standards).
Furthermore, regulatory oversight has been on a massive decline as competent people leave or don't even enter state service, so that too few people in government employment are available to properly assess and control construction process.
- sageikosa 11y agoWell, maybe Europe built itself with government projects, but apart from some dubious transcontinental rail lines, America's "original" heavy and light rail systems were built by combinations of corporate, municipal and state entities. Roads were municipal matters, heavy trucks were seldom seen as that channel grew in symbiosis with the Eisenhower Highway system. Heavy trucks drive the need for durable roads, and they just weren't the norm until the Fed subsidized the crap out of inter-city highways and regulated the rail (most predominantly: the Pennsylvania RR) until if collapsed. Light-rail had its own similar history with roads and busses (and the fight for "right-of-way" at street level).
- mschuster91 11y agoWeren't the beginnings of cross-US rail lines laid back at a time where regulatory frameworks (esp. cross-county/state, and noise emission) weren't that strict as today? Also, back in the time it was customary to create stock companies where people bought shares to actually BUILD something of value? When was the last time that a stock company was founded to build long lasting infrastructure? Stock companies, these days, in my opinion focus WAY too much on creating short-term gains on the back of employees and unsuspecting investors...
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Weren't the beginnings of cross-US rail lines laid back at a time where regulatory frameworks (esp. cross-county/state, and noise emission) weren't that strict as today? The major cross-US rail lines were laid down when government (IIRC, both federal and state governments) were handing out money like candy for building railroads. It was no more free market than today, its just the orientation of the government involvement was different. And a lot of the companies created at that time in the industry were mostly created to funnel money from those subsidies into the hands of investors. You really shouldn't idealize the early cross-US rail period either as one of an absence of regulatory involvement or one of noble value building vs. short-term extraction by capitalists. Sure, even with all the outright corruption, rail lines to nowhere, and other abuses, there also happened to get some useful, long-lasting infrastructure and organizations with long-term value built. But its wrong to overly romanticize the process that went into that.
- flubert 11y agoFor more details on transcontinental railroads financing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Transcontinental_Railroad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Transcontinental_Railroa...
- sageikosa 11y agoBasically why I excluded the transcontinental. It took an act of congress to start its construction and an act of congress to stop it as well.
- maxxxxx 11y agoI think you are hitting the real point. Governments have less and less experts who can oversee such a project. Instead they rely on bidders who manage the project. If you ever have dealt with contractors working on your house our outsourced an IT project to a company you quickly learn that you need to stay on top of things all the time otherwise you'll get ripped off.