7 ms·
Do you know the probability that this correspondence happened by chance?
by zepto 11y ago
Do you know the probability that this correspondence happened by chance?
- stepvhen 11y agoI was convinced beyond reasonable doubt, having phone records that matched rather well with testimonies. I also might have fixated on it and ignored chance, but that's why there are 12 jurors.
- jstanley 11y agoIf someone on HN ignores the statistics, what are the chances that the other jurors paid any attention to statistics?
- stonecraftwolf 11y agoReasonable doubt is not defined in terms of statistical confidence.
- nitrogen 11y agoMaybe it should be.
- abritinthebay 11y agoBased on most of the posts here I'd say "someone on HN" is just as likely - if not more, due to misplaced confidence - to ignore statistics.
- lucb1e 11y agoOr all humans fall victim to largely the same kinds of fallacies. That's why there is no jury in all countries that I know of except America. I'm not sure if a jury is a bad idea, when I first learned of it, I kinda liked the idea, but I'm worried about this kind of reasoning...
- piptastic 11y agoWhat do other countries do? Is the decision made by one person that has these same fallacies? At least the risk is spread out some in the jury situation.
- burkaman 11y agoOther countries definitely use juries, just not as universally as the US. They more often just have a judge or a panel of judges, or sometimes a sort of jury that includes judges.
- antris 11y agoProper training alleviates these fallacies. I trust a judge much better than a jury of random people.
- yompers888 11y agoOn the other hand, the random jury doesn't have the same perverse incentives and web of relationships that support conviction.
- r00fus 11y agoWould you still trust that judge that was elected to office with lobbyist money?
- burkaman 11y agoI think electing judges might also be a uniquely American thing, and less than half the country does it. It's a much weirder practice than using juries. Obviously you can still say a judge was appointed by people elected with lobbyist money, but it's not that direct.
- lucb1e 11y agoMight be my lack of knowledge in the subject, but I've never heard of electing judges. Isn't it just a study and a background check or so, at least in western Europe?
- zepto 11y agoDid any of the other jurors calculate the probability of the result being by chance?
- danso 11y agoI wonder if the defense attorney brought in a statician to argue that?