4 ms·
Then he should be sentenced on the other evidence anyway. The failure to provide additional incriminating evidence could be used as an aggravating circumstance
by tremon 11y ago
Then he should be sentenced on the other evidence anyway. The failure to provide additional incriminating evidence could be used as an aggravating circumstance in the ruling, not as a separate crime with infinite detainment.
(edit: replaced punishment with detainment, it's probably more neutral)
- tptacek 11y agoFor the punishment to be infinite, wouldn't the courts at every level up to SCOTUS would have to agree to its reasonableness? (Subtextually, I'm saying: the punishment isn't infinite.)
- marcoperaza 11y agoIt's not a punishment. It's being held in contempt of court for refusing to obey a court order. He holds the keys to his own freedom; he has to provide the password.
- tptacek 11y agoDetention is punishment for the offense of contempt.
- cpncrunch 11y ago>Then he should be sentenced on the other evidence anyway Yes, probably. I'm not really convinced that this isn't a violation of the fifth amendment, but I'm not a lawyer. I suspect a jury would find him guilty anyway, and the fact that he refuses to decrypt his hard drive will likely not help his chances of convincing a jury that he's innocent.
- april1stislame 11y agoTo be sentenced he would have to be charged, which he still isn't after 7 months...
- Spooky23 11y agoWhy? He's in possession of data deemed contraband, but apparently not linked to distribution. The police need to demonstrate possession and can do so when their search is complete. The police did an investigation, obtained a warrant to search for the contraband and seized the hard drive. The defendant was ordered by the judge to decrypt the drive per the warrant, and refused to follow the order. He's in contempt of court, and he can get out of jail very easily -- by complying with the order.
- mordocai 11y agoUnless, of course, he actually has forgotten the password after 7 months+ of not using it.
- curun1r 11y agoBecause we have the 5th amendment. nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself As I understand it, Miranda established that the 5th amendment applies to all interactions with law enforcement, not just answering questions in court. So they can search the hard drive all they want, but the constitution protects us from being required to disclose what's in our heads which, in this case, should include the password.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Mikhail_Edoshin 11y agoThere's no criminal case right now, so the fifth amendment doesn't apply.
- curun1r 11y agoMiranda vs Arizona established that 5th amendment protections apply outside of a criminal case. That's why police have to read the Miranda warning when arresting someone. He's been arrested and read his Miranda rights and is invoking them.