3 ms·
Perhaps the NYC subway is a special case in the cost-per-kilometer club but how about something more run-of-the-mill like the MA green line extension [0] which
by zaroth 11y ago
Perhaps the NYC subway is a special case in the cost-per-kilometer club but how about something more run-of-the-mill like the MA green line extension [0] which is $2-$3B for 4.3 miles of above ground track? [1]
They recently had to go back and try to slash the budget since the Fed and State have pledged $1B each and no more. Some of the reasons given for rthe explosion from $2N -> $3B were poor oversight over the bidding process [2].
To cut cost they scaled back the station designs (apparently people were complaining after some stations became little more than a platform without even shelter from the weather), kept some bridges they originally planned to replace, and shortened a walk/bike path.
Nowhere in the news do I see anyone talking about labor rates, unions, health insurance / pension, or eminent domain issues causing the cost overruns.
I've been on the board of a small condo (27 units) which did a major residing project a few years ago. The process of spec'ing, bidding, overseeing the construction was hugely involved for the huge for us but relatively tiny project. The contractor bids, which were against a very detailed 3rd party specification, had a huge spread. During the project there were significant work items which were outside the spec and ended up being negotiated to control costs. The takeaway for me is that these projects are insanely complicated and cities just don't have the expertise and dedication to tightly manage them and wring out the cost savings. The experts outmaneuver the municipality and we end up paying far too much.
What's interesting about the Green Line Extension is the nature of the funding means the first $2B is almost like free funny money but every dollar thereafter is like spilling blood because it comes from the locals. So at least the funding structure is trying to impose some limits. And lo-and-behold if the choice is for a city to cough up the extra cash versus cutting costs, they cut the cost by 1/3rd.
I think the biggest problem is cultural. The people overseeing the project are not spending every dollar like it's their own. If the cost isn't "real" to the people running the project, it completely changes how the project is run. Human nature.
[0] - http://greenlineextension.eot.state.ma.us/docs_about.html http://greenlineextension.eot.state.ma.us/docs_about.html
[1] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Line_Extension https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Line_Extension
[2] - http://www.boston.com/news/local-news/2016/01/15/report-green-line-extension-budget-issues-brewed-long-before-crisis http://www.boston.com/news/local-news/2016/01/15/report-gree...