9 ms·
I'm always amazed when there's a story about road construction in the local news, and it costs like 1.5 million dollars to repave 4 blocks of some street..how i
by bluedino 11y ago
I'm always amazed when there's a story about road construction in the local news, and it costs like 1.5 million dollars to repave 4 blocks of some street..how is that possible?
I had a friend have his average-sized driveway re-done with cement and it was like $60,000 which I thought was insane. Remove old cement, grade the dirt, pour new cement, smooth it out...and wait.
- jschwartzi 11y agoOn a road they typically have an underlayment that has to be packed to withstand trucking. There are usually also new street lights, and sidewalks. In my area they plant trees either in the median or between the sidewalk and the road. When you factor in the cost of those changes, 1.5 million seems reasonable for roughly a mile of road.
- dhd415 11y agoWhere was your friend located? I've had my 40'x20' driveway re-done (old one torn out and recycled and a new one formed and poured) for 1/10 of that price in Texas.
- hrktb 11y agoSo from your friend's driveway to 4 blocks of streets it only costs 25 times more ? Taking into account that public roads are not just random cement but usually a special mix for durability, sound properties and water resistance, and then you have all the cables and tubes going under that might need to be taken care of when removing the current layer and putting back the new one. All of this has to be done on public property by qualified staff. Overall a 25x increase in cost seems pretty fair from an external point of view.
- PantaloonFlames 11y ago> All of this has to be done on public property by qualified staff. With safety measures erected for the public, traffic direction, signaling, etc.
- cmdrfred 11y agoIn NJ i've seen guys standing by the side of the road just to let trucks out (once every few hours). After a few weeks of this, they had little makeshift tents they would hangout in and play with their phones all day. I'm sure the reason is 'safety' when the public asks but that's why they have the highest cost per mile[0] of anywhere in the US. [0]http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2014/09/study_ranks_new_jersey_roads_high_in_cost_low_in_performans.html http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2014/09/study_ranks_new_jer...
- HCIdivision17 11y agoYou might need to be amazed at the savings at scale. The land area covered by a few city blocks of road compared to a driveway is pretty large. The $1.5M is likely a pretty good buy. Napkin calc: assuming a driveway that's 20 feet wide and 30 feet long, the area will be 600 feet^2. The typical residential road's going to be something like 30 feet wide (enough for a parked car and two opposing lanes with comfort) and a guess at a block being like 1/20 of a mile, or 250 feet; that gives each city block of road about 7500 feet^2. So guessing conservatively, about one city block is probably at least 10 times larger than the driveway. And that's before the actual road complexity. A city road also likely has to account for sewage, powerlines, telecom cables, drainage, etc. There's also a trade-off in road design: your friend likely never wants to build his driveway again, so he'll want something permanent like cement. But the city may want to make different trade-off; blacktop can be more easily maintained and expanded and upgraded than pavement, but also costs more in the long run (but pavement is more expensive up front).
- XorNot 11y agoAlso account for time - you absolutely can't close down the entire city block, so all the major construction tends to have to be scheduled at night.
- maxerickson 11y agoThe majority of miles of paved city blocks in the US can easily be shutdown during the day. The streets are often a grid, so there are easy detours. It's not so simple in high density areas, but those are a small portion of the paved streets by area.
- Bartweiss 11y agoYou really can't, not for any substantial length of time. First, you create horrible traffic distortions - a place like LA or Boston simply can't load adjacent streets with more traffic and expect good outcomes. Second, you effectively shut down any business on that block, especially in an area that isn't walking friendly. You also cause huge problems for anyone living and parking at that street. High density areas are a small portion of streets by area, but not by use (and therefore wear) or by cost. I suspect that a mile of highway is often cheaper to replace than a block of dense urban road.
- antman 11y agoRepave in Greece costs 10€^m2 including materiald
- chadgeidel 11y agoFinally! Here's where my extensive background in concrete construction pays off! :-D (Seriously though, my father and brother run a concrete construction business and I have worked on both residential and commercial jobs for 10+ years of my "youth") For starters - $60k is a LOT for a driveway. My brother's company charges $10 per square foot (at the top end) to remove and replace a driveway. This assumes the ground is appropriate (drainage is acceptable, no need for fill, etc.) This is based on 4" of concrete and steel reinforcing mesh and no subgrade prep. As with anything there are "price boosters" but that's a reasonable estimate. Average driveway is maybe 20x40, so that works out to be $8 grand max. This is in suburban South Dakota, so it might be more in larger metro areas. A highway is nothing like a driveway. As others have pointed out, the thickness of concrete alone is double or triple (probably a minimum of 8 inches - more like 10 inches) and the reinforcement is considerably more (3/4 inch steel rebar mat 16-18 inches on center). You have to also consider that the subgrade needs at least a few inches of gravel, which is fairly expensive. It doesn't stop there - once the concrete is poured, there is typically a curing agent applied on top of the surface, and then the expansion joints have to be sawed and sealed. This is just for the road surface. I'll bet this cost also has to take into account curbing and sidewalks. I've personally worked on both kinds of jobs - residential driveways and suburban streets. It's at least 10x more work "per foot" to do a road over a driveway. It's the difference between building a weekend "hacker project" and a production ready ecommerce website.
- angersock 11y agoOur highways will probably last centuries if not millenia once cars and trucks stop banging on them. The Romans would be envious.
- chadgeidel 11y agoI would guess that within about 10-20 years of non-use they would be overgrown to the point of invisibility. Joints are tooled/cut every 20 feet (I think?) and grass has a habit of growing everywhere. The individual "sections" would remain in place of course, but growing things and erosion would push the joints further and further apart every season. IMHO - the pristine unbroken roadways would be like that for only a few years/maybe a decade.