4 ms·
What should he have done instead? A more circumspect whistleblower who worked within the system could have exposed wrongdoing without risking legitimate secret
by PhasmaFelis 11y ago
What should he have done instead?
A more circumspect whistleblower who worked within the system could have exposed wrongdoing without risking legitimate secrets, yes. But whistleblowers aren't allowed to work within the system. Snowden tried and was rebuffed. The tactic he eventually chose was less harmful than allowing the NSA to continue running wild with no effective oversight.
- slg 11y ago>What should he have done instead? It could have been something as simple as telling the journalists "You only have the documents because I leaked them to you therefore everything you publish is my responsibility both legally and ethically. In turn, as long as I am alive I request editorial approval of everything you publish on the subject." >The tactic he eventually chose was less harmful than allowing the NSA to continue running wild with no effective oversight. Like mass surveillance is less harmful than potential allowing the next 9/11? Don't you see the flaw in this logic? You can't just ignore the law because you personally think the ends justify the means. This applies equally to both sides of the debate.
- sjburt 11y agoSnowden does not have access to anything he leaked any more. He physically turned everything over before he left Hong Kong and did not bring copies with him to Russia. Since he's undoubtedly under surveillance in Russia, there's not any safe way for him to review anything.