26 ms·
My first instinct in this case is to agree that the data is public, or at the very least, protected by account login and therefore only legally protected by the
by chatmasta 11y ago
My first instinct in this case is to agree that the data is public, or at the very least, protected by account login and therefore only legally protected by the OkCupid terms of use. I see no possible legal argument against the methods of data collection, unless OkCupid wants to sue the researcher for breaching terms of use. Or, perhaps, users could sue OkCupid for failing to diligently protect their data.
That said, this was an Academic study, presumably funded at least in part by the University, and therefore subject to approval from an Institutional Review Board (IRB) [0]. Granted it was not an American university, so perhaps no IRB exists. And it was a small study by a group of graduate students, which seems unlikely to be subject to as much scrutiny as a study officially funded and endorsed by the university. However, this is no excuse for circumventing research ethics. To quote the wiki article, "a key goal of IRBs is to protect human subjects from physical or psychological harm," which implies that moral arguments should hold at least as much weight as legal arguments when considering the potential impact of a study.
It's entirely possible for a study to be legal, but immoral. Since this study came from a university, any moral argument should be as valid as a legal one. The trouble seems to be that nobody heard any argument, moral or legal, before approving the study.
In this case, the failure seems to lie with the Danish University, who allowed its graduate students to conduct a study without consultation from an IRB or any kind of ethical oversight committee.
Interestingly, the data is "public," in the sense that anyone could replicate this study with some Python and OkCupid accounts. So even if researchers are stopped by an IRB from collecting the data, that doesn't mean another entity can't do the exact same study, free from any procedural impediments. So it makes you wonder about the premise of questioning the study in the first place. Perhaps a better use of this soapbox, instead of lambasting the researchers, would be to raise awareness of the fact that what you put onto the Internet is public.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_review_board https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_review_board
- chimeracoder 11y ago> And it was a small study by a group of graduate students, which seems unlikely to be subject to as much scrutiny as a study officially funded and endorsed by the university Whether or not this is what happens in practice, the purview of an IRB in the US very much is supposed to cover this situation. IRBs have intentionally broad mandates and cover quite a lot of things that most people would not immediately recognize as 'research' or 'experiments'. > to raise awareness of the fact that what you put onto the Internet is public. Most technical people consider 'doxxing' to be bad. However, in most cases, 'doxxing' is simply publicizing information that is already part of the public record[0]. There's a difference, based on the barrier to accessing that information. [0] If I know your name and your city/state of residence, it's trivial for me to obtain a copy of your driver's license or voting registration information FOIA/FOIL requests typically charge a nominal processing fee to cover the costs of processing the requests, but only because it's a largely manual process, and the marginal costs of requesting many records at once is very low.
- chatmasta 11y ago(Not disagreeing with you in any way, just want to add onto your points) > IRBs have intentionally broad mandates and cover quite a lot of things that most people would not immediately recognize as 'research' or 'experiments'. And yet, professors routinely assign their students to conduct informal "studies" for class credit (perhaps a final project) or learning experience. These sort of "studies" are rarely, if ever, sent to any kind of IRB, and yet plenty of undergraduates are capable of creating a python scraper to download data from OkCupid. > "There's a difference, based on the barrier to accessing that information" What is "that information" in the case of this OkCupid study, and what is the "barrier," before and after the research was published? If the "information" is, for example, the fact that your spouse is cheating on you, does this research really remove any "barrier" to make it easier to discover than it was before publishing? If I wanted to know if my spouse was cheating on me, I could simply create an OkCupid profile and check the listings in my local town around my spouse's age range. Releasing the data of 60,000 OkCupid accounts, all of which is accessible from simply logging into the website, does not make it any easier for me to find that profile. Also note that this is different from, say, the Ashley Madison hack, where email addresses were released from an internal, private database. The emails were not "public" information before the data dump, and therefore the data dump lowered the "barrier" to searching for a target individual amongst the thousands of members. In this case, it seems the "data dump" did not introduce any new paths of accessing information. Instead it simply mirrored information that already exists and is readily accessible by effectively anyone with a computer.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> What is "that information" in the case of this OkCupid study, and what is the "barrier," before and after the research was published? To clarify, I'm contesting this statement: > Perhaps a better use of this soapbox, instead of lambasting the researchers, would be to raise awareness of the fact that what you put onto the Internet is public. on the grounds that, even if we were talking entirely about information that is already 100% 'public', there are ethical concerns with making already-public information more readily accessible (and therefore easier to use for nefarious purposes). Doxxing is an easy example because most people generally agree that it crosses some sort of ethical line, and there are plenty of clear examples where doxxed information has been used for nefarious purposes (ie, to harass, stalk, and/or abuse the victim). In other words, I'm not saying that all of the information in this particular case was already public. I'm saying that focusing on that distinction is a distraction from the underlying issue.
- lanaius 11y agoNormally publishers look for some statements (either in the manuscript or in the submission or both) that you have followed ethical standards in gathering and sharing the data. It's easy to bypass that when you start your own Journal!
- akyall 11y agoIRBs are an American institution. My understanding is that research ethics in Europe are governed by inter-institutional ethics committees, but only for biomedical research (i.e. clinical trials). That aside, IRBs have been very slow to adjust review procedures for online studies. For example, the nonmedical IRB at Cornell determined that the Facebook emotional contagion experiment was outside of its jurisdiction, since Facebook was the data collection agent-- from their perspective the Cornell researchers were working with a pre-existing dataset. So it's not necessarily the case that ethics review is a silver bullet for cases like this. It's not clear to me that we have a good understanding of what ethical responsibility looks like in this domain, in large part because the organization of research on online behavior (a joint venture between social scientists, software engineers, universities, companies like OKCupid, etc.) is still poorly understood by most of the academic world.
- cs2818 11y agoIRB would likely not review this if the researcher pitched it to them as a public dataset. 45 CFR 46.101(b)(4) enumerates topics which are exempt from IRB review, one is: "Research involving the collection or study of existing data, documents, records, pathological specimens, or diagnostic specimens, if these sources are publicly available or if the information is recorded by the investigator in such a manner that subjects cannot be identified, directly or through identifiers linked to the subjects." [0] http://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/regulations/45-cfr-46/index.html#46.101 http://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/regulations/4...
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> Perhaps a better use of this soapbox, instead of lambasting the researchers, would be to raise awareness of the fact that what you put onto the Internet is public. That is maybe not the best lesson to take from this. The problem seems to be that people want to create a binary distinction between "public" (meaning public domain, can be used for anything by anyone) and "private" (meaning something known solely to a single individual), with no intermediary steps between them. But profile data like this is something that lives in the space in between. You're clearly intending to share it with people in a particular category (other similarly-situated users) but not everyone and not forever. It's the sort of data you expect not to be archived; if you delete your account then it should go away. That is not how the laws of physics work. If you allow the data to be seen by other users and anyone can sign up to be another user then anyone can see the data and anyone can copy it. But that is why we have social norms. That is why finding the online dating profile of everyone who works at the same company as you and then mass mailing it to everyone in the office is not considered friendly behavior. And probably what companies that run sites like this should be doing is adopting a robots.txt that disallows crawling of user profiles and then rate limiting to some maximum number of profile views (e.g. 10,000/month) that no real user would ever hit but would provide a good hint to data hoovering operations that they aren't wanted here.
- drdaeman 11y ago> people want to create a binary distinction between "public" [...] and "private" Because they (me included) tend to believe that's how it works in reality - at least when the worst-case scenarios kick in. Something's either known or not, and there's a saying that a word spoken is past recalling (or similar idioms in many languages). Social and legal norms may provide one with a recourse/remedy after the exposure, trying to compensate for the leak, create a chilling effect to prevent others from performing similar actions, and possibly limit the distribution of the leaked information. Nonetheless, chances are, it will already be seen (and copied) by many, thus effectively becoming public. Sure, sometimes data could get lost forever, with no public copies remaining, but sometimes it could rise to extent of Streisand effect as well. So, well, I tend to believe it's a good idea to raise awareness that the only guaranteed way to not get burnt is to not share the sensitive information, at the very least with the parties you can't trust to handle it. And trusting any party must also include a consideration of the risks involved. This probably sounds harsh, but the idea of awareness is that it must be better be informed about worst-case scenarios and be safe(r) than unaware and sorry.
- lowbloodsugar 11y agoIANAL but IIRC if a person accesses a computer in violation of a terms of use agreement, then the government can prosecute them for unauthorized access under CFAA. The government. Not OkCupid. Prosecute, not sue. OkCupid has a statement in its terms of use that this is for personal use only. Accessing it for the purpose of sharing data as an academic study seems to violate those terms of use, which would mean access was illegal under CFAA.
- drdaeman 11y agoFound this on Wikipedia[1]: > United States v. Lori Drew, 2008. The cyberbullying case involving the suicide of a girl harassed on myspace. Charges were under 18 USC 1030(a)(2)(c) and (b)(2)(c). Judge Wu decided that using 18 U.S.C. § 1030(a)(2)(C) against someone violating a terms of service agreement would make the law overly broad. 259 F.R.D. 449 I think it was a wise decision. This particular case aside, government's ability to prosecute over ToS violations opens up an enormous way for possible abuse (think of visiting a site whose ToS forbid ad-blocking with one active). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act#cite_ref-8 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act#c...
- fredophile 11y agoHis webpage says he's a student in linguistics. He appears to have no psychology credentials. The article does a really poor job of pointing this out and just refers to him as a graduate student. This appears to have been done through OpenPsych which is a project he founded. I'd be willing to bet that there was zero oversight and no ethics committee for this "study".