4 ms·

I am saying that the author is using Sentinelese interchangeably with Jarawa/Andaman incorrectly. The only reference I can find for such contact is a blog post

I am saying that the author is using Sentinelese interchangeably with Jarawa/Andaman incorrectly. The only reference I can find for such contact is a blog post and a 1993 news article that appears anecdotal. I'd like to see the journal article written about this contact by the Anthropological Survey of India which funded the contact with the Andaman Islanders, but I can't find a source, leading me to believe it didn't happen as described.

x1798DE 10y ago
According to Wikipedia, Sentinelese is apparently (based on other encounters) ,not mutually intelligible with Onge, which does seem to be an inconsistency in the idea that she heard them asking for coconuts in Onge.
- codezero 10y ago
  Wikipedia references the same anecdotal source material and not anything from an authentic source.
  - codezero 10y ago
    I think I misplaced this comment, sorry!
stevecalifornia 10y ago
You didn't read the article. She landed on North Sentinel island and interacted with the Sentinelese. Then, later in the article it focuses on Jarawa.
- codezero 10y ago
  I did read it. I just don't trust the veracity of the claims. The best I can find is this book: https://books.google.com/books?id=-4PDCQAAQBAJ&pg=PA140&lpg=PA140&dq=allen+point+sentinel+islands&source=bl&ots=UFU2HZZYj0&sig=eLPW59HhLtX37jud0z0yH2s5X0I&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiWlpHagOLMAhVK-2MKHUt8AScQ6AEIKjAB#v=onepage&q=allen%20point%20sentinel%20islands&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=-4PDCQAAQBAJ&pg=PA140&lpg=... This text claims to have made friendly contact in 1986, and says 1994 had contact on the eastern coast. These dates don't line up with the story, and I can't find any official source information about the contact, so the inconsistency is a red flag.
  - khedoros 10y ago
    She apparently wrote a book 15 years ago: http://www.amazon.in/Tribes-Car-Nicobar-Madhumala-Chattopadhyay/dp/8176252395/ref=sr_1_1/275-2311076-5393852 http://www.amazon.in/Tribes-Car-Nicobar-Madhumala-Chattopadh... I don't know how one would go about researching Indian anthropological expeditions to find the officially-documented connection to reality, but presumably that's where you'd start, if you wanted to verify the story.

x1798DE 10y ago

According to Wikipedia, Sentinelese is apparently (based on other encounters) ,not mutually intelligible with Onge, which does seem to be an inconsistency in the idea that she heard them asking for coconuts in Onge.

codezero 10y ago
Wikipedia references the same anecdotal source material and not anything from an authentic source.
- codezero 10y ago
  I think I misplaced this comment, sorry!

stevecalifornia 10y ago

You didn't read the article. She landed on North Sentinel island and interacted with the Sentinelese. Then, later in the article it focuses on Jarawa.

codezero 10y ago
I did read it. I just don't trust the veracity of the claims. The best I can find is this book: https://books.google.com/books?id=-4PDCQAAQBAJ&pg=PA140&lpg=PA140&dq=allen+point+sentinel+islands&source=bl&ots=UFU2HZZYj0&sig=eLPW59HhLtX37jud0z0yH2s5X0I&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiWlpHagOLMAhVK-2MKHUt8AScQ6AEIKjAB#v=onepage&q=allen%20point%20sentinel%20islands&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=-4PDCQAAQBAJ&pg=PA140&lpg=... This text claims to have made friendly contact in 1986, and says 1994 had contact on the eastern coast. These dates don't line up with the story, and I can't find any official source information about the contact, so the inconsistency is a red flag.
- khedoros 10y ago
  She apparently wrote a book 15 years ago: http://www.amazon.in/Tribes-Car-Nicobar-Madhumala-Chattopadhyay/dp/8176252395/ref=sr_1_1/275-2311076-5393852 http://www.amazon.in/Tribes-Car-Nicobar-Madhumala-Chattopadh... I don't know how one would go about researching Indian anthropological expeditions to find the officially-documented connection to reality, but presumably that's where you'd start, if you wanted to verify the story.