3 ms·
They can innovate. Startups often make shit products the market doesn't want too, and often fail more slowly and expensively than the example of Gerber's adult
by notahacker 11y ago
They can innovate. Startups often make shit products the market doesn't want too, and often fail more slowly and expensively than the example of Gerber's adult food line; the article could instead have talked about how Gerber did successfully roll out a life insurance product. The followup articles mention Xerox and Apple: two companies which produced more game changing products as mature companies than 99.99% of Silicon Valley ever will.
If I was to propose my own cod theory of why big companies don't innovate, it would probably involve them seeing innovation as driven by MBAs formulating "innovation strategies" based on articles full of interesting anecdotes and open-to-interpretation theories rather than management saying yes to a higher proportion of projects their underlings want budget for.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoOne trip to Walmart or a large, grocery store shows you how much the big companies can innovate. Actually, they do it even more than that but often do focus groups in a form of fail-early and fail-fast. The bad ideas get weeded out before they can soil the brand or dilute the earnings. What we see is what at least seemed to work. It then usually makes plenty of money. Also, the big companies' innovation usually nets them tens to hundreds of millions in extra revenues or plenty of profit. They care about making money, not growth to sell out. Changes the nature of innovation considerably.
- nol13 11y agoCan't speak for all giant companies, but they care about percent growth. A product that might be profitable, but millions profitable and not billions profitable, it isn't worth the effort and gets axed or sold. A 0.1% profit boost isn't gonna matter to share price. Not saying I agree with it, just an observation.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoIt depends on the company. Many of the big companies... can't say most without data... get their money through a collection of products and services. They do care about millions because a million here and there accumulates. The low-margin business care down to the pennies of individual items. So, that isn't a rule for big businesses especially in the Global 2000. Many care about that stuff. There's just competing interests that can axe one thing for another. The ones doing stupid, expensive stuff also make the news more since "incrementally improved operation to make more money" isn't as exciting over coffee. ;)
- saosebastiao 11y ago> If I was to propose my own cod theory of why big companies don't innovate, it would probably involve them seeing innovation as driven by MBAs formulating "innovation strategies" based on articles full of interesting anecdotes and open-to-interpretation theories rather than management saying yes to a higher proportion of projects their underlings want budget for. Well said. Even at innovative companies like Apple or Amazon, it's amazing how many interesting and exceptional ideas get budgeted out of existence due to prioritization of top down initiatives from senior level executives that are several levels removed from customers and the people capable of solving the customers' problems.