6 ms·
Linguistic purism in English
- ludamad 11y agoLinguistic purism in English is a different topic now than it use to be with English as an international language. I believe spelling reform to be the much more fruitful topic.
- fighting 11y agoIt would be interesting if the common availability of spellcheck turned out to obviate such reform. Technology would be retarding progress and enabling ossification in this instance.
- kmicklas 11y agoSpellcheck more or less solves the needs of an educated native speaker who occasionally forgets weird spellings. But there's still a huge economic and educational burden to teaching spelling to kids and (especially) the millions of non-native learners.
- fenomas 11y agoIt seems to me that issues like this are far more pressing for languages like Japanese and Chinese, where the rise of fonts and IMEs makes it technically unfeasible to create or change the fundamental building blocks of words (kanji). For Japanese, the current state is that most new words are loan words written with the non-kanji syllabaries. It makes you wonder if someday the loan words will overbalance the originals, causing kanji to die out from Japanese (as it has, to some extent, from Korean).
- barry-cotter 11y ago>It seems to me that issues like this are far more pressing for languages like Japanese and Chinese, where the rise of fonts and IMEs makes it technically unfeasible to create or change the fundamental building blocks of words (kanji). This is not a technological issue, it's a social one. After the American conquest of Japan the American occupation forces were quite keen on the idea of language reform, whether using romaji or one of the native syllabaries. The idea died a death when they compared ease of decoding/reading speed. Japanese speakers, even not terribly well educated ones in terms of years of education were on a level with English speakers. Mao wanted to replace the hanzi with pinyin (the modern romanisation used in the PRC) but didn't feel it was worth the political cost. Replacing the hanzi/kanji would be a boon for foreigners but a massive and unnecessary disruption for Japanese and Chinese speakers. >For Japanese, the current state is that most new words are loan words written with the non-kanji syllabaries. It makes you wonder if someday the loan words will overbalance the originals, causing kanji to die out from Japanese (as it has, to some extent, from Korean). Korean is a very different case from Japanese or Chinese. If the Japanese hadn't conquered Korea they'd probably be using some combination of hanja (hanzi/kanji) and hangul (the syllabary used in modern Korea (North and South). To be fair that's the case nowadays but there are less than 300 hanja that every educated Korean would know. Any literate Japanese person knows over two thousand. The kanji aren't going anywhere in Japanese. They're the words that you use for educated, literate speech.
- fenomas 11y ago> This is not a technological issue, it's a social one. I meant that fonts and IMEs make it technically unfeasible to change kanji or create new ones. > kanji .. are the words that you use for educated, literate speech. But not for neologisms. That's what my post was about.
- gizmo686 11y agoI wonder how relevant technology has been to the reduction in kanji. It seems like the technical difficulties in adding kanji pale in comparison to the social difficulties of teaching the new kanji to the public; especially when you realize that this is the language that gave us emojis. Further, my lay understanding of Japanese history is that their have been many attempts to reduce or eliminate kanji usage.
- rjsw 11y agoMaybe emoji should be considered to be new kanji.
- getoj 11y ago>I wonder how relevant technology has been to the reduction in kanji. Actually IMEs have led to a resurgence in kanji usage. A lot of words that normal people could not (and were not expected to) write in kanji are now used online every day, to the extent that grade schools now teach them as kanji to appear on reading tests but not to be graded in handwritten essays. The most famous example of these "read only" kanji is 鬱 ('utsu', depression or melancholy), introduced to the school system in 2013 (iirc). Also words that can be written in either kanji or kana but with a preference for kana in modern edited text are often written in kanji online (like 或いは instead of あるいは).
- ludamad 11y agoPeople spelling things nonstandardly is not really a serious issue in the first place. It's the extra information that must be learned, raising the bar for non-native speakers and people with a learning disability.
- getoj 11y agoA major problem of English spelling reform is that pronunciation varies widely among native speakers. That problem is only made worse by an even greater number of non-native speakers having appeared, with an even greater variety of pronunciations. If you say t'meito and I say t'mahto, and a Spanish speaker says tomato and a Korean speaker says 토마토 and a Japanese speaker says トマト, none of which are phonetically the same, it seems like spelling it 'tomato' is as good a system as any.
- skissane 11y agoI was about to say the same thing. For example, I speak a non-rhotic dialect of English (Australian) in which the "r" is silent in many words (e.g. "hard"); whereas in many other dialects (e.g. most US dialects) that "r" is pronounced. So, dropping the "r" from the spelling of that word would make it more phonetic for me, but less phonetic for most Americans. To introduce phonetic spelling into English, you'd need to either privilege one dialect's pronunciation over all the others (which speakers of those other dialects would be unlikely to accept), or else you'd end up with far greater spelling variation between different dialects of English than exists at present (which would harm international communication.) The other problem with phonetic spelling is that phonology changes faster than orthography. If we adopted phonetic spelling tomorrow, then within a few generations many of those spellings likely wouldn't be phonetic any more. Keeping orthography reasonably fixed over time (even as pronunciation changes) makes it easier for us to understand the written texts of past generations.
- eru 11y agoIn German we went with the first option: elevate one dialect. I heard in Turkish they went with another option: everything is spelled phonetically, and there's a `standard' pronunciation / spelling. But I heard of a case where some people spell a word differently, because they pronounce it differently. (And that's seen not as a failing of these people's spelling.)
- bigger_cheese 11y agoI had a friend from Austria who told me some words were spelt differently in 'Austrian German' than in Germany. So I think the same problem exists. I'm Australian we mostly use British English. The biggest complaint for me is in Programming language API's. "colour" vs "color" and "centre" vs "center" have cause me so many syntax errors.
- chillacy 11y agoIt's one reason english got in this mess in the first place: > From the 16th century onward, English writers who were scholars of Greek and Latin literature tried to link English words to their Graeco-Latin counterparts. They did this by adding silent letters to make the real or imagined links more obvious. Thus det became debt (to link it to Latin debitum), dout became doubt (to link it to Latin dubitare), sissors became scissors and sithe became scythe (as they were wrongly thought to come from Latin scindere), iland became island (as it was wrongly thought to come from Latin insula), ake became ache (as it was wrongly thought to come from Greek akhos), and so forth.[6][7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English-language_spelling_reform https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English-language_spelling_refo... That wiki also lists a number of proposed spelling reforms.
- wnoise 11y agoIf spelling and pronunciation differ, why is it that spelling needs to change? Clearly the right solution is pronunciation reform. (And given that there are many pronunciations in common usage, we can't alter the spelling to fit them all. And there are essentially only two spelling systems, and they only differ in minor ways.)
- katedye 11y agoIt seems odd that Orwell advocated for English purism, 1984 makes it seem like using 'base' English words as building blocks and eliminating unnecessary, flowery language was synonymous with fascism (or at least not a good thing)
- jsprogrammer 11y agoI think the real power was in getting words to "mean their opposite"; WAR IS PEACE, etc.
- danharaj 11y agoThe threat of newspeak is that it can render concepts unspeakable. Orwell advocated using words better. A simple word that bears the right meaning is better than a complex word that has nuance, but in having nuance is flabby. He complains in particular that "prose consists less and less of words chosen for the sake of their meaning, and more and more of phrases tacked together like the sections of a prefabricated hen-house." He claims that there is political intent behind the trendy language of the day. He's probably right. I will walk out of the conference room the next time someone tells me to "drill down" or "circle back" or "touch base". I'll do it for Orwell. Think of it as a cargo cult of language; play-acting at meaning-saying: Language wielded like a ritual dagger instead of a tool. You can recognize some examples of what he'd complain about if you pay attention to that sense. I'm annoyed by lots of uses of English; I must be fun to be around. I can't say they're misuses, but i dislike them. My favorite might be "I would argue", followed by... the author making an argument? Why the distancing? It's a verbal tick. It creates an air of passivity or detachment which is immediately contradicted by the words that follow. I suppose there's an idea these days that being detached and emotionless confers objectivity and wisdom, but I can't say i know at all for certain why people write or speak the way they do. Language should stick to meaning like muscle to bone. http://www.orwell.ru/library/essays/politics/english/e_polit/ http://www.orwell.ru/library/essays/politics/english/e_polit...
- sb057 11y agoI think Orwell's view of language is the same basic principle as engineering: keep it as simple as possible. Don't make it too simple as to lose meaning, but don't needlessly overcomplicate things either.
- girzel 11y agoI was going to comment that they're about a thousand years too late with this, but then read the article and saw that that was precisely the point. It's a lovely thought that, in this modern day, we might once again unlock our wordhoards! I once read a poem by Seamus Heaney (who also re-translated Beowulf) in which the language of the poem itself recapitulated the development of English over the centuries. It was really quite beautiful, though a bare five minutes of Googling has not turned up the name. edit: I think it's the Bone Dream sequence, from the collection North.
- mc32 11y agoYeah, I like his translation. I think in the intro he speaks about discovering that the word 'þolian' in Beowulf was used pretty commonly by someone in his family, in its modern incarnation, thole, and was fascinated by that coincidence. [and the kicker, IIRC, was the speaker thought it more indigenous (to Ireland) than the "regular" English words.]
- redsummer 11y agoIs there a spellchecker or style-checker which helps you write plain pre-Norman English (or another "pure" form of English)? In it's simplest form it could just be a dictionary of acceptable words. A more sophisticated version would suggest "pure" replacements of impure words.
- arctor 11y agoPre-Norman English looks like this - "Wé Gárdena in géardagum þéodcyninga þrym gefrúnon hú ðá æþelingas ellen fremedon". I reckon you'd have to sacrifice quite a lot of intelligibility in your quest for purity.
- wtbob 11y agoThat's not quite fair. Sure, it'd be cool to bring back þ, ð, æ & ȝ, and maybe even to have Anglo-Saxon as a kind of priestly or formal tongue. But that's not needful. One can choose to use 'hearty' instead 'cordial' &c. I wouldn't mind a tool which helped me choose words of Anglo-Saxon parentage rather than Latin, when they exist.
- tomc1985 11y agoThe want of linguistic purity is superfluous, and contrary to how languages develop. In the comforts of daily life polyglots fuse their multiple languages together, creating a new dialect. I'm no linguist but one can clearly observe this in japanese "Engrish" (which is a real phenomenon abroad, my former sensei had stories of mispronounced English being taught in schools and understood locally), or in hybrids like Afrikaans or Portuguese. Or in any of the regional dialects that spring up in mixed cultures. "Pure" languages like Esperanto are neat, and I think they can serve a legitimate and useful role at the world's table, but a language that fights impurities has to constantly push against a strong current. (See: French.) Real language is messy -- because if the majority of people break some rule of grammar together, it becomes the new grammar! Also, those examples of 'pure' Modern English were ugly/crude-looking/inelegant :(
- Angostura 11y ago> The want of linguistic purity is superfluous, A "want of" something means a 'lack of' - "The kingdom was lost for want of a nail" You probably want "the want for"
- tomc1985 11y agoI had always heard that as "for want of," but whatever, it's too late to edit
- TelmoMenezes 11y ago> or in hybrids like Afrikaans or Portuguese Portuguese is not a hybrid language, it's a romance language, a direct descendant of Latin with some influences from classical Greek, the same as Spanish, French, Italian and so on. Modern English could more easily be classified as "hybrid" than Portuguese, given how much it is influenced by both French and Germanic languages.
- blowski 11y agoIs Brazilian Portuguese a hybrid? It borrows an awful lot from English, African and native American languages.
- ScottBurson 11y agoThe problem with defending the purity of the English language is that English is about as pure as a cribhouse whore. We don't just borrow words; on occasion, English has pursued other languages down alleyways to beat them unconscious and rifle their pockets for new vocabulary. -- James Nicoll (originally posted to Usenet!)
- jhanschoo 11y agohttp://anglish.wikia.com/wiki/Main_leaf http://anglish.wikia.com/wiki/Main_leaf Here's a wiki in Anglish. It looks very fun.
- lgessler 11y agoIt might be interesting to consider bodies some countries have created to regulate language use. In particular, in some some cases (as far as I'm aware), they do their best to purge the language of foreign loanwords. See French's Académie française and Hindi's Central Hindi Directorate.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoInteresting that you anglicized one instead of the other, that is, why not use "French Academy" and "Kendriya Hindi Nideshalaya".