18 ms·
Firefox tops Microsoft browser market share for first time
- dukenuke 11y agoFirefox also sends enormous amounts of metadata about your browsing to the cloud and it's very difficult for non-savvy users to turn this off. They call it telemetry and 'safe browsing', but users overlook that every URL is checked against a database of URLs already in Google's 'safe browsing' repository. Firefox is not actually private and their business model can't allow for privacy, because they're in bed with Google. Use something like Palemoon and configure about:config a bit more and you should be fine. But be very skeptical of Mozilla claiming FF is some privacy enhancing tool. Their plugins ecosystem is also a security nightmare...
- gtk40 11y agoIs the claim that Firefox/Mozilla is in bed with Google sourced by the use of Google for data about safe browsing? Is there any other reason to think this now that they no longer receive revenue from Google?
- gboss 11y agoActually Mozilla ditched Google as their search revenue partner and now is partnered with select search engines depending on the market. Yahoo for the US, Yandex for Russia and Baidu for China, for example. Mozilla to my knowledge no longer relies on Google for any revenue. See how do we generate revenue question: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/annualreport/2014/faq/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/annualreport/2014/f...
- gtk40 11y agoYes, this is what I was referring to when I said "they no longer receive revenue from Google." He seemed to be basing the entire claim of the two companies being in bed together on Mozilla's use of Google's safe browsing data. I was asking if there was anything else now that the monetary agreement has ceased.
- KaneEdger 11y agoThe opposite was the case. Mozilla was ditched by Google. It is logically that they say it the other way around, as it does sound much better, and gives the illusion that Mozilla is in control about their fate. They got ditched after Google enforced minimalism (Australis) on Firefox with giving Mozilla "good design advice's" that of course backfired. And as soon as Mozilla's share dropped enough, Google gave them the boot.
- whamlastxmas 11y agoFigured I'd post this here since after reading your comment I made an effort to simply make my existing Firefox more private: Install the "Privacy Settings" Firefox extension. This makes it easy to toggle the about:config options and has handy presets so you don't have to spend an hour reading articles to understand what to enable/disable. I also tried "Policy Control" extension which is supposed to help prevent fingerprinting, but it didn't seem to work with EFF's panopticlick tool.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoFirefox, at least modern versions of it, does not tell Google which sites you're visiting. It pulls a list from Google and checks against it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Safe_Browsing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Safe_Browsing And Firefox enables you to turn this off in settings. Firefox's telemetry can also be turned off. In fact, when you install Firefox, it asks you if you wish to enable it. And regarding the plugins ecosystem, Firefox is moving away from the old XUL/XPCOM extension model towards WebExtensions, which should be better here.
- rhelmer 11y agoMozilla has very clear, detailed privacy policies for all data it collects: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/privacy/firefox/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/privacy/firefox/ You can find more developer-focused information on Safe Browsing and Telemetry: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Safe_Browsing https://wiki.mozilla.org/Safe_Browsing https://wiki.mozilla.org/Telemetry https://wiki.mozilla.org/Telemetry My understanding of the Safe Browsing feature based on browsing the above is that a list of blacklisted URLs is downloaded to the client, this list is known phishing sites. > Use something like Palemoon and configure about:config a bit more and you should be fine. But be very skeptical of Mozilla claiming FF is some privacy enhancing tool. Keeping Firefox secure and making the right tradeoffs for collecting data to make the product better (like telemetry and crash reports) while avoiding using the data for nefarious purposes is a hard job, and I think Mozilla does it very well (disclaimer: I work there, and I see the way people treat and talk about users and their data). > Their plugins ecosystem is also a security nightmare... Assuming you mean extensions (aka Add-ons) - it is true that there isn't really a security model around classic Firefox extensions, which is one reason they are so powerful. The current form of Firefox extension is essentially the same as in the 1.0 days, and was intended to keep the browser slim and allow for new non-core features. Web Extensions are intended as the replacement, they are similar to (and largely compatible with) the current Chrome extension system: https://wiki.mozilla.org/WebExtensions https://wiki.mozilla.org/WebExtensions Firefox already does and will continue to support more APIs than Chrome does, to enable more powerful extensions such as Tree Style Tabs.
- ChrisGranger 11y agoIf a user is too non-savvy to click a couple of check boxes in Options > Security to turn off Safe Browsing, they probably need that protection. Users this non-savvy are probably already being tracked left, right, and center and an easy target for malware served by advertising networks, and Safe Browsing is the least of their worries. It's similarly easy to turn Health Report and Telemetry off from Options > Advanced > Data Choices.
- wldcordeiro 11y agoIgnore the user you are responding to. Their expectations of Firefox are unrealistic and misinformed.
- adregan 11y agoThere was a talk[0] which included some info about this recently at !!con[1]. The safe browsing dataset is compressed and stored as a bloom filter so that the check for a safe site can be performed locally. 0: http://bangbangcon.com/speakers.html#adam-marcus http://bangbangcon.com/speakers.html#adam-marcus 1: https://youtu.be/C3ox1zQcV_I?t=16259 https://youtu.be/C3ox1zQcV_I?t=16259 (timestamp is right at the beginning of the bloom filter details)
- gcp 11y agoIt's Chrome that uses a Bloom Filter. Firefox uses a compressed Prefix set, which has no false positives (unlike the Bloom filter).
- ljk 11y agoif you really want to talk about lack of privacy you should go after Chrome...
- VT_Drew 11y agoseriously, this is the very reason I use FF over Chrome.
- gcp 11y agowhat users overlook that every URL is checked against a database of URLs already in Google's 'safe browsing' repository ...the database of which is downloaded ahead of time and hence not transmitted to Google. Read this: https://feeding.cloud.geek.nz/posts/how-safe-browsing-works-in-firefox/ https://feeding.cloud.geek.nz/posts/how-safe-browsing-works-... because they're in bed with Google. It's actually Yahoo, not Google, that funds Firefox.
- Manishearth 11y agoSafe browsing doesn't work like that; the list is stored locally. When something does need to be fetched, Firefox obfuscates what's being fetched. Most of telemetry is on Nightly only, IIRC. The bits that are on regular Firefox are thoroughly vetted to ensure that they don't impinge on privacy.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mmastrac 11y agoWow. I remember watching these stats, waiting for Firefox to edge past IE in the 2000s. Chrome really took the ball and ran with it. They had the advantage of seeing things that FF did that really worked (tabs, extensions, find-as-you-type) and the intelligence to iterate on that (multi-process support, a world-class debugger) and a really solid foundation in WebKit (née KHTML). In a way Chrome was in the right place at the right time, with the right bunch of people. If they hadn't launched, Firefox would likely be sitting where Chrome is now, though likely without a bunch of drive to improve things as much as they currently have. Of course, in an alternate universe where Firefox was #1 and IE #2, we might have had royalty-free video codecs mandated by standards and no W3C-endorsed DRM...
- kpcyrd 11y ago> Chrome really took the ball and ran with it I'm still kind of bitter with the way they did that. A lot of windows installers, which usually installed you toolbars if you forgot to uncheck a box, started installing chrome as your default browser if you forgot to uncheck a box. I've seen a lot of non-technical people using chrome who have no idea what chrome is or remembering giving consent to installing chrome.
- mmastrac 11y agoInteresting. I didn't see that - I assumed it was just a result of advertising it to everyone who searched on Google. Do you have any specific examples?
- vlan0 11y agoAdobe is guilty of this. If you download Flash Player from their site, the "Optional offers" are to also install Chrome and Google Toolbar. Both of which are checked by default.
- zobzu 11y agoyou're thinking google did not pay adobe for this, adobe is doing this just cuz they like it? are you mad
- wodenokoto 11y agoDidn't Firefox use to have almost 30% ? Or was that only in select markets?
- mtgx 11y agoIt did. It dropped off a cliff when Google made Chrome default on Android, though.
- wazoox 11y agoBTW I'm using FF on Android too (and it's way better than Chrome, with a true adblocker which is even more important than on the desktop), but since the upgrade to Android 6 applications revert to the stock Android browser without any option to select FF instead, grrrr...
- kristopolous 11y agotry turning off JS and just whitelisting sites on mobile - it's in-crea-dible .... content loads, I can navigate through it ... amazing.
- Infinitesimus 11y agoYou'll have to clear chrome from your defaults and set FF as the default. One of the "features" in 6.0 (I think) is removing the ability to let an application handle an intent "Just Once". Instead, whatever you choose the first time will be the default. It's a very very annoying thing for the (likely very few) of us who like using multiple apps for the same thing
- distances 11y agoThough I haven't found a way to change the Google search bar default app. There's a menu button "Open in Firefox" after you follow a link, but in Android M you'd get Firefox already by default. Also can't replace the Google bar with Firefox bar. Well I could change the launcher I suppose, but a bit inconvenient still.
- AdmiralAsshat 11y agoI'm curious how this graph would look if you compared only Linux users (obviously IE and Edge would drop off). It didn't strike me how important Firefox is to the FOSS world until I started experimenting with Linux distros and found that it was consistently pre-installed on flavors of Ubuntu/Debian/Mint/Fedora/FreeBSD. It becomes even more valuable on distros that refuse to pre-load any proprietary software.
- gbersac 11y agoI tryied chrome on Ubuntu. It is so slow it is almost unusable, so I switched to firefox (that I feel less user friendly). That may be the reason why it is preinstalled on linux distos.
- emerongi 11y agoIt has worked just fine for me on Ubuntu (and other distros built on Ubuntu) as well as on Arch Linux. I still use Firefox though. Extensions are better.
- gtirloni 11y agoI've had a lot of problems like that due to bugs in 3d acceleration and AMD GPU drivers. The latest kernel 4.5 updates practically fixed all Chrome issues. It's fast and doesn't break while rendering any more. I can also open other apps that use 3d acceleration and everything works fine.
- c_c_c 11y agoI have no metrics but Android (Linux) and Chromebooks (Linux) would heavily skew the graph. If you ignore mobile you would probably see something similar.
- SimeVidas 11y agoMozilla: We are a non-profit and we protect your privacy; we won’t use your data to make money. Most users: Nah, man. We’ll go with the search engine and ad network company.
- larrik 11y agoEvery time I try to switch to Firefox, it just doesn't work as well, and I switch back. I'd rather Firefox over Chrome for philosophical reasons, but I feel like Firefox just isn't there technologically. It's getting better, but they really let it stagnate back in the day.
- distances 11y agoCan you elaborate on this? I've tried Chromium once and again, but always fall back to Firefox as it feels better to me. Direct reasons are the address bar functionality and better privacy support out of the box, but also some generic feel is somehow just more familiar to me. Firefox does have global freezes on particularly heavy pages due to the single process model. It's rare enough not to bother me much though. As a tip, the Firefox Android version allows add-ons -- uBlock most critically. It's just great.
- SimeVidas 11y agoMulti-process is being tested in Firefox Beta right now, according to https://wiki.mozilla.org/Electrolysis#Schedule https://wiki.mozilla.org/Electrolysis#Schedule.
- endemic 11y agoAnecdotally, e10s has made me go back to Firefox.
- epoch1970 11y agoWhile some progress is being made, it worries me that it's taking so long to get this functionality into the release versions. I'm not suggesting it should be rushed out, of course. But the Electrolysis efforts date back to 2009, if not earlier. That's a long time to make users wait!
- iLoch 11y agoWhat an awful way to present that data...
- erikb 11y agoDidn't that happen, like, 10 years ago?
- cpeterso 11y agoThe numbers just show Firefox losing market share more slowly than IE/Edge, not that Firefox is gaining. Chrome is still climbing. I wonder when Chrome's market share will peak and level out.
- partiallypro 11y agoI prefer Firefox to Chrome, Edge is still unstable but I do like some of the direction they are going in. The lack of extensions I think killed it out of the gate. It's also odd to me that Edge doesn't update through the Windows Store, and instead is updated through Windows Update...doesn't that defeat the purpose of it being a UWA? I actually find what Opera is doing a lot nicer than any other others are the moment though, find myself using it more and more.
- scholia 11y ago> The lack of extensions I think killed it out of the gate. True, but the extensions are coming. > I actually find what Opera is doing a lot nicer than any other others are the moment though, find myself using it more and more. I use Firefox and Opera, mainly, but I'm increasingly using Vivaldi. It's Chromium based and from the guy who originally founded Opera, but didn't like the way it was going. It's extremely configurable. If you have any nostalgic feelings for Opera 12, it's worth a go....
- hrbrtglm 11y agoFor me, it's all about the details, and I just can't come back to Firefox for silly reasons, even if I appreciate their stance on privacy. The tabs shape is repulsing me, I know that's a strong feeling and I can't explain it. The disymetrical back and forward buttons bothers me as well. I can't find how to whitelist domains accepting cookies in Firefox. Switching profiles is much easier with chrome. I'm used to chrome developper tools. I don't like neither safari neither MS edge. If it wasn't for the missing onenote extension, maybe I'd be using opera. Again, all about the details.
- infogulch 11y agoIsn't this something that could be fixed with an extension? A quick google (heh) brought me to the FXChrome add-on [0]. 100k+ users. [0]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/fxchrome/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/fxchrome/
- hsivonen 11y agoThe Dev Edition has a different tab shape. You can deny cookies by default and then add exceptions in the cookie manager.
- Raphael 11y agoI use this dark theme with rectangular tabs: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/ft-deepdark/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/ft-deepdark/
- shmerl 11y agoRecently I experienced a high profile site throwing some errors in Firefox, and their support rep suggesting me to use Chrome (of course I didn't). This brought the memories of "best viewed in IE" times...
- jrcii 11y agoUnfortunately it's an almost weekly occurrence that a site I'm visiting clearly was only tested in Chrome and something critical doesn't work in Firefox. For those instances I use this extension to open the current page in Chrome https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/open-in-chrome/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/open-in-chrom...
- gvb 11y agoHeres a live flashback for you: http://www.fastcgi.com/ http://www.fastcgi.com/ Best viewed with Netscape 3.0+ or Internet Explorer 4.0+. ©1996-2002 Chelsea Networks
- StillBored 11y agoChrome is the new IE. Its actually got a lot of bugs that have existed for years and years (https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=180722 https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=180722) and the developers refuse to fix them. Yet, I still find web developers that only run chrome and give blank looks over their mac/linux machines when asked if they tested the code in IE. But that isn't the primary problem. The primary problem is that its simply too hard for most web developers to install/run a HTML validator in their web browser and fix the errors it finds. Try it out, run html validator, for a few months while browsing the public web, its almost a surprise when a major web site actually has syntactically correct code. As a "systems" programmer spending about 30% of my time doing web development, simply having my code syntax checked (yah I run php and javascript validators in my deployment package too) before it makes to the the browser increases my productivity significantly. In the year or so after I started running validators/JSlint/etc (1) a lot of things started making sense in HTML/CSS and I went from a crappy web hack, to being the guy in the office helping the full time web guys when they get stuck... Now if I could just find a good way to ask "experienced" web developers if they run a validator without leading them to the "right" answer I might have a good interview question. (1) Part of this was I completely customized our "build" environment so that there was a debug vs release package/deploy process too. Things like JS minificantion/php obfuscation only happen during release deployment. JQuery/etc are actually checked into the version control in their unminified version. Plus, it usually only takes one or two calls from a web developer who can't figure out why their code won't deploy before they start checking the build logs.
- jedberg 11y agoThis isn't entirely surprising to me. For one, Edge only runs on Windows. Windows is losing market share to Mac OS, iOS and Android (Firefox is on all three as well as Windows). For two, I personally use Safari, Firefox, Chrome, and Chrome Canary on my box, each for their own purpose, but I have yet to find a need for Edge. There is no site that I go to that works best in Edge.
- bobajeff 11y agoI won't care about Edge until they've open-sourced it and made it cross platform.
- BenElgar 11y agoDoes that same logic apply to Safari?
- bobajeff 11y agoYes. Though Safari at least has their rendering engine open sourced. But really that just makes me care about Webkit.
- pritambaral 11y agoI strongly doubt the browser or even its rendering engine would be open sourced, but at least the JS engine is.
- EdSharkey 11y agoThis has to be worrisome to the Chrome team. I take this to mean that Firefox is getting faster and less janky with recent releases. Enough Windows users who are in the know and who occasionally kick the Firefox tires are finally settling on it. I don't view this as a knock on the quality of Microsoft products as much as an overall improvement in Firefox. I'm on Mac, and I believe Chrome software quality has slipped in the past 12 months. Lots more crashes than I have ever seen and some new CSS curiosities. And that's with me rarely running Chrome - Firefox is my primary browser. Maybe Mac is a much tougher platform to target and isn't the priority for Goog, or perhaps the transition to Blink has been rough. Whatever the reason, Chrome seems to be getting creaky in its old age.
- untog 11y ago> This has to be worrisome to the Chrome team. Looking at the data, not really. Their usage continues to grow, Firefox growth is at the expense of IE/Edge, not Chrome.
- EdSharkey 11y agoYes, Chrome is the current 800lbs gorilla, and they continue to grow. I am still operating under a browser wars mentality where Netscape/Mozilla's marketshare completely collapsed and they slowly recovered over time. I'm just impressed that Firefox is in double digits in terms of marketshare given that they don't have a huge marketing engine driving them (Okay, I guess Yahoo is pretty decent as engines go.) I remember when Chrome shipped with V8 as being a big turning point for the way Firefox was run. Management went from complacent to reactionary. The bug reports regarding JavaScript performance in the Firefox bug tracker at that time were really fascinating to watch - Mozilla was a very disturbed hornets' nest! Then came rapid release and all the arewe*yet.com websites, etc. Mozilla has been punching above their weight class ever since Chrome came to market, but I perceive that recently Mozilla management has been transitioning from reactionary to offensive. Their moves on Rust and sunsetting XUL and XPCOM are geared towards security AND performance, which are painful and necessary shifts. Largely hitting pause on FirefoxOS and Thunderbird and everything else not Firefox is also the right, if painful, thing to do. That's why I'm going to stick with my assertion. Every day that Mozilla/Firefox doesn't shrivel up and die has to be a concern to the Chrome team!
- lucasmullens 11y agoAbout a month ago I saw a news story that said Chrome finally passed IE, based on some other browser usage tracker. Each website that tracks this can have some huge bias, so making a general claim about a browser passing another doesn't really mean much.
- xiphias 11y agoIt must be really hard for the Microsoft CEO. He's doing what he can to fix the problems that Steve Ballmer left, but it's extremely hard for him.
- Upas 11y agoThe decision to put Edge under the Windows org and make it Windows-only was a decision made under Ballmer. I'm guessing if Satya had to do it today, he'd try to make Edge cross-platform.
- pessimizer 11y agoChrome's share is a Firefox's reward for making their browser indistinguishable from Chrome in every way except for the fact that their entire UI freezes every time it hits some bad javascript. Great choice, to go from being a great Firefox to a crappy Chrome clone.
- hackuser 11y agoMore significant is that Firefox' marketshare dropped from 16.1% to 15.6% in three months, and all lost to Chrome, it appears. Yikes! What is Chrome doing right now to advance so quickly? Or has that been the rate of increase for a long time?
- beefsack 11y agoIf Servo ever lands in Firefox I wonder what sort of impact that'd have on market share.
- Manishearth 11y agoI don't think Servo will "land in Firefox" (it's possible, but it's a lot of extra work). However, components written in Rust (taken from Servo or written in scratch) may indeed land in Firefox -- there are a couple in Firefox today! (Except on Windows). https://wiki.mozilla.org/Oxidation https://wiki.mozilla.org/Oxidation (There are a bunch of alternative paths forward other than sharing components with Gecko that don't involve dropping it into Firefox)
- netheril96 11y agoFirefox is really bad at rendering Chinese fonts. It chooses different font than other browsers, sometimes using a Japanese font to render Chinese text, and the pixelization is just palpable. I know most people here couldn't care less, but the poor internalization may be one of the reasons for a global disadvantage compared to Chrome. Internationalization is really something open source products have been lacking traditionally, as it is neither fun nor sexy.
- woodman 11y agoSounds like there aren't enough Chinese open source contributors. As the saying goes, works for me - patches welcome, they'd be in a better position to do so anyway.
- netheril96 11y agoYes, that is true. But at the same time, they should not lament about the global dominance of other browsers that do not have this attitude.
- tkubacki 11y agoWhat I like about Firefox and Chrome is that they democratized Linux as a desktop OS. Till IE was mainstream all sites assumed you are Windows box. Now it's rare that there is site I can't use except few Silverlight based dinosaurs.
- ksec 11y agoAs some had pointed out on Installing Chrome by other software etc, but normally these are real bad software. Most users who had no idea what Chrome was at the time was presently surprised by how fast Chrome was, and they stick with it. In ther early 2010s I forced switch the whole company about 200s to Firefox, but few years down the road everyone quietly installed Chrome and was using it. It was fast, and they dont care about anything else. Forcing them back on Firefox were met with opposition, saying using somthing inferior was insane. Complaining to Mozilla has been served with deaf ears. It was mostly an management issues from top to bottom, they were so full of themsevles, so righoutous, that they fail to relaize the marketing is changing. By the time they realize they have shrink below 20% market share already and were continuing downwads. Somewhere along the line, Mozilla changed their tone, it wasn't about market shares. It is about Open Web, and always has been. How do you force the Web to be Open if had no influence on it what so ever? They wasted resources on Firefox OS, which is a dismal failure. They think JS is king, and evrything, including the OS should be someday written in JS. Firefox is dying, and i am glad. Becasue as a users from Netscape era everytime Mozilla / FIrebird / Firefox reborn things has become better. Firefox is very noble. But the world has never been about one way or the other. Luckiy in the past year something happen within Mozilla. I have no idea what it is because i am not following their post anymore. ( e10s is STILL not shipped ) But things are getting better. User experience matters, less Janks, memory usage kept low and most importanly Chrome has been getting worst with every release. ( Strange indeed ) This mean more people are swithing back to Firefox. And for users with specific workflow and 100s of Tab, Firefox is still the only option on the market.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- KORraN 11y agoI always wonder how big influence on these statistics have all kind of adblockers. Like a lot of you said, there are a LOT of "forced" installs of Chrome on computers of not-so-power users. Most of them don't even know what the browser is so I bet they don't have any adblocker (unless someone installed it for them). On the side, we have power users that have adblockers and (AFAIK) they are not visible for scripts from StatCounter and similar companies. So results of browsers like Firefox, Opera, Vivaldi, Brave may be understated, am I right?