3 ms·
> The biggest protection a worker has is his ability to quit and find another employer. That's only ever a protection as long as your skills are valued and in
by masklinn 11y ago
> The biggest protection a worker has is his ability to quit and find another employer.
That's only ever a protection as long as your skills are valued and in high demand. Which means it's only a temporary protection, and only for a minority of the population.
> All other "protections" usually end up costing you someway or another.
The "other" is misplaced here, if all you have is the ability to quit, you have no stability[0], you have limited bargaining power (and are pretty systematically in a position of weakness), and the cooperative incentives with coworkers are very different, and arguably lower.
[0] and things get worse if you own property (now your "protection" is tied to property markets), a partner (now your "protection" may be tied to fucking them over) or dependents
- segmondy 11y ago> That's only ever a protection as long as your skills are valued and in high demand. Which means it's only a temporary protection, and only for a minority of the population. What's wrong with that? If your skills are not valued or in high demand, you don't deserve any protection. Retool and equip yourself with valuable and skills that are in demand. Should I be protected because I dug my head deep into MSDOS or APL and refused to catch up to the modern day ubiquitous Unix systems and C++?
- vertex-four 11y ago> Retool and equip yourself with valuable and skills that are in demand. So precisely how does the US allow people to do that? Which programs are available which will keep a family of 4 fed, sheltered and clothed while the parents retool because their jobs are shitty and probably doing illegal things, and they know for a fact that the second they call their company out they're going to get fired? No, you shouldn't be protected from your job actually disappearing (past getting paid off) - but you should be protected from your employer being awful.
- NotSammyHagar 11y agoAnd of course there aren't any programs. Suppose you don't have a good education, and your only job is janitor. Should you make minimum wage for the rest of your life? Pretty much the only way for someone like that to make more money is get together with other janitors. Suppose someone is 20 years old, maybe they have time to go to night school. But if you are 45 years old, a couple of kids. It's going to be almost impossible. Suppose that janitor can't find a job with health insurance because there's no minimum protection. They get sick, and they just die? I don't see how this works out for someone like that without some group negotiation - they are too weak otherwise.
- bduerst 11y agoWhy do you think healthcare is in such a terrible state? The U.S. and Canadian unions in the early 20th century are a great comparison. In Canada, they pushed the government to provide healthcare. In the U.S., they pushed the corporations to provide it. Fast forward 80 years, and as unions are being depowered, the healthcare options get worse for U.S. employees because they're not guaranteed by law.