4 ms·
> Perhaps a better use of this soapbox, instead of lambasting the researchers, would be to raise awareness of the fact that what you put onto the Internet is pu
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
> Perhaps a better use of this soapbox, instead of lambasting the researchers, would be to raise awareness of the fact that what you put onto the Internet is public.
That is maybe not the best lesson to take from this.
The problem seems to be that people want to create a binary distinction between "public" (meaning public domain, can be used for anything by anyone) and "private" (meaning something known solely to a single individual), with no intermediary steps between them.
But profile data like this is something that lives in the space in between. You're clearly intending to share it with people in a particular category (other similarly-situated users) but not everyone and not forever. It's the sort of data you expect not to be archived; if you delete your account then it should go away.
That is not how the laws of physics work. If you allow the data to be seen by other users and anyone can sign up to be another user then anyone can see the data and anyone can copy it. But that is why we have social norms. That is why finding the online dating profile of everyone who works at the same company as you and then mass mailing it to everyone in the office is not considered friendly behavior.
And probably what companies that run sites like this should be doing is adopting a robots.txt that disallows crawling of user profiles and then rate limiting to some maximum number of profile views (e.g. 10,000/month) that no real user would ever hit but would provide a good hint to data hoovering operations that they aren't wanted here.
- drdaeman 11y ago> people want to create a binary distinction between "public" [...] and "private" Because they (me included) tend to believe that's how it works in reality - at least when the worst-case scenarios kick in. Something's either known or not, and there's a saying that a word spoken is past recalling (or similar idioms in many languages). Social and legal norms may provide one with a recourse/remedy after the exposure, trying to compensate for the leak, create a chilling effect to prevent others from performing similar actions, and possibly limit the distribution of the leaked information. Nonetheless, chances are, it will already be seen (and copied) by many, thus effectively becoming public. Sure, sometimes data could get lost forever, with no public copies remaining, but sometimes it could rise to extent of Streisand effect as well. So, well, I tend to believe it's a good idea to raise awareness that the only guaranteed way to not get burnt is to not share the sensitive information, at the very least with the parties you can't trust to handle it. And trusting any party must also include a consideration of the risks involved. This probably sounds harsh, but the idea of awareness is that it must be better be informed about worst-case scenarios and be safe(r) than unaware and sorry.
- ghaff 11y ago>a robots.txt that disallows crawling of user profiles It's a voluntary mechanism and convention that requests that pages not be crawled, which is somewhat different from what you wrote. (Which isn't to say that it shouldn't be used buy AFAIK it has no legal significance.)
- EdHominem 11y agoIt's intended as a way to help robots crawl a site. If you have a robot that doesn't need help it should ignore the file. Because so many people misunderstand it, robots.txt is often a list of what you should crawl to find the good stuff.
- EdHominem 11y agoNo, robots.txt is never related to authorization. Even suggesting it in the same post is misleading. If you have something that shouldn't be seen, password protect it. Also, your rate-limiting idea misses the point. It just adds a few steps to the scraping process without actually changing the game. If you realize you can't hide profiles you need to tell your users that they should write a profile they wouldn't mind having seen at work, not pretend that making the door smaller helps.