4 ms·
The licensing issue with PyQt is very simple: it's the main source of revenue for Riverbank, a small UK company founded by PyQt's author, Phil Thompson. He can'
by toyg 11y ago
The licensing issue with PyQt is very simple: it's the main source of revenue for Riverbank, a small UK company founded by PyQt's author, Phil Thompson. He can't give it away for free because it's literally his livelihood. He does a great job of evolving and updating the wrappers -- just ask how "easy" that is to the PySide authors, which are supposed to do the same job and have been struggling (technically and financially) ever since their project lost "free money" when Nokia died.
The licensing for Qt itself is very simple: if you redistribute and don't go GPL, you have to pay. It's one of the fairest arrangements out there. PyQt has similar terms.
- throwaway13337 11y agoI'm not implying these vendors should work for free. Just that they could have been more creative with the way they monetized. The way that makes most sense to me is charging for the authoring tools and making the language/VM completely open (e.g. MIT license). Maybe that's too idealistic?
- infinite8s 11y agoHave you tried making a living that way?
- kgwgk 11y ago> I'm not implying these vendors should work for free. You're implying that they should charge others for the parts that you don't care about? If only they had been a bit more creative...
- throwaway13337 11y agoNot at all. I used adobe's toolset for flash. Even if flash was open source completely, I'm sure the authoring tool would have been still nearly required. Keeping the underlying language open simply means that it would have been more usable and extensible.
- kgwgk 11y agoOk. I don't know anything about PyQt so if you tell me that the dual license arrangement prevents you from using and extending it, despite your willingness to pay, I'll take your word for it.
- iamcreasy 11y agoI think you can use Qt free license in your commercial product(distribute it or not) as long as you dynamically link Qt libraries.
- toyg 11y agoThe situation for Qt has changed several times in the last few years through the various acquisitions, so yeah, I might be a bit out of date because it doesn't really matter for PyQt itself -- that's just GPL or commercial.
- mherrmann 11y agoExactly. The LGPL (which Qt is licensed under) permits this. It also permits subclassing. What toyg wrote would be true if Qt were licensed under the GPL.
- dagw 11y agoQt is under the LGPL, but PyQt isn't. So if you want to develop Qt applications with python and PyQt you have to abide by the GPL, not just the LGPL, or buy a commercial license.
- infinite8s 11y agoYou can use the LGPL version of Qt and the commercial version of PyQT (which is much cheaper than the commercial version of Qt)
- dbcurtis 11y agopyside recently came back under the Qt umbrella, so it should be viable option again.
- sevensor 11y agoAnd, PyQt works great! I've been playing around with the QOpenGLWidget lately, which not only integrates beautifully with the rest of Qt, but also makes it really easy to write and use a shader program. It's a shame, although not at all surprising, that the few decent online tutorials for modern OpenGL go the C++ / GLEW route. The barrier to entry with PyQt is so much lower!