4 ms·
Its targeted gene mutation versus random gene mutation - not very different if you ask me.
by collyw 11y ago
Its targeted gene mutation versus random gene mutation - not very different if you ask me.
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoThere's a difference between marker assisted selection ('traditional' breeding aided by the use of genetic analysis to look for desired traits early) and physically editing the genome. I suspect you'd find most GMO critics are fine with the former. Most worrisome there have been several cases where funding for breeding programs has been cut because the 'new hotness' of genetic engineering pulls in more industry funding. An example is the 'Arctic' non-browning GMO apple here in Canada. It's a sad stupid story. Non-browning already exists as a potential trait in the natural Malus genome. Selective breeding had already produced apples here and there that had this trait. Despite this federal funding and regulatory approval was extended to the GMO program and cut from traditional breeding. And an existing non-GMO non-browning apple was ordered destroyed from a research centre. Meanwhile the Arctic apple even after approval for sale has only generated controversy, and now consumers who are suspicious about GMO will be suspicious about _any_ apple that demonstrates non-browning, GMO or not.
- collyw 11y ago"I suspect you'd find most GMO critics are fine with the former" Most GMO critics that I have spoken to don't have a clue about how it actually works. "A fish gene in a plant?!?" being the sort of quote they will come out with, not realizing that we share a huge portion of our genomes with fish.
- littletimmy 11y agoIf you want to be taken seriously, take on the best of the GMO skeptics rather than the worst. Going for easy pickings like these is a waste of everyone's time.
- collyw 11y agoI have yet to meet one that knows the basics of biology.
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoYou just replied to one. I'm trained in horticulture own a small hobby farm, I breed plants, and have a license to spray pesticides. But sure, go on beating up your straw man.
- collyw 11y agoI haven't met you you just replied to a comment on this forum. Plus horticulture doesn't imply an understanding of what is going on during cell replication at a molecular level (OK, I said did say biology, can we change that to molecular biology).