5 ms·
I understand the technical limitations. But here's what I don't understand at all... Has anyone ever been sailing? On yachts we have radios, but these radios
by Someone1234 11y ago
I understand the technical limitations.
But here's what I don't understand at all...
Has anyone ever been sailing? On yachts we have radios, but these radios are designed assuming the person operating it might be completely ignorant.
So we have this literal red button, you lift a flap, hold down the button and the radio sends an SOS with complete GPS coordinates and boat name on Channel 16. Then it leaves it on channel 16 so you can describe the emergency.
So back to smartphones, on smartphones we have dialer apps, these apps know when you dial 911. Why in holy heck don't they have a big red button on-screen which when pushed sends your current GPS coordinates USING VOICE over the open line?
Here's what we need to do that:
- Dialer app. CHECK.
- GPS. CHECK.
- Some kind of UI. CHECK.
- Text to voice system. CHECK.
We have all of the components to roll out a system TODAY which tells 911 via voice where you are calling from. It would almost be free, but we haven't, and nobody is suggesting it.
Everyone is talking about these crazy complicated standards that will, best case, be available in 2021 and cost ungodly amounts. I am talking about using voice which the operator themselves can type in.
Am I mad here? Why isn't this a thing? Why doesn't the dialer even DISPLAY GPS coordinates when you dial 911?
Seriously I bet if someone made this a big deal we could get Apple and Google to sign on almost immediately and this would be available within a year. All smartphones already have all of the prerequisites to do this!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 11y agoSearching "911 app" returns results. They exist.
- HiroshiSan 11y agoThe whole point is that you shouldn't have to download a third-party app, it should already be a feature on your phone. Analogous to how organ donation should be opt-out instead of opt-in.
- wayn3 11y agoBeing owned by the government by default sounds reasonable.
- jocro 11y agoIf you're dead, what's to own? If anyone takes specific exemption to it they could opt out - but for everyone else we address a legitimate public concern (lack of organs for donation) by accessing an otherwise wasted resource. And it's not like this is a readily producible resource - people die on organ transfer lists precisely because other avenues of acquisition can't meet the necessary levels. It's a question of priority IMO, maybe not philosophically ideal but in a cooperative society compromise can save many lives.
- astrodust 11y agoIndia just mandated a panic button in all phones (http://money.cnn.com/2016/04/27/technology/india-smartphone-panic-button-rape/ http://money.cnn.com/2016/04/27/technology/india-smartphone-...) so you might get this kind of functionality rolled out more broadly once it's implemented there.
- StephenConnell 11y agoMy android s6 active has pocket dialed 911 a handful of times in the past month. I called dispatch to apologize, they took down my info and confirmed my address. They were only a couple of houses off. Not too bad. I must say I hate the emergency button on the stock lock screen, and how glitchy replacement lock screens are.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- enzanki_ars 11y agoA couple houses off could mean life or death in a real emergency.
- yellowapple 11y agoTo add onto this: isn't this basically how many modern home alarm systems already work? I'm pretty sure that if they detect a break-in or a fire, they'll at the very least call some corporate call center (or perhaps even 911 directly) with location details and a description of the problem.