3 ms·
Indefinite prison for suspect who won’t decrypt hard drives, feds say
- gedy 11y agoThe suspect sounds vile if this is true, but is there not a way to convict based on some evidence apart from unlocking his encrypted hard drive?
- damienkatz 11y agoI wonder what if he legitimately doesn't remember the passwords? How can you possibly prove or disprove such a thing?
- DanBC 11y agoYou don't need to prove / disprove that the defendent hasn't forgotten their pass, you need to convince someone else. For some cases the burden of proof will be "balance of probabilities"; for other cases it'll be "beyond all reasonable doubt". This is the kind of thing that courts deal with all the time - how can you prove that a thief had the intention of permanently depriving someone of something and wasn't just borrowing that item? How can you prove a murderer really wanted to kill a person and not just injure them?
- dmfdmf 11y ago> The authorities also said that it's not a violation of the man's Fifth Amendment right against compelled self incrimination because it's a "foregone conclusion" that illegal porn is on the drives, and that he is only being asked to unlock the drives, not divulge their passcodes. If its a "foregone conclusion" then why do they need it? If the authorities made this claim in a legal brief they should lose the argument. It concedes the need for the decryption. Either they have evidence apart from the drive or they don't. I think if this guy was into child porn there has to be enough circumstantial evidence in logs and download records to convict. Its no accident that this case is against a child pornographer, don't be fooled, the government is trying to establish legal precedent on the most loathsome of criminals and then later will expand their powers.
- cnvogel 11y agoOne important fact one should keep in mind: This particular case is likely pushed forward because the suspect is accused (morally, and not even in a legal/formal way, as the article mentions) of a particularly abhorrent crime. It's always Child-Pornography and Terrorism. Once it will become standard practice to force people to decrypt files or harddrives, expect being compelled to unlock your computer for suspicion of owning pirated files, "whistleblown" documents or GPS logs of traffic infringements :-(
- shirro 11y agoProsecutor: "We have found a witch, may we burn her?" Judge: "How do you known she is a witch?" Prosecutor: "She won't decrypt her hard drive" All: "A witch! burn her burn her!!"
- sharemywin 11y agoto me it's speech. <sarcasm>Why not just save everyone time and jail all the criminals until they say they are guilty. obviously, if the prosecutor thinks he's guilt we should take his word for it. </sarcasm>